An administrative law judge ruled Tuesday that the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette bargained in bad faith with an advertising employees union over a new contract, but did not violate the law in implementing a new health plan for those workers.
Judge Geoffrey Carter, of the National Labor Relations Board, ruled the company violated labor law by “failing and refusing to bargain in good faith” for a new contract with the Pittsburgh Typographical Union No. 7, an affiliate of the Communications Workers of America, AFL-CIO Local 14827.
But Mr. Carter said there was no evidence the company acted improperly in implementing a new, high-deductible health insurance plan, which is offered to every employee of Block Communications Inc., the newspaper’s Toledo, Ohio-based corporate parent.
Previously, health coverage for the advertising union members was provided through the Bridgeville-based nonprofit Employment Partners Benefits Fund, which ended participation in October 2022.
“Considering the course of effects bargaining as a whole, I do not find that (the Post-Gazette) engaged in bad faith bargaining during effects bargaining for an interim health care agreement,” Mr. Carter wrote. “The general counsel and the union offer several arguments to support their position that respondent bargained in bad faith, but I do not find that any of the arguments have merit.”
Advertising department employees along with members of three other Post-Gazette unions walked off the job Oct. 6, 2022 over implementation of the new health plan, which came with higher monthly premiums. Members of the Newspaper Guild of Pittsburgh joined the strike Oct. 18. Union officials were unavailable for comment on the new ruling Wednesday.
Read More
In April, one of the five striking unions, Teamsters Local 211/205, reached a settlement with the company.
The last collective bargaining agreement between the Post-Gazette and the advertising union expired in 2017. In addition to bargaining in bad faith for a new contract, the judge said the company should not have stopped collecting union dues from worker paychecks in 2020. The case was tried in Pittsburgh between July 17, 2023 and Feb. 7, 2024.
The judge on Tuesday ordered the Post-Gazette to make the union whole for any dues it would have received from employees. The newspaper was also ordered to compensate the union for financial harm resulting from the unfair labor practices and to restart contract bargaining within 15 days of the union’s request.
Contract talks must be held for a minimum of 15 hours per week and the Post-Gazette must submit a written bargaining progress report every 15 days to the NLRB’s Pittsburgh office, according to the ruling.
The judge rejected the union’s request that it be reimbursed for negotiating costs and expenses, saying the company had not “engaged in unusually aggravated misconduct in this case” that would support such a ruling.
“While respondent did engage in bad faith bargaining, the general counsel and union have not maintained (or established) that respondent has a history of violating the act.”
Kris B. Mamula: kmamula@post-gazette.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.