There is outrage in the city.
Why is Keith Butler still the Steelers defensive coordinator? Why wasn’t Gregg Williams hired after his successful run in Cleveland? Wouldn’t anybody else be better? Now the team is thinking about adding to Butler’s responsibilities by having him coach the outside linebackers? What’s going on at 3400 South Water Street? Are they out of their minds? The anger is palpable.
I’m sorry.
I can’t get worked up about it.
The problem for the Steelers defense this season wasn’t Butler or bad coaching.
It was too many mediocre players.
Read More
Butler is a good coach and has been for a long time in the NFL. I’m glad Art Rooney II and Mike Tomlin haven’t given in to outside pressure and made him a scapegoat for the Steelers’ lost season.
I just wish Tomlin would allow Butler to run the defense without so much interference.
Being involved in the game plan is one thing. That’s a must for any head coach.
Correcting calls that he doesn’t like during a game is another thing.
But taking over the play-calling, which I believe Tomlin frequently does, is too much. It’s hard to blame Butler exclusively when things don’t go well.
It should be noted things didn’t turn sour for the Steelers defense with the promotion of Butler from linebackers coach after the 2014 season. It was fading fast before him under Hall of Famer Dick LeBeau.
I didn’t blame LeBeau at the time. It’s not like he suddenly took stupid pills. It wasn’t his fault that players such as Troy Polamalu and Ike Taylor got old.
But I’m not going to put all the blame on Butler now. It’s certainly not his fault that Ryan Shazier was injured in Cincinnati in December, 2017. I also don’t think it’s his fault that Artie Burns, Bud Dupree and Jon Bostic – among others – weren’t good enough this season.
An example:
It’s third-and-20 in New Orleans from the Steelers’ 32 with 1:41 left. The Steelers lead the Saints, 28-24. Butler (Ok, maybe Tomlin) has the right defense called, but Morgan Burnett blows the coverage. He bites on an underneath route and allows wide receiver Ted Ginn Jr. to run free down the middle for a 25-yard gain. The Saints come back to win, 31-28.
Is it Butler’s fault that Burnett – a nine-year NFL vet – messed up his assignment?
I can’t go there.
There were too many blown plays this season. That’s the biggest reason the Steelers lost fourth-quarter leads in three of their six losses plus the tie at Cleveland. The needs for next season became more and more obvious. An inside linebacker who can cover tight ends and running backs. An outside linebacker better than Dupree. A cornerback better than Coty Sensabaugh.
I’m going to give a little credit to Butler/Tomlin for the defense’s improvement late in the season. It held the Saints to 31 points in the Mercedes-Benz Superdome where they had been averaging 38. Two dubious pass-interference penalties against Joe Haden were just as hurtful as the third-and-20 play. A week earlier, the defense was huge in a 17-10 win against Tom Brady and the New England Patriots.
No one wanted Butler’s head that night.
That isn’t to say Butler/Tomlin don’t deserve criticism.
Their halftime adjustments weren’t always spot on. Losing a 23-7 halftime lead against the Los Angeles Chargers – the worst home collapse in franchise history – was inexcusable, although a 73-yard punt return for a touchdown by the Chargers didn’t help.
The defense was good at getting sacks but couldn’t force turnovers all season. It’s still hard to believe it finished with eight interceptions and seven fumble recoveries despite leading the NFL with 52 sacks.
Bottom line:
The defense wasn’t good enough.
Fire Butler, if you will.
I’m putting more blame on the players.
Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com and Twitter @RonCookPG. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Joe” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.