It wasn’t just a good story that led to Eli Heidenreich being a seventh-round selection in his hometown by his hometown team. The Pittsburgh native became a standout at Navy with playmaking abilities that helped the Midshipmen finish tied atop the American Conference standings with a 7-1 league record.

The profile Heidenreich built didn’t have the full skill set of a dominant receiver or running back prospect — but the variety of skills combined with his athletic profile well enough that he could become a useful tool in Mike McCarthy’s new offense for the Steelers.

After he helped Mt. Lebanon win the WPIAL Class 6A football championship as a senior in 2021, Heidenreich worked his way up the roster over the next four years at Navy to become a playmaker who was difficult to deal with for defensive backs and linebackers alike.

His 1,994 receiving yards and 16 touchdown receptions over the three years he played for Navy are both program records, with 991 of those yards and six of those touchdowns coming in 2025.

Advertise with us

That year, Heidenreich had a career game against Air Force, when he caught all eight of his targets for 243 receiving yards and three touchdowns. That game had several moments that flashed his potential as an athlete.

His biggest play of that day was an 80-yard touchdown reception, during which he showed off the speed that earned him a 4.44-second run in the 40-yard dash at the NFL combine. That play showcased the aspect of Heidenreich’s game that made him difficult to cover for cornerbacks who couldn’t keep him from earning inside leverage before he got into his route.

On the 80-yard touchdown, you can see Heidenreich’s speed kick in once he got to the inside of his cornerback and outran the deep safety, who was supposed to provide help on a deep ball. His quarterback trusted he’d be there, and Heidenreich delivered with a catch and run that broke the game open.

Despite being listed as both a running back and a receiver, Heidenreich often won with vertical routes at Navy when he stretched defenses with his speed. The Midshipmen could line him up all around the offense as a wideout, slot receiver, halfback, H-back or at other spots, and he’d exploit mismatched defenders who couldn’t keep up with him on downfield routes.

Earlier in the game against Air Force, Heidenreich caught a 36-yard deep ball when he was able to get a step behind a defensive back on a wheel route. Once he got that step, he made a solid adjustment on the deep ball and hauled in a contested catch for a big gain.

Advertise with us

When Navy went up against stronger teams, those big-play moments would often come when he could draw a mismatch in coverage with his ability to line up all over the field. During Navy’s 35-13 win over Cincinnati in the Liberty Bowl, Heidenreich scored on an angle route.

He motioned across the formation to draw a linebacker in coverage, broke outside to create space in the middle of the field and then cut back inside of the linebacker to create a clear target for his quarterback to see.

Those are the moments when Heidenreich’s position alignment versatility caused issues for college defenses. It could be interesting to see if he finds a similar place in McCarthy’s offense — if he makes the team. Out of his 746 snaps in Navy’s offense, Pro Football Focus charted Heidenreich as playing 331 snaps in the backfield, 41 snaps inline, 110 snaps in the slot and 264 snaps as a wideout.

Heidenreich also showed impressive effort on plays when he wasn’t the focus but helped his teammates. Against Army, a quarterback sneak at the goal line almost became a disaster for the Midshipmen when the ball squirted loose and laid on the turf. But Heidenreich quickly jumped on the ball, and that preserved the red-zone possession.

Against Notre Dame, Heidenreich turned from a route runner into a blocker at a key spot that helped his quarterback, Braxton Woodson, break a big play on a scramble. After his slant was covered, Heidenreich turned from a receiver into a blocker and walled off his man to help Woodson’s run grow from a 20-yard gain to a 41-yard gain.

Advertise with us

But against both Cincinnati and Notre Dame were also moments that showed why Heidenreich was a seventh-round pick. Against higher-pedigree collegiate athletes, when Heidenreich’s position didn’t fool anyone or create an opening, he would often be covered up.

PFF charted Heidenreich as making 13 of 18 contested catches in 2025 — but none of them came against the Bearcats or the Fighting Irish. Against Cincinnati, Heidenreich ran a wheel route that was sniffed out, and that turned into a jump ball between him and cornerback Daniel James, and the ball was knocked to the ground.

If Heidenreich is to line up in a traditional receiver role for the Steelers offense, he’ll need to further develop his route-running skills, not tip his routes and make it more difficult for defenders to pick up on his plans.

Against Notre Dame, Heidenreich broke in on his slant, but the route was jumped by cornerback DeVonta Smith, who was waiting on the pass and broke up the play.

Heidenreich’s lack of high-level route running could be attributed to his jack-of-all-trades profile for Navy. It could just take some time in the NFL to he focus on his craft for more of those skills to grow with his athletic profile.

Advertise with us

But between his speed, 6-foot, 198-pound frame and ability to make plays from different spots in the offense, Heidenreich has the potential to be a unique weapon if he continues to grow in the NFL. But he’ll have to also earn snaps on special teams if he hopes to make the Steelers’ final 53-man roster out of training camp and avoid being cut — as seventh-round picks often are coming out of a summer at Saint Vincent College.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.