PITTSBURGH — Historians treating with the 2028 election need not struggle to identify the moment the campaign began: It was Monday, Nov. 16, at 4 p.m. in Simmons Auditorium in the Tepper School of Business of Carnegie Mellon University.
That’s when Rahm Emanuel — former member of the House of Representatives, White House chief of staff, mayor of Chicago, and ambassador to Japan — delivered a speech whose title likely will serve as his campaign motto: “An Economic Blueprint to Learn and Earn: An economy that rewards work and builds a thriving middle class.”
It’s bulkier but just as effective as the one that was employed in his first major exposure to national politics: “It’s the economy, stupid.”
White House ambitions
How exactly do we know that Emanuel, who turns 67 this month, is running for president? He leaked the text of his speech to the Wall Street Journal before it was delivered, and the paper updated the tenses from “will deliver” to “delivered” about 10 minutes after he concluded his remarks. You can bet that the next two speakers in the Carnegie Mellon President’s Lecture Series — Douglas Brinkley, the Rice University historian, and Sonia Manzano, who played “Maria” on Sesame Street for 44 seasons — won’t provide prepared texts to the Journal before their appearances in Pittsburgh.
Oh, yes: The Journal, with an eye to its readership, helpfully provided a sub-headline to a fawning account of the Emanuel remarks: “Former Chicago mayor is carving out a middle lane with a focus on corruption and the tax code, rather than the ills of capitalism.”
That’s tactics, which Emanuel excels at. But most striking in his nearly two hours on stage were five things:
He didn’t swear. He wasn’t a jerk. He was self-effacing. He offered perhaps the most comprehensive, coherent and innovative political roadmap since Elizabeth Warren emerged with a plan for everything. And he did it earlier than any presidential candidate of contemporary times, maybe ever.
Testing the zingers
The Journal, of course, loved the line “A wing of my party thinks the problem with capitalism is capitalism. It isn’t.” (Check number one for separating himself from Senator Bernie Sanders, Representatives Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez of New York and Ro Khanna of California and the six Democrats affiliated with the Democratic Socialists of America who were elected to the House of Representatives this month.)
There were some withering zingers (“The only people who have actually put money in their pockets are the Trump family and their friends in Mar-a-Lago”) and a creative bow to his hosts (“We didn’t become the envy of the world by favoring the Carnegies or the Mellons. We did it by doing hard work”)
But overall, Emanuel put some meat on the timeworn anti-Trump liturgy.
To wit: Close loopholes allowing companies to stash profits overseas. Raise the corporate tax rate at least to 25%. Hike the capital-gains rate from 20% to 28%. Put a four-year cap on new spending. Redirect 20% of federal expenditures on ICE to modernizing community colleges. Ban pupils absent for more than 7% of the school year from being promoted or graduating from high school. Provide free post-high-school tuition for students whose parents’ income is under $200,000 and let college students graduate after three years if they leave high school with 20 college credits.
It goes on and on. Institute a 10%-to-20% levy on transaction fees from gambling, and pour the money into an innovation fund (“We can be a country of entrepreneurs or of sports bettors”). End the war on immigrants and on immigration (“We are a nation of laws and a nation of immigrants. That has been our past and that will be our future”).
He has his applause lines down. Here’s one of them that takes on Donald Trump and his family while assuring voters he’s one Democrat who won’t institute collective farming and Soviet-style five-year industrial plans: “Corruption is a cancer at the core of capitalism.” And to an electorate that swept Republicans out of office three weeks ago in part out of disgust with crony capitalism and the Trump family enrichment program, he said: “I was the mayor of Chicago. We have a high standard for corruption.”
Uphill road
Now that I (happily) have chewed up nearly 700 words dealing with a political figure’s ideas rather than his electability (and thus satisfied the fussy academic theorists who deplore any piece that carries the stink of horse-race commentary), let’s have a look at how serious a contender Emanuel might be.
He’s been traveling the country for much of the past year, even visiting New Hampshire, the traditional breeding ground for presidential campaigns. He joked that in traveling the mountains of the Granite State on his bicycle he only found the uphill roads.
Whether inadvertent or intended, that aside is an irresistible invitation to say that Emanuel is indeed traveling an uphill road.
American politics is about (unequal) parts personality and policy. The rare figure (Ronald Reagan, Bill Clinton, Barack Obama and Donald Trump) has a surfeit of both. Emanuel leans toward the policy element, though in his Pittsburgh appearance he showed signs of an emergent affability that heretofore has been hidden.
It won’t help him that his record includes a brief stint as a volunteer assisting the Israel Defense Forces (IDF), and he can expect rivals to conflate that into a geopolitical affinity that doesn’t exist: He’s been a forceful critic of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and of the country’s response in Gaza to the October 7, 2023, Hamas invasion. In fact, he travelled this summer to Israel and, at Tel Aviv University, described the Jewish state as a “territorial pariah.”
Many of his rivals in the moderate lane of 2028 potential Democratic presidential candidates also are Jewish: Governors JB Pritzker of Illinois (the two have had a warm relationship) and Josh Shapiro of Pennsylvania along with Sen. Jon Osoff of Georgia. There’s no way to gauge the prospect of Jewish candidates at a time of rising antisemitism, but the question is top of mind among Jewish leaders if not among political professionals and voters.
Rahm Emanuel may be a long shot. But his candidacy is a shot across the bow of conventional politics. Regardless of how the next several months go, this much is clear: He has set the standard for specificity and creativity in the Democratic field. As surprising as his rivals may consider that, they ignore his thoroughness, and ignore him, at their peril.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.