It’s a little much to expect anyone to learn things here, in a time when everything seems unconscionably, terminally dumb. We’re flooded with stupidity, and the bits of detritus that aren’t stupid tend to be confusing.
Here we are, flooded, stupid and confused. Eat at Arby’s.
But if there’s been one takeaway — locally, nationally, in sports, in life — from the last few days, it’s that, if you have any degree of public notoriety, the rationale behind your choices as they relate to President Donald Trump, if you leave any amount of of ambiguity, is no longer your own.
The Steelers learned this the hard way. It seems the Penguins weren’t taking notes.
First, the football team. On Saturday night, they dragged each other out of bed — affecting their preparation for the Bears, according to more than one player — and took their best shot at squeezing their mind grapes until something resembling a decent, anodyne plan for the national anthem dripped out.
They came close. If you believe Al Villanueva and Ben Roethlisberger (and I do, for whatever that’s worth), a crowded locker-room tunnel threw something of a wrench in the works.
Read More
That mishap — and everyone, like Villanueva, should root for video to surface at some point, if only to see what the hell happened — left an Army Ranger, the player who rightfully struggled with the concept of staying inside the locker room more than anybody else, standing by himself.
That’s the image, Villanueva standing with his hand on his heart in the Chicago sunlight while his teammates were stuck 20 feet behind him, that led to the overdriven chaos of the last few days. Monday at the practice facility was a circus. You probably don’t get videos of fans burning jerseys on Twitter, or police reports of charred backpacks showing up at team offices, if 100 percent of the team pulls off staying in the tunnel or the locker room. (Again, someone — anyone — come up with video of the flag-wielding Soldier Field tunnel-hog. We need it. We need it.)
Villanueva explained the situation as convincingly as possible. He also showed more brains and guts than most by simply stating facts: Kneeling during the national anthem is not protesting the flag or the military. The anthem is a medium for calling attention to racial injustice, inequality and police brutality.
(As an aside, the original point has been defanged, if not lost entirely. Trump and NFL owners, whether they realized it or not, worked in concert at that one. Given that the president called a chunk of their labor force “sons of bitches” who deserve to be fired, the outcome could’ve been worse than Jerry Jones mugging for cameras at the end of a protest play-action fake, like some putty-faced, billionaire version of Jim Halpert. Still, though — what started out as a clear-eyed call for equality and actual change by black athletes has now been, out of partial necessity, reframed and co-opted in the name of “unity,” which sounds great but has no real road-map to reality.)
Anyway, things here have been ugly — despite Villanueva’s efforts, and despite an old-fashioned football leadership tour de force by Mike Tomlin on Tuesday. That would be a little less true had the Steelers managed to execute their original plan.
But if you think there still wouldn’t be some measure of outrage over the Steelers staying back for the anthem — even though, in their minds, they made the least political decision possible — I’ve got a beach house I could sell you in Idaho.
And that brings us to the hockey team. The morning of the NFL’s league-wide reckoning, and the day after Trump revoked the Warriors’ White House invitation over Stephen Curry’s personal indecision, the Penguins released a statement saying that they planned to attend their own ceremony.
The Penguins respect the institution of the presidency, they said, and would be visiting Trump, just like they’d visited George H.W. Bush and Barack Obama
“Any agreement or disagreement with a president’s politics, policies or agenda can be expressed in other ways,” the statement said. “However, we very much respect the rights of other individuals and groups to express themselves as they see fit.”
Nobody should hold their breath waiting for any individual to break ranks. Sidney Crosby backed the decision. Ryan Reaves, the Penguins’ only black player, said he wouldn’t go — but he wasn’t part of the Cup team, so that’s a moot point.
That led to Mike Sullivan on Wednesday defending what he believes to be the apolitical nature of the decision, along with Crosby specifically, who’s taken a fair amount of heat for it.
For the record, here’s #Pens coach Mike Sullivan’s entire answer to question about anthem protests: pic.twitter.com/m0ibxNaCX1
— Sam Werner (@SWernerPG) September 27, 2017
“There appears to be a perception out there that because our organization has made a decision to accept the invitation to the White House that we have taken a stance on the issue, when the reality is it’s just the opposite,” Sullivan said. “We haven’t take any stance. The Penguins as an organization and our players have chosen not to use this platform to take a stance. There appears to be a perception that we have. It’s wrong.”
“[We] have respect for those that choose to express themselves differently. I wish we would receive the same respect in return. I wish our captain would as well.”
Can’t blame Sullivan there. We all have wishes. Most of them don’t come true.
But visiting the White House is a more political choice than ever. Trump made it that way.
On a level slightly more tangential to the visiting-champion tradition, this is true; huge swaths of Americans are seeing their well-beings threatened by the Trump administration in ways that, literally, have never been seen. The less white you are, the less rich you are and the less male you are, the worse a time this is for you. “Hockey player” might be whitest, the richest and the malest job you can have, other than “Trump cabinet appointee.” “Not taking a stance” is a less relatable position than ever. Sounds like a nice grift, if you can pull it off.
Beyond that, though — and this is important — Trump himself has directly politicized the actual visit. He banned the Warriors, according to his own words, because of Curry’s “hesitating.” Maybe nobody told him that Curry and Kevin Durant had already decided not to go, or that the odds of the rest of the team following suit were really, really, really good.
Going to the White House is considered a great honor for a championship team.Stephen Curry is hesitating,therefore invitation is withdrawn!
— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) September 23, 2017
But, still — his reasons are his reasons, and a revoked invitation is a revoked invitation. The Warriors publicly disagree with Trump, so Trump gave them the hook. It’s in the text.
The Penguins, on some level, have to see the logical jump there; teams that don’t agree with Donald Trump don’t go to the White House. That’s what they’ve opened themselves up to. Maybe they’re fine with it; the NHL heavily skews big-C Conservative, and the portion that doesn’t, at minimum, is little-c. You do what you’re told, you don’t make waves, and you don’t draw attention to yourselves.
That element of hockey culture, more than anything, is the driving force here — and that element makes it a little easier to have sympathy for them. But that’ll only go so far. You can’t expect to stand with the president and not have people think you stand with the president.
This much we know: Last weekend, the Steelers tried not to take a stance, blew it and opened the doors for others to take the stance for them. On Oct. 10, the Penguins will do the same — and this time, instead of Twitter randos or a racist firefighter using them as avatars for their own hang-ups, it could be someone much, much more important.
The Penguins don’t want their White House visit to be politicized. When they make it to Pennsylvania Avenue, wearing suits and surrounded by cameras, do you really think Donald Trump will be able to resist? Do they?
Sean Gentille: sgentille@post-gazette.com and Twitter @seangentille.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.