Forget a quarterback controversy.
The Steelers don’t have a quarterback.
That was never more obvious than it was during Sunday’s 16-10 win against the Cincinnati Bengals. Mason Rudolph threw another interception — his fifth in basically six quarters — and was benched after going 8-for-16 for 85 yards with a 39.8 passer rating. Duck Hodges came on and threw a 79-yard touchdown pass to James Washington that was mostly the result of a brilliant catch-and-run by Washington. Hodges completed just four of his other 10 passes for 39 yards.
The Steelers’ quarterback play was abysmal. Take away the big play by Washington, and the quarterbacks averaged just 4.8 yards on their other 26 passes.
It’s a good thing the winless, woeful Bengals were the opponent.
No one should be surprised. Any realistic chance the Steelers had of competing for the Super Bowl was lost when Ben Roethlisberger went out at halftime of the second game. The only reason the team is 6-5 and in playoff contention is because of its defense.
Read More
Next year won’t be any better offensively unless Roethlisberger comes back strong from his elbow surgery.
Rudolph might not be the long-term answer. Hodges certainly is not.
The infatuation with Duck has merit. His story is wonderful. He wasn’t drafted out of Samford in April and wasn’t signed as a free agent until after the Steelers tried him out in May and gave him a $1,000 bonus. He was cut before the first regular season game and wasn’t claimed on waivers, returning to the Steelers after Josh Dobbs was traded and Roethlisberger was injured. He was the quarterback for a win in Los Angeles against the Chargers when Rudolph was out with a concussion. He made the one big play Sunday.
It’s an incredible story made even better because Hodges is such a colorful character.
A duck hunter, for goodness sake.
But here’s the problem with it:
Hodges might not even belong in the NFL. It doesn’t seem as if Tomlin is sure, either. Tomlin has been consistently unimpressed — at least publicly — when it comes to Hodges.
“He didn’t kill us,” Tomlin said of Hodges’ play against the Chargers.
“Next question,” Tomlin said, dismissively, when asked if he considered replacing Rudolph with Hodges the next week against Miami when the Steelers trailed 14-0, before rallying behind Rudolph to win 27-14.
“You’ll make more out of Duck’s contributions than need be,” Tomlin said after the Bengals game.
Not much of an endorsement, right?
It’s also clear why people are so down on Rudolph. He hasn’t developed as quickly or as well as many hoped he would after the Steelers said they had a first-round grade on him when they drafted him in the third round of the 2018 draft. He seemed to take a step forward in the 17-12 win against the Los Angeles Rams on Nov. 10, but then took two steps back against the Browns and another big step back against the Bengals.
Tomlin acknowledged that Rudolph went through a horrific time during and after the Cleveland game but said he wouldn’t speculate if that had an impact on his weak performance against the Bengals. Rudolph threw four interceptions against the Browns and was involved in an ugly melee at the end of the game with defensive end Myles Garrett, who ripped off his helmet and clubbed him over the head with it. Rudolph, who was fined $50,000 for his role in the brawl, also was accused of using a racial slur by Garrett, an allegation Rudolph vehemently denied.
“It was a tough week for him on a lot of levels,” Tomlin said.
In a fascinating interview with Steelers.com last week, Tomlin said he felt the need to have “some non-football discussions” with Rudolph after the Cleveland game.
“He’s a young guy. He’s new to the public life,” he said. “Often times, some things are said about you that are untrue, that don’t characterize you in an accurate or appropriate way. And when you live a public life, you have to learn how to absorb that and not be consumed by it and move on. You want to aggressively defend yourself, your name, your honor and so forth. In many instances, it’s not worth your time. It’s fruitless. People who don’t know you are going to believe what they want to believe, anyway. … Sometimes, it’s general hate and envy. … So we had a lot of discussions about that.”
It figures to be a long week for Rudolph even if Tomlin names him as the starter for Sunday’s home game against the Browns, as it’s expected he will do. Rudolph will have to re-live that nightmarish first game in Cleveland and its uglier aftermath again and again.
Check out what Browns defensive tackle Sheldon Richardson had to say about Rudolph on Sunday after the Browns beat Miami for their third consecutive win. “I hope he plays.” When asked why, Richardson got an incredulous look on his face and asked, “Did you see him last game?”
The negativity will only get worse for Rudolph.
“I’ve just got to handle it and move on,” he said.
If only it were that easy for Rudolph.
If only it were that easy for the Steelers.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.