This is a story about Mary and Jane, two women, each in their late 70s, who lived fruitful lives for decades with their husbands.
They enjoyed their careers, raising their children and watching their grandchildren begin their lifetime journeys, and building a financial nest egg.
Then, each of their husbands died in their early 80s. That’s where things started on two very different paths for each of the women, and the results for each widow and her family were drastically different.
A couple months after the deaths of their husbands, both Mary and Jane were still working through the grieving process but knew they had a responsibility to investigate whether they should be doing anything to plan for adjusting their finances, taxes and legal documents.
Mary and Jane both made appointments with their financial advisers and accountants who assisted them in transferring their husbands’ respective assets into the wives’ names.
The financial advisers explained that there really was not much to do because both widows now owned all the marital assets and they could continue to be invested and owned by each widow in her individual name.
Read More
Both women’s accountants indicated that there was no taxable event in transferring their late husband’s assets to each of them as a surviving spouse and that each widow would be filing single income tax returns in the future, which meant that they could now be subject to the “widow’s tax” by not being able to now use the more tax friendly “married filing jointly” tax filing status.
Mary went back to the local estate planning lawyer who had prepared her and her late husband’s wills years ago. Her lawyer indicated that there was nothing much to do since her own will already left everything to her children if her husband pre-deceased her.
Mary’s estate planning attorney also advised her that even though the title to their home was in joint names, it was not necessary to re-title the home since she now owned it legally by surviving her husband. Mary left her attorney’s office confident that she had addressed any legal issues for her estate plan as a widow in her early 80s living at home independently.
Jane, on the recommendation of her late husband’s funeral director, made an appointment with a certified elder law attorney (CELA).
This attorney explained to her that statistically many of us (approximately 70% of individuals over 65) will need expensive long-term care as we age, either at home or in a long-term care facility. Jane said she had looked into long-term care insurance years ago, but at this point her age made obtaining this coverage cost prohibitive.
He suggested that Jane create a family asset protection trust that would protect Jane’s home and other valuable assets in the event she needed long-term care in the future and wished to access the Medicaid program to pay for this care rather than spending down a lifetime of assets that she and her late husband had accumulated.
Her attorney also explained to her that she would have complete control over the right to live in her home, sell or buy a new home as well as select investments, retain income from the investments and even make gifts to her children or grandchildren from the trust at her discretion.
Finally, he explained to her that there is a five-year lookback period for these types of trusts for Medicaid eligibility, so it’s better to get started sooner than later. Jane completed her plan with the certified elder law attorney and funded her family trust, and life went on as usual.
About five years later, as Mary and Jane approached their mid-80s, both of their daily activity skills had declined.
Mary, sadly, also developed declining cognitive skills, eventually diagnosed by her physician as dementia. She would need a caregiver daily for the rest of her life.
After another year, she was unable to stay at home with the caregivers and was admitted to a skilled nursing facility at an out-of-pocket cost of $17,000 per month.
Jane had her own medical issues, suffering a severe stroke and after some rehabilitation, she was admitted to a similar nursing facility costing about the same monthly amount as Jane’s care.
When Mary’s family received the first nursing home bill of approximately $17,000, they were shocked to discover that Mary’s Medicare insurance would not cover the future costs of Mary’s care, which could stretch on for years.
Mary’s family called the local estate planning lawyer whom they consulted after Mary’s husband died and he told them there wasn’t much that could be done to save Mary’s assets because of the five-year lookback on asset transfers for Medicaid eligibility and that eventually when she ran out of money the state Medicaid program would only then pay for Mary’s care.
Jane’s family contacted the certified elder law attorney who had created Jane’s family asset protection trust plan several years before and he explained that Jane’s home and all of her assets that were placed in the trust were now protected from being considered available for nursing home spend down and that Jane would be able to access Medicaid coverage to pay for her care. In addition, the lawyer explained that the trust assets would avoid probate upon Jane’s death.
Eventually, both Mary and Jane died. Mary’s family was forced to spend all of Mary’s money to pay for Mary’s care until she could qualify for Medicaid. To make matters worse, Mary’s home had to go through probate to be sold by the family with most of the sales proceeds to be paid to the state Medicaid agency for reimbursement of her Medicaid costs (called “estate recovery”).
On the other hand, after Jane’s death, her family met with the certified elder law attorney who had designed Jane’s plan years before. The plan worked well in that all of the real estate and investments held in the trust were distributed out to Jane’s family quickly and without probate.
In addition, when the state Medicaid agency requested repayment for the Medicaid benefits paid out for Jane, neither the trust nor Jane’s family members were responsible for repayment to the state because of the expiration of the five-year look-back period.
This story of two similar people with very different outcomes demonstrates the importance of working with a certified elder law attorney because of their training, experience and knowledge of the intricacies of long-term care, which can help a person and his or her family navigate related issues with the best results.
Julian Gray and Frank Petrich are both Certified Elder Law Attorneys with over 75 years of combined elder law experience who practice in the Pittsburgh area at Julian Gray Associates. Send questions to elderlawguys@grayelderlaw.com and visit their website at www.grayelderlaw.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.