Full disclosure: I’m a great fan of both authors of this delightfully erudite and very disturbing story of a fictional (but nonetheless credible) plot to set off a nuclear attack on Washington D.C. I consider both women to be among the most interesting and intelligent people of our time, and they’re in top form here.
“STATE OF TERROR”
By Hillary Rodham Clinton and Louise Penny
Simon and Schuster/St. Martin’s Press ($30)
The leading characters are only barely disguised. A new (liberal) president has been sworn in, replacing an irrational despot who has left the country divided and chaotic. No one in the White House, past or present administration, knows who among their colleagues and alleged friends they can trust or distrust. But the quirky premise here is that the new president has chosen for his Secretary of State a brilliant, somewhat rebellious woman from the earlier administration named Ellen Adams (substitute Hillary Rodham Clinton, of course). Whether POTUS has chosen her for her talents or so that he can keep watch on her is an open question. “Keep your friends close but your enemies closer,” as they say.
Reinforcing Ellen’s fears is the fact that she has just returned from a disastrous trip to South Korea, during which everything political and diplomatic went wrong, and she is under a cloud of suspicion over her competence. Back home, her chief of staff can only barely disguise his hostility, while the president’s chief of staff is openly antagonistic. Ellen is equally suspicious of the acting director of national intelligence; and of the general who is chair of the Joint Chiefs of Staff. Either or both may be working for the “enemy,” whether that enemy is the defeated political party, or Pathon – a Pakistani terrorist organization plotting to plant bombs on American soil.
For support and trust, Ellen relies on her longtime friend, ally and unofficial assistant, Betsy Jameson, who travels with her and carries out many of her tedious day-to-day responsibilities. They communicate in a private code that exploits verbal esoterica: “An oxymoron walked into…” Betsy, however, can be overprotective and overly anxious to take over the actual running of Ellen’s work. Both Ellen and Betsy, by the way, were brought up on Pittsburgh’s South Side.
Not long after Ellen returns from her Korean catastrophe, she is confronted with a series of suicide bombings on buses in London, then Paris, then Frankfurt. Each appears to have been aimed at eliminating a respected Middle Eastern nuclear scientist. And Ellen’s estranged son, Gil, is a Reuters journalist with an agenda of his own, who happens to have been on the scene for one or more of these events. Further complicating the plot, a lower level member of Ellen’s department, Anahita Dahir, is sending Ellen coded messages of her own. Unknown to Ellen, Anahita – an American with some Iranian ancestry – has had a past affair with Gil and is still in love with him.
There’s a stock character bad guy, not very sharply drawn, who sells weapons to terrorists and takes refuge in South Florida.
It strains the reader’s credulity that a lot of characters do a lot of things that are so patently stupid that we know they will get into life-threatening situations (and we also know that they are likely to come through it all intact). Especially when they knowingly walk into the enemy’s sovereign territory alone and without a safety net. Also on the negative side, there are too many characters to keep track of, and the shenanigans go on just a bit too long. This is offset, however, by Clinton’s insights into the workings of the U.S. government, and the brilliance and ingenuity of Penny’s linguistic skills.
The Clinton-Penny collaboration is an extraordinarily good one, and this book, despite some flaws in plot and pacing, is a joy to read.
Robert Croan is a Pittsburgh Post-Gazette senior editor.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.