It’s a story familiar to many in southwestern Pennsylvania: After massive job losses in steel and manufacturing in the 1980s, the region became a hub for jobs in hospitals and the health care industry.

But in his new book, “The Next Shift: The Fall of Industry and the Rise of Health Care in Rust Belt America,” author Gabriel Winant connects the dots in ways many might have not previously considered.

“THE NEXT SHIFT: THE FALL OF INDUSTRY AND THE RISE OF HEALTH CARE IN RUST BELT AMERICA”

By Gabriel Winant

Advertise with us

Harvard University Press ($35)

“It was not a coincidence that care labor grew as industrial employment declined,” Winant contends. “The processes were interwoven.”

So, “How did Steel City become a city of nursing assistants?” he asks.

His book covers the decadeslong transformation of the region’s economy and its working people, taking the reader from the heyday of Big Steel and its largely unionized workforce, the generous health insurance coverage workers won through unionization and collective bargaining, and the system of hospitals that arose to serve steelworkers and their families.

It continues through the decline of the mills, the region’s loss of younger workers, the economic downturn that pushed more women into the labor force and caregiving jobs, the corporatization of the health care system, and consolidation and closures of community hospitals in more recent years.

Advertise with us

“Poverty, job loss and unemployment, aging populations, generous insurance policies and well-capitalized health systems all may contribute to either poor population health, high rates of utilization of the health care system, or both,” Winant explains. “These phenomena of course may occur separately. But there exists a distinctive historical process that produced all of them together: deindustrialization.”

Winant, an assistant professor of history at the University of Chicago, is clear throughout the book that Black workers were largely excluded from the industrial era’s gains and are hurt disproportionately now by the low wages of many caregiving jobs.

He is equally explicit about the gender and family dynamics involved. In Big Steel’s heyday, the wives of many steelworkers did not work for pay outside of their homes, partly because the steelworkers’ wages were enough to sustain a family. As the economy shifted, though, the caregiving workforce became disproportionately made up of women.

The author does not overly romanticize the steel era or how dirty or dangerous the jobs were.

“Mill work was alienating and exhausting not only because of its hours, but also because of the constant, inescapable risk of injury and death,” Winant writes.

Advertise with us

While readable for a layperson, the book is a bit academic at times. However, “The Next Shift” is impressive in the staggering number and types of sources it cites, from interviews to archives, and the reader often hears from the real men and women at the heart of what Winant is explaining.

The author defines the paradox here: Workers like home health aides, nursing home staffers and other care workers are in a growing field and are essential to the well-being of millions, yet they are poorly paid and don’t wield the political clout of previous generations of industrial workers.

Winant’s book is essential reading for anyone interested in Pittsburgh history, the labor movement or the economics of our health care system. It helps us to make sense of the region and the economy we inhabit today.

Kate Giammarise is a reporter at 90.5 WESA, Pittsburgh’s NPR News Station. She previously covered poverty and social services for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette.