When Mike McCarthy’s Steelers offense takes the field against the Atlanta Falcons in Week 1, its aims are going to be different than in recent years.
Back during Steelers OTAs in May, McCarthy told reporters how it’s a goal for his offense to average 55 touches — combined rushing attempts and completions — per game. But if you want to better understand his vision for the offense, it doesn’t start with his target number for the end of a game.
It starts with first down.
While the Steelers shoot for McCarthy’s 55-touch goal, the methodology of how they get there will involve a plan that will be different from recent Steelers offenses. To get a sense of how touches per game play a factor in modern NFL offenses, I examined Steelers offenses, McCarthy’s offenses and recent elite offenses.
One trend became clear: McCarthy's best offenses attacked first down through the passing game, creating favorable down-and-distance situations that led to more first downs, longer drives and, ultimately, more touches.
Early efficiency
When looking for offenses to compare, I examined the most recent Steelers offenses of 2025 and 2024 and the last time they had an elite unit — 2017.
Read More
I also looked the No. 1 scoring offenses for each of the last three NFL seasons — the 2025 Los Angeles Rams, the 2024 Detroit Lions and McCarthy’s 2023 Dallas Cowboys.
Plus, I checked out the most recent McCarthy offense with the Cowboys in 2024 and his last strong year with the Green Bay Packers, when he was paired with Aaron Rodgers.
Out of those eight teams, the three offenses that ranked at the top of the league had the most touches per game, with the 2017 Steelers not far behind — but none of them actually averaged 55 touches per contest.
The closest were the 2024 Lions at 54.4 touches per game. But even the Packers’ 2016 offense, when Rodgers led the unit to finish fourth in scoring, finished with 48.9 per game — which was behind the 2024 Steelers with Russell Wilson.
That showed McCarthy’s goal of 55 touches per game isn’t necessarily about truly averaging that mark but making an effort to possess the ball and maintain longer drives for more chances to score.
Out of the eight teams I examined, McCarthy’s 2023 Cowboys averaged the most plays per drive and ranked at the top of the NFL in that statistic. The next-closest teams were the 2024 Lions and 2025 Rams — all three of the No. 1 offenses we evaluated.
When people think about possession, they’ll often look to running the ball. But among the better offenses, there wasn’t a strong connection between rushing success or frequency in the ground game. Among the offenses in this comparison, the clearest common thread wasn't rushing efficiency.
It was first-down passing.
Net passing yards per attempt accounts for sacks by measuring passing yards minus sack yardage over total dropbacks. In 2025, the two teams that bracketed the Rams in that statistic were the New England Patriots’ offense, with 10.4 net passing yards per attempt, and the Seattle Seahawks, with 9.0. Those two teams made the Super Bowl.
Early-down passing success set the stage for the distances on ensuing downs to be more favorable. All of these offenses averaged at least 25 points per game and placed as top-10 scoring units for their respective seasons.
Each of the three offenses I examined that didn’t rank among the best scoring teams in the NFL for their seasons — the 2025 and 2024 Steelers, as well as the 2024 Cowboys — also averaged less than 6.0 net passing yards per attempt on first down.
That showed a strong connection between offensive output and efficiency with first-down passing — and a big link for how successful modern NFL offenses move the ball.
And when looking at the way McCarthy has called his offense in recent seasons, it’s apparent that’s what he’s chasing as a play-caller.
Early aggression
When you look at the majority of McCarthy’s offenses over the past decade, they have been among the ones that throw the most on first down. Since 2016, seven of the eight offenses McCarthy coached ranked among the top in the NFL when it came to first-down passing attempts, including four of his five years in Dallas.
And with the Cowboys, they ranked among the top three teams in first-down passing attempts in three of those seasons.
It’s apparent a big part of McCarthy’s philosophy to get his offense going involves throwing the ball early and often. Out of the higher-ranking offenses I examined, the 2025 Rams, 2023 Cowboys, 2017 Steelers and 2016 Packers ranked among the top six teams in first-down passing attempts for each of their respective seasons.
That’s in stark contrast with the Steelers of recent seasons.
While the Steelers ranked 18th in first-down passing attempts in 2025, much of that could be attributed to their willingness to let Rodgers lead the offense with his arm and football IQ. That was a huge change from the previous two seasons, when the Steelers ranked 31st in first-down passing attempts both years.
The Steelers weren’t always that way. They were much more aggressive in passing the ball on early downs when they had Ben Roethlisberger, Antonio Brown and other higher-pedigree playmakers.
But as the offensive talent faded in the late 2010s, Omar Khan turned the front office’s attention to rebuilding the offensive line, and the offensive play-calling focused on the run game to protect the team from turnovers.
It’s clear that if McCarthy were to bring to the Steelers what he brought to the Cowboys and his later years with the Packers, that will change in Pittsburgh.
And if that change yields success, McCarthy could get the Steelers closer to his 55-touch-per-game benchmark that correlates to longer possessions and more points.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.