“THE TEN YEAR WAR: OBAMACARE AND THE UNFINISHED CRUSADE FOR UNIVERSAL COVERAGE”

By Jonathan Cohn

St. Martin’s Press ($29.99)

Was the Affordable Care Act a groundbreaking, landmark achievement of American social policy, or a half-measure that didn’t reach nearly enough people?

Advertise with us

Journalist Jonathan Cohn grapples with both aspects of the 2010 law and its ongoing impacts in his new book, “The Ten Year War: Obamacare and the Unfinished Crusade for Universal Coverage.”

Mr. Cohn’s work couldn’t be more timely: with a newly-elected Democratic president, pressure from the party’s left flank to move toward universal coverage, an ongoing pandemic, and an economic crisis where millions of Americans have lost their employer-based insurance, the book is required reading.

“Figuring out how to fix American health care has never been entirely, or even primarily, about what kind of system would work best. It’s also been about what kind of changes can actually survive the political process,” the author explains.

And indeed, Mr. Cohn’s account focuses a great deal on the politics of Obamacare and how politics shaped the law, though he does not let the reader forget the moral issues at stake, or how health care policies and costs impact real people’s lives.

The book briefly explains U.S. health care history in an easy-to-understand way: how exempting employers’ health care benefits from World War II-era price controls gave birth to our system of private insurance, and the fights of previous generations of Democratic presidents (and yes, Richard Nixon) to move toward more universal coverage. He explains in detail the failure of the Clinton administration to pass a health care bill – and how that thwarted overhaul and its battle-scarred veterans shaped Obamacare – as well as the success of a similar health care overhaul in Massachusetts in 2006 led by then-Governor Mitt Romney.

Advertise with us

Of the effort to craft the bill, Cohn drives home the constraints of the ACA’s architects and how that led to the final product: “Trade-offs were everywhere,” he explains. “Covering more people or raising insurance standards would raise the price of the program, requiring higher taxes, more dramatic changes to the financing of public insurance programs, or some combination of the two. Every upside had a downside, every benefit a cost.”

For an account heavy on politics and policy, the book is still highly readable, and Mr. Cohn doesn’t forget to explain all the people involved, both in Congress and the administration. Even though most readers likely will know the story’s outcome, it is still full of dramatic moments and twists: the victory of Republican Scott Brown in Massachusetts that imperiled Obamacare at the 11th hour, the dramatic thumbs down of the late Senator John McCain that dashed Republican hopes of an Obamacare repeal, raucous town hall meetings, and more.

Reading Mr. Cohn’s account – the unified Republican opposition to the law, the repeal efforts, the terrible rollout of HealthCare.Gov, the initial negative public perception of the law, the Supreme Court challenges – it seems astonishing Obamacare ever became law at all, or that it is still standing today. And he reminds us, there’s still yet another challenge to the law currently before the Supreme Court, in which any outcome is possible.

“The Affordable Care Act is a highly flawed, distressingly compromised, woefully incomplete attempt to establish a basic right that already exists in every other developed nation,” Mr. Cohn concludes. “It is also the most ambitious and significant piece of domestic legislation to pass in half a century—a big step in the direction of a more perfect union, and a more humane one as well. It is not nearly good enough, and yet so much better than what came before it. In America, that is what change looks like.”

Kate Giammarise is a reporter at 90.5 WESA, Pittsburgh’s NPR News Station, covering the economic impact of COVID-19. She previously covered poverty and social services as a reporter for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette.