There’s a thing with Cleveland and Pittsburgh, like there’s a thing with certain sets of siblings; the worst arguments are borne of shared DNA. Similarity breeds contention. It’s always true. It always will be.
The animosity between these two cities — usually football-based, but not always — is rooted in being more alike than not. It isn’t that we’re the same; 140 miles counts for something geographically, just like six Super Bowls vs. none counts athletically — but, ultimately, the pointing Spider-Man meme applies.
That’s not a bad thing, either. It’s just the truth. We should accept it, though odds are decent that you don’t.
All that brings us to Mario’s East Side Saloon on Sunday afternoon, the site of one of the most shocking applications of our premise; for all the qualities Pittsburgh and Cleveland share, “rooting for the Browns” was, overwhelmingly, not one of them.
Football makes for strange allies, though — particularly late-season collapses and bad clock management and red-zone interceptions and playoff tiebreaker rules.
So, here were a couple hundred folks gathered on the second-floor patio of a Shadyside bar, engaged in the unthinkable. The 100-plus Browns Backers were doing what they do every week in this spot: rooting for their team. This time, nearly everyone else was doing the same. (Except for the Eagles fans. That’s another story, though.)
Read More
This wasn’t the dead rising from the grave. It wasn’t human sacrifice or mass hysteria. It was, though, cats and dogs living together. It was Browns fans and Steelers fans, pulling in the same direction in a public place. Here’s a bit of what it was like.

■ ■ ■
Abbie Salka wanted to be clear: Her priorities are straight.
“I’m rooting for the Steelers, but I’m also hoping that the Browns can not be the Browns for a little bit and make it possible for us to get into the playoffs,” she said.
Part of that hope — she called it “extreme desperation,” actually — led to her to add a duct-tape “S” to her Antonio Brown jersey. Desperate times, desperate measures.
It made her wardrobe choice easy enough; she said she has about 15 jerseys, from Joe Greene to Willie Parker to Mike Wallace to Ben Roethlisberger. Usually after playoff runs, she retires one.
So, ideally, the No. 84 color rush model she’s wearing would be on borrowed time. For that, she’s relying on the Cleveland fans congregated on the other end of a garage-style roll-down door. It served a nice, natural barrier.
“They’re trying to isolate themselves, so that’s fine,” Salka said.
Not that it’s necessary. Salka, for the time being, was comfortable co-existing.
“I don’t hate [the Browns]. I feel like they’re the redheaded stepchild of our division. As long as we’re not playing them, I don’t mind seeing them do well because I’ve never thought they could be a threat,” she said.
“I do kind of pity them. I really admire their fans, though — how your team can consistently perform so poorly, but they don’t stop. And you see every week, they’re here. They shut down the whole corner of this bar. They really believe it. It’s easy to be a Steelers fan most of the time. And I don’t think it’s always that easy to be a Browns fan. So credit to them.”

■ ■ ■
Dominic Fiore is 30 years old. It makes sense that he’d be here; he’s from Youngstown, Ohio. That isn’t the mathematical midpoint between Cleveland and Pittsburgh, but it’s close enough. If Fiore were born a few miles east, the odds are good that he’d be wearing a JuJu Smith-Schuster hoodie and holding his nose to root for Baker Mayfield.
Instead, the cartoon on Fiore’s sweatshirt — a Christmas present from his brother — is Mayfield. The Browns, it seems, have found a quarterback after going without for a cool two decades. Could happen to anyone, really. Lots of teams roll out 31 starting quarterbacks in 20 seasons.
Mayfield, though — and this should be said with an extreme degree of reluctance that has nearly nothing to do with him — seems like the real deal. If there was a reason for Steelers fans to think Cleveland could pull this off, it was the short dude in the headband wearing No. 6.
Browns fans are certainly all in; if Mayfield goes belly-up, it’s going to hurt. You don’t expect much from your Cody Kesslers and your Charlie Fryes and your Spergon Wynns. This guy feels different, though.
“We all love him,” Fiore said. “I haven’t bought a jersey in eight years because the Browns always waste their best players, but I showed faith and bought the Baker jersey.”
The last jersey Fiore bought? Trent Richardson. Right now, you should be either laughing or Googling.
Fiore, who moved to Pittsburgh five years ago for work, took his fandom a step farther; he’s a member those Browns Backers, part of the team’s official network of fan clubs. More than 360 chapters are listed on the website in every state and nearly 30 countries: Israel, Ireland, Kuwait and, as of this season, Shadyside.
“Every Sunday, I’m here,” Fiore said.
The group used to meet at Peter’s Pub in Oakland. Before this season, that bar, a Pitt institution, changed hands — it’s slated to become Mario’s Oakland, coincidentally — so the Browns Backers moved a couple miles down Fifth Avenue. Now, each week, a chunk of the second floor is theirs. Sometimes, there are 20 people. Sometimes, there are 50. For the Ravens game, it was over 100.
Part of that was due to the Browns themselves; fueled by the presence of Mayfield, the absence of Hue Jackson (3-36-1 as head coach) and a core of high-end talent at important positions, they had reason for optimism. Part of that was due to the opponent; the Ravens left Cleveland for Baltimore a generation ago.
And yes, part of it was the opportunity to watch a game with actual postseason implications. Even if it was for someone else. It’s tough to imagine the scene being quite the same if the Steelers were a playoff lock.
It’s easy to imagine how much crazier it’d be if, say, Cleveland vs. Pittsburgh with the playoffs on the line — and it’s getting easier. One team might be cycling up; the other seems to be jogging in place. For Steelers fans, that felt like the unspoken truth; the Browns, as much as they can be, are becoming a team to worry about.
Fiore is fine with that.
“Believe me, you ask anyone in here, we all absolutely despise the Steelers. It’s been tough in that regard, that the Steelers have had so much success and we always are terrible, but I can see it starting to get harder now,” he said.
“Because I wear this Browns hat everywhere in the winter no matter what, and nobody ever says anything [negative] to me. Everyone always wants the Browns to be good so the rivalry is back, but I think it’s gonna be a different story next year.
“I can’t wait for the hate. The Browns haven’t mattered. They’ve been irrelevant for so long.”
■ ■ ■
Ryan Cunningham has a window seat. A Browns season-ticket holder from Aurora, Ohio, he made the trip on the advice of his cousin, who was at Heinz Field for Steelers-Bengals. The bug was planted at Christmas.
“He said, ‘If you come up to Pittsburgh and the Browns win, you guys will be heroes,’ “ Cunningham said.
So, he, his brothers and his nephew hopped in the car. They knew Mario’s was the spot — there was reserved space and fellowship and Great Lakes beer specials, so all was well.
Not that the trip didn’t have its hiccups; when Cunningham poked his head in Mario’s first floor, nary a Browns fan was in sight. Eventually he realized he had to head upstairs for that.
Plus, there was a mild run-in with a cleaning lady at Cunningham’s hotel.
“Oh my god,” she said, according to Cunningham, when she saw him in his Denzel Ward jersey, “what are you doing here?”
“I said, ‘You need me. You need me!’ And she said, ‘That’s the only reason I let you wear those colors in here.’ And I said, ‘For once, you need me.’ “ Cunningham said.
“I’ve been here the last two years for Browns games here, and honest to god, I haven’t had a word said to me. And I think that’s because they pity me. They’re not afraid of me. It sort of sucks. I want something.”

■ ■ ■
A Columbus, Ohio, native and Squirrel Hill resident, Jen Tiberio lived in Pittsburgh for five years. She’s an official Browns backer and a regular at the game watches; she hasn’t missed one at Mario’s yet.
She’s also a major anomaly; a Browns fan by choice, not birth, since 2003.
“There was a guy that I dated, and that was the only benefit I got from the relationship, was being a Browns fan,” she said.
And, oddly enough, she means it — even if you press.
“Yeah, absolutely! The fans were what made me a fan. The team sucked,” she said, “but I love the fans.”
She was talking to her new friends; Leanna Grieby and Bethany Miller were in town from Cleveland visiting a friend who’s a nurse at Children’s Hospital of Pittsburgh of UPMC. Their friend had to work, and Grieby had watched games at Mario’s when she lived in Pittsburgh. Miller had not, and neither knew that their people were upstairs. It was dumb luck.
“I was literally terrified to wear my Browns gear down here because I’ve never been here. I didn’t realize they were counting on us to win the game,” Miller said.
As they spoke, Mayfield threw a third-quarter touchdown pass to Jarvis Landry that cut Baltimore’s lead to 20-14. The Steelers were coming alive against the Bengals, too, so the bar briefly melted down. Things, like Tiberio said, were getting bizarre.
“Oh, now, it’s really weird,” she said. “It’s extremely weird. It’s a different dynamic, because now we’re actually good, and by good, I mean …”
She was interrupted by Browns Backers leader Paul Carson, who hammered a police siren and announced through a bullhorn that Mayfield had tied the NFL rookie touchdown passing record.
Tiberio picked back up: “It’s a really awesome, amazing feeling to know that it depends on you. You can walk through the city like, ‘What’s up? What’s going on?’ “

■ ■ ■
Nearby is Ben Loguidice. He’s a second-generation Browns fan, despite growing up in Connecticut. Loguidice’s dad is from Buffalo but didn’t root for the Bills.
“The AFL wasn’t real football when he was growing up,” Loguidice said.
So, he made a choice, then passed it down. His son recently moved to Pittsburgh for work and found Mario’s a few weeks ago. Now, he’s hooked.
“It’s been heaven ever since,” he said. He picked the right time to start; for once, the Steelers needed something.
“It gives us some sort of empowerment that we probably shouldn’t have,” he said.
Loguidice’s big-picture aspirations are simple enough; Like Fiore, Cunningham and plenty of others in the bar, he wants to walk around in his Browns gear and get something other than pats on the head.
“I want people to say ‘[Screw] you’ instead of ‘We feel bad for you.’”
■ ■ ■
Quickly, Loguidice’s wish came true — but it was the monkey’s paw version. Pittsburgh won; Cleveland did not. You can read the details elsewhere. The upshot? A playoff dream died on the Mario’s floor. Steelers fans were, indeed, yelling curse words at Browns fans.
So, one bit of order was restored. Another — the Steelers and Browns, consistently playing meaningful games against each other — seems like it’s on the way. That’s not a bad thing, either. It’s the truth. And it’s pretty cool.
Sean Gentille: sgentille@post-gazette.com, Twitter: @seangentille




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.