At what point does it become acceptable to talk about a Mike Tomlin hot seat?

Didn’t we just see the Green Bay Packers fire Mike McCarthy, amid scant criticism, after several failed seasons with a franchise quarterback?

McCarthy won the Super Bowl in 2010 and never returned. He won just five playoff games over the next eight years.

Tomlin lost the Super Bowl in 2010 and has never returned. He has won just three playoff games — one by miracle — in the subsequent eight years.

Advertise with us

It’s time.

Not to fire Tomlin, but to force change upon him after watching yet another season end in abject humiliation.

There’s a pattern here.

A bad one.

This is how the past eight seasons have ended …

Advertise with us

• 2011: Tim Tebow lights up the Steelers like a pinball machine in what turns out to be the greatest game of his career (a perfect “10” on the Humiliation Scale).

• 2012: No playoffs, lose de facto division title game at home to Bengals (7).

• 2013: No playoffs for second year in a row, first back-to-back misses since turn of millennium (8).

• 2014: Lose at home to Ravens in wild-card round — no real shame here (3).

• 2015: Need help from Rex Ryan to sneak into playoffs after losing to Ryan Mallett, need Jeremy Hill’s fumble, plus Bengals idiocy, to advance, then lose to Denver in divisional round (6, strictly on account of Mallett).

Advertise with us

• 2016: Advance to AFC championship before Tom Brady shreds a helpless defense (5).

• 2017: Promise the world you’ll see the Patriots again only to give up 45 points in playoff opener to a Jacksonville team that won 30-9 on the same field earlier in season (10).

• 2018: Lose four of final six, including one to the wretched Oakland Raiders, to blow the division. Finish with sickly, 16-13 home win against the Cincinnati Bengals JV team, then are reduced to praying for the new Cleveland Browns to beat the old Cleveland Browns in order to back their way into a division title (11).

Listen, I’ve been a card-carrying member of the Tomlin Apologist Society for years.

He has won a ton of games.

Advertise with us

He made the playoffs four years in a row before this one. I would not fire him.

And the Steelers won’t.

We know this.

But after last year’s hideous ending and this season’s collapse — notably in Oakland, where Tomlin admitted he could have put an injured Ben Roethlisberger into the game “a series or so earlier” — the seat needs to heat up.

The prudent move here for Art Rooney II is to keep any idea of a Tomlin contract extension on hold. Based on precedent, an extension should be forthcoming this offseason, as Tomlin has two years left on his deal.

Advertise with us

I would not extend his contract, and I would force major changes on the defensive staff.

I would give serious consideration to firing special teams coach Danny Smith, as well.

I would make Tomlin hire a replay specialist to advise him on challenges (he’s winless in his past 10 challenges, stretching back multiple seasons) and an analytics expert to offer information in game-management situations, such as clock management. Just a couple more eyes on the game. Others coaches employ such specialists. Why not Tomlin?

Rooney was not pleased with last year’s defense, saying its performance against the run was “not Steeler football.” It has improved slightly in that area, but it was terrible late in games and rarely forced turnovers. It was a worse unit overall.

Even this game, against an indescribably horrid Bengals team that had 18 players on injured reserve (then lost a few more), leads the NFL in false starts, generally stinks at football and has a person named Jeff Driskel playing quarterback, the Steelers couldn’t close. They allowed a 51-yard run to Joe Mixon with 8:35 left in regulation, setting up the tying field goal.

Advertise with us

My first question, if I’m Rooney, is this: Who is actually running the defense?

If it’s Tomlin, as many believe, then why is coordinator Keith Butler here? Butler was supposed to be a star-in-waiting, a coach the Steelers went to great lengths to keep in their organization.

This just isn’t good enough.

Veteran defensive end Cam Heyward sat slumped at his locker Sunday night, after many players and fans stayed on the field to watch the Browns game on the scoreboard, wondering what might lie ahead.

“To know we didn’t get the job done for each other is tough, because each team changes,” he said.

Advertise with us

“Guys are gone. Some guys are brought in. But this group will never be the same, no matter what you think. You just never know who’s gonna be here and who’s not.”

There will always be some change.

But after another season ends so disastrously, for a franchise with such super high standards, does Heyward expect any big changes?

“That’s above my pay grade,” he said. “I’m sorry, but I don’t make those choices.”

He then added, “I hope not.”

Advertise with us

The Steelers actually made several significant coaching changes after last season, on both sides of the ball.

The bet here is they will make some more.

Eventually, though, if the arrow doesn’t start pointing up again, there will be only one more place to look.

jstarkey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @joestarkey1.