They say a picture is worth a thousand words. The image of Steelers offensive lineman Alejandro Villanueva standing apart from his teammates during the national anthem Sunday afternoon in Chicago implied four words he and his Steelers teammates never intended.
“The Steelers are divided.”
That’s the interpretation many fans had in the hours after the photo was published and distributed worldwide. And it’s the exact opposite of what they desired.
One day later, Steelers captains Ben Roethlisberger and Cam Heyward said they regretted how things played out at Soldier Field, and that moving forward the Steelers would be on the sidelines for the national anthem. And Mr. Villanueva apologized, saying his actions made his teammates look bad.
He also explained how that now-viral image took shape.
After a hastily called players-only meeting Saturday night, the plan was for the team to remain in the tunnel during the anthem. Before the game, after getting text message from veterans, Mr. Villanueva, the former Army Ranger who served three tours in Afghanistan, approached Mr. Roethlisberger and asked if they could find some middle ground.
Read More
Mr. Villanueva wanted to be somewhere close to the field where he could see the flag and stand for the anthem. Mr. Roethlisberger and Mr. Heyward agreed to the plan and wanted to stand by Mr. Villanueva in a show of support.
But those plans were ruined. In the chaos after pregame festivities, some Chicago Bears personnel prevented the captains from joining Mr. Villanueva before the anthem started because they clogged the path in the tunnel to join Mr. Villanueva.
“This plan sort of morphed to accommodate this tough moral dilemma I had on my hands,” Mr. Villanueva said Monday afternoon at the team’s training facility on the South Side. “I stopped as soon as I saw the flag. That, to me, was enough. When I turned around to signal everyone else that’s when they were unable to exit. The decision was, do you walk out of the national anthem and join your teammates? I knew that would look bad. Or as a team, do you start moving halfway through the national anthem? What we can get out of this is that we butchered our plan to have a response.”
Alejandro Villanueva speaks on Steelers' national anthem decision
Mr. Villanueva took ownership for going against the plan the team devised.
“Very few players knew I was going to the tunnel because I only asked the team leadership,” Mr. Villanueva said. “Because of that I didn’t give them an opportunity to stand with me during the national anthem. That is the very embarrassing part on my end. When everyone sees an image of me standing by myself everyone thinks the Steelers are not behind me. That’s absolutely wrong. It’s quite the opposite.
“The entire team would have been out there with me. Even the ones who wanted to take a knee would have been there with me if they knew the extreme circumstances that at Soldier Field, in the heat of the moment, when I have soldiers, wounded veterans, texting me that I have to be out there. I think everything would have been put aside …
“Unwittingly, I have made a mistake. I’ve talked to my teammates about the situation. If they don’t understand, I still have to live with it because the nature of this debate is causing a lot of heated reactions from fans and players and it’s undeserving to all the players and coaches from this organization.”
Word had spread by late Saturday that NFL players might protest during the anthem after President Trump used derogatory language toward players and called for their firing if they didn’t stand for the anthem.
Mr. Villanueva apologized to his teammates, to coach Mike Tomlin and to the Steelers organization for not going about it another way. He was torn between standing with his teammates and standing by veterans who died serving the country.
“People die for the flag,” Mr. Villanueva said. “There is no other way to put it. There is nothing else to justify dying for that mission. I wish I could stay home. I wish we could all play ‘Call of Duty’ and not go to war. Some men sign up for this challenge and they do it for the flag. When I see a flag on the mission that reminds me that this guy is with me. That reminds me that I have to lay my life down for him.
“That’s what the flag means to me. That’s what the flag means to a lot of veterans. Wounded warriors, they have no legs. They have shrapnel in their legs. They stand up and salute the national anthem. It means a lot to them. It means a lot to me. I think my teammates respected this thoroughly. It just wasn’t communicated and the plan did not allow for them to support me or to go back to the lab and sit five more hours and figure out a plan. I thought we had to go to bed, work something in the middle. Unfortunately, I threw them under the bus unintentionally.”
Before speaking to reporter, Mr. Roethlisberger posted a statement on his personal website, saying he had a hard time sleeping Sunday night because of what happened before the game Sunday.
“We’ve had a team meeting and discussed what we want to do,” Mr. Roethlisberger told reporters. “Moving forward, we will be on the field. What we do when we’re out there will be determined. Luckily, it’s not the night before a game where we have to make a decision. I know I want to be on the field. Cam wants to be on the field and the guys in that locker room want to be on the field. We plan to be on the field this week in Baltimore.”
If some players choose to kneel or sit, Mr. Villanueva said he would be fine with it.
“There have been players who have gone out of their way to thank me for my service, arch rivals in the AFC North, Terrell Suggs, Michael Johnson, John Harbaugh,” Mr. Villanueva said. “Out of all these players in the NFL who are taking a knee, as a veteran, I don’t take offense.
“I think in the big picture nobody thinks you’re offending the flag. I don’t think anyone who is standing for the flag is not respecting the fact that there are a lot of injustices and racial divide in this country. We’re talking about two different things, but it’s interpreted as disrespect to the flag. At the end of the day, people have to live with those consequences. I take no offense.
“Veterans signed up and fought so someone could take a knee and protest whatever their hearts desire.”
Ray Fittipaldo: rfittipaldo@post-gazette.com and Twitter @rayfitt1.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.