Tenth in a series
Stepping into Cummings Candy and Coffee in downtown Butler is like walking into a vintage soda fountain shop: tin ceilings, hardwood floors, an original cash register from 1914.
Even the custom booths made from mahogany and cherry wood date back a century.
The Cummings family has been making candy since 1905. The family, which emigrated from Sparta, Greece, moved the business to its location on Main Street around 1915 and the operation has been in the family since.
The Survivors
A series examining Pittsburgh-area businesses that have beaten the odds and made it past the half-century mark.
First in a series: Most companies don’t last 50 years, but these Pittsburgh businesses have
Second in a series: Mt. Lebanon Office Furniture & Interiors started out repairing typewriters
Third in a series: After a frightening start, brothers found their feet and kept insurance company growing
Fourth in a series: Brighton Heights butcher's sharp skills build an enduring neighborhood business
Fifth in a series: Real estate brokers Beynon & Co. have moved a lot of property over the decades
Sixth in a series: Close family ties, and a secret recipe, keep business going
Seventh in a series: Seven decades of success: Dorsey's Record Shop has evolved with the times
Eighth in a series: A high school dream turns into a family legacy at Bethel Bakery
Ninth in a series: Rothman Awning weathers time, and a few changes, over 95 years
The cash register may be the same, but there have been plenty of changes over the decades that have allowed this place to outlast competitors and changing consumer tastes.
Over time, the shop has added coffee, smoothies and other treats. It’s known for hand-dipped chocolates with store-roasted nuts and fruits, and for its homemade peanut brittle.
Now, the business has expanded. After opening a cafe in Butler Memorial Hospital in the early 2000s, Cummings Candy and Coffee set up a third location on Route 68 in July. The newest location offers a different experience than the historic shop on Main Street, featuring later hours, live music and open mic nights. It also is geared toward the commuters that travel Route 68.
“It was temping to open a smaller space for to-go items, but I wanted to have something that brings people together,” said Barry Cummings, the grandson of the founder. “It makes me feel good to see people there on a Friday, and provide something that brings the community together.”
Mr. Cummings grew up in the business, of course.
“I remember when we had half days in kindergarten. I would spend three hours a day sitting in a booth drinking milkshakes while I waited for my mom to pick me up,” he said. “Later, I started to help out my dad, making ice cream and roasting cashews and peanuts.”
The shop added coffee in 1995, not long after Barry Cummings graduated from Robert Morris University with a marketing degree in hand.
His father, Tom, was running the candy shop.
“I was interviewing for jobs, walking around Downtown in a suit and with a briefcase. It didn’t feel like me,” Mr. Cummings said. “I was talking to my father and told him I’d like to open a coffee shop. He said, ‘Why not here?’”
The idea clicked.
The next step was to update the building, down to the wiring. Butler was among the many rust belt cities hit by the steel industry downturn. At some point, the compressor on the soda fountain went down and it hadn’t been repaired in years.
“Then, if something broke, you weighed whether you had to fix it or not. If you didn’t see a return on fixing it, you didn’t,” Mr. Cummings said.
When the work was done on Main Street location, it was a quiet opening.
“We opened the new place in July on (Route) 68, we had a grand opening and tried to create a buzz,” Mr. Cummings said. “But here (on Main Street), we just turned on the sign and waited to see what happened.”
Coffee certainly brought a different flavor to the business mix, and gave customers a reason to stick around awhile.
The business gets its beans from Nicholas Coffee Co., in Downtown Pittsburgh, and Commonplace Coffee House and Roastery in Indiana, Pa. The shop added a coffee roaster in April to roast its own beans.
“Roasting coffee is very fun, and you can’t really take your eyes off it,” Mr. Cummings said. “It’s not like making popcorn.”
“We put the roaster in the window to create a little theater,” he said. “It’s a different experience than going to a big box.”
Mr. Cummings and his father, Tom, worked together for years.
The shop was open from 7 a.m. to 10 p.m. in the 1990s. Barry Cummings would often crash on a cot tucked away until it was time for his shift.
But Tom Cummings passed away about 16 months ago.
“He was my mentor and working across the aisle from him — he was just a sage. He had faith in me. I don’t know if he bought into the coffee idea at the time,” his son said.
Stephanie Ritenbaugh: sritenbaugh@post-gazette.com or 412-263-4910.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.