Quarterback: After taking care of the ball so well for most of the season, Mason Rudolph threw another interception in the first quarter, his fifth in five quarters. This one cost the Steelers three points and played a big role in Mike Tomlin ultimately deciding to turn to Devlin Hodges in the second half. But it wasn’t the only reason. Rudolph missed Tevin Jones when he was open late in the second quarter, and the Steelers were forced to settle for three points. After a three-and-out to start the second half, Tomlin had seen enough and put Hodges in the game. Hodges only completed five passes, but his 79-yard touchdown to James Washington turned the game in favor of the Steelers. Hodges finished with a quarterback rating of 115.0 while Rudolph’s was 39.8. The Browns probably want another shot at Rudolph, but they might get Hodges instead next week at Heinz Field.
Grade: F/B
Running backs: In his first game after missing the past three with a knee injury, rookie Benny Snell almost registered his first 100-yard running game. He finished with 98 yards on 21 carries and provided a big spark to a running game that had been dormant for most of the season. Kerrith Whyte, who was signed last week off the Bears’ practice squad, had six carries for 43 yards, and the Steelers finished with a season-best 160 rushing yards on 38 carries. With James Conner out with a shoulder injury, the Steelers got a big boost from two rookies when they really needed it.
Grade: B
Receivers: Don’t look now, but James Washington is starting to come into his own. For the third consecutive game, it was Washington who led the Steelers in receiving yards. He finished with 98 yards on three catches, with the biggest one being the 79-yard touchdown in the third quarter. He stiff-armed Bengals corner B.W. Webb to complete the highlight-reel score. Deon Cain, who was signed last week off the Colts’ practice squad, had a 35-yard catch and drew a pass interference penalty. Look for him to get more involved in the coming weeks as he gets more comfortable with the playbook. The Steelers need him because teams are going to treat Diontae Johnson as the No. 1 receiver until JuJu Smith-Schuster returns from injury. Johnson was held to just 29 yards on three catches and the only other receiver to catch a pass was Tevin Jones, who had one for nine yards.
Grade: B
Read More
Offensive line: Finally, a game the line can feel good about. The counter was working with right guard David DeCastro leading the way. The power running game made a return too as the Steelers successfully killed the clock at the end of the game with Snell getting most of his yards on the final two drives. The Bengals have the NFL’s worst run defense, but give the line credit for taking advantage of the Bengals’ weakness. It wasn’t a perfect game. The Bengals had three sacks, including one by Carlos Dunlap in the fourth quarter when he got past left tackle Alejandro Villanueva. That play could have been costly if the Steelers defense didn’t close the game out.
Grade: B-
Defensive line: Cam Heyward had another huge day. He had six tackles, a sack and four quarterback hurries. He’s been doing all the heavy lifting for the line since Stephon Tuitt was lost for the season. The run defense continues to be a bit of a concern for the Steelers. The Bengals had 86 yards on only 21 carries. With Nick Chubb and the Browns visiting Heinz Field next week, the Steelers are going to have to tighten that up.
Grade: B
Linebackers: Devin Bush came up with another big play for the Steelers when they needed it most. His strip of Tyler Boyd when the Bengals were going in to take a lead in the fourth quarter was the defensive play of the game. It was the seventh turnover he’s helped create this season in addition to his two interceptions and four fumble recoveries. Mark Barron tied for the team lead in tackles with six and had a sack. The outside linebackers also played well. Bud Dupree’s strip sack and fumble recovery late in the fourth quarter allowed the Steelers to run out the clock. T.J. Watt also had a sack, a forced fumble and a pass defended.
Grade: A
Secondary: Bengals quarterback Ryan Finley only completed 12 passes, but two came on their touchdown drive late in the first half that gave the Bengals a 7-3 lead at the intermission. Terrell Edmunds allowed a 47-yard catch by Boyd late in the first half that set up his 15-yard touchdown catch over Joe Haden on the next play. Haden also dropped two interceptions late in the fourth quarter when the game was still in doubt. The best play of the day by a defensive back was made by safety Minkah Fitzpatrick, who scooped up the fumble Bush created and tip-toed down the sidelines, giving the Steelers good field position.
Grade: B
Special teams: Chris Boswell was 3 for 3 on field goals, keeping him perfect in his career against the Bengals. He had two 26-yard field goals, and his 47-yarder early in the fourth quarter gave the Steelers a lead they would not relinquish. Punter Jordan Berry also made some big contributions, including a 60-yard boot. Johnson is an adventure as a punt returner, but he had four returns for 21 yards, which is better than they get most games. The Steelers had a couple of special-teams penalties and allowed a kickoff return to the 31 that helped set up the Bengals’ only touchdown.
Grade: B-
Coaching: Tomlin sparked his team by changing quarterbacks early in the third quarter. The decision to bench Rudolph in favor of a rookie undrafted free agent will have lasting effects, but it was necessary to winning an important game that keeps the Steelers in playoff contention with five games left. Offensive coordinator Randy Fichtner’s play-calling, especially on the first drive of the second half, was curious at times, but he finally figured out that the best way to beat the Bengals is attacking Webb, their weak link in the secondary. Defensive coordinator Keith Butler continues to push the right buttons, especially with his young playmakers. It’s not easy breaking in a rookie inside linebacker and a free safety in the middle of a season, but give Butler credit for giving Bush and Fitzpatrick opportunities to make game-changing plays.
Grade: B



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.