The inter-family struggle for control of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette’s parent company continued Wednesday in an Ohio court with a judge denying a motion to dismiss former CEO Allan Block’s complaint against the board.

Mr. Block, who was dismissed as chairman and CEO of Block Communications Inc. in May, is suing twin brother John R. Block and the company’s board over his termination as chief executive, which he alleges was without cause. Visiting Judge Jonathan P. Hein agreed in dismissing BCI’s motion to throw out the claim, saying the matter could be litigated further.

“Based on the employment agreement, the defendants must possess not only a voting majority to remove plaintiff from his role as CEO, but also defendants must possess cause,” the judge found. “The employment agreement explicitly requires that cause must exist before plaintiff can be removed as CEO.”

Moreover, Judge Hein ruled that reinstatement of Allan Block as CEO was a possible remedy.

Advertise with us

On May 8, Allan Block filed a four-count lawsuit in Lucas County Common Pleas Court in Toledo against BCI, a privately held media corporation that owns broadband, cable TV and telephone companies in addition to the Post-Gazette and Toledo Blade newspapers. In the lawsuit, he said his goal was to stop what he called an “ill conceived, resentment fueled” effort by his twin brother and other trustees to sell the newspapers and publishing company. He claimed he was sidelined from a board committee formed to explore future direction of the company.

BCI has said there is no proposed sale of the company.

BCI trustees named Allan Block to the board’s exploratory committee May 20, while continuing to support president and chief operating officer Jodi Miehls, a 25-year company veteran, as the most senior executive at the company. Allan Block continues as a shareholder and BCI board member.

The company was successful on some points, including having any breach of fiduciary duty claims against the company dismissed, with the judge saying “responsibility for the alleged breach — and violations of fiduciary duties related to the breach — are laid at the feet of the directors and shareholders.”

In addition, the number of parties included in Allan Block’s breach of contract claim, as it pertains to accessing corporate books and records, was reduced, with the judge granting a motion to dismiss claims against individual defendants, leaving BCI as the sole defendant.

Advertise with us

Allan Block and John R. Block, who serves as Post-Gazette editor-in-chief, are third generation in a family business that is more than 100 years old. A hearing in the lawsuit is scheduled Monday in Lucas County Court, with a jury trial set for Oct. 15.

Allan Block was not available for comment Friday and John R. Block told the Toledo Blade that he was awaiting the outcome of Monday’s hearing.

Both are 25% stockholders in BCI. Family trusts, whose beneficiaries are members of the Block family, collectively own the other 50% of the company.

Kris B. Mamula: kmamula@post-gazette.com