Chuck Noll, Bill Cowher and Mike Tomlin might have had a difficult time becoming head coaches if the current climate in the NFL existed when they were hired.
Or maybe the Steelers are just, well, renegades.
Seven teams have new coaches after they fired their old ones, and we’re still waiting for Miami to check in with its replacement. The Bengals have found their man, too, but haven't officially named him yet because he's involved in the playoffs with the Rams.
Common themes among the new hires: You either had to be born around the disco era or old enough to remember the Kennedy assassination. It also behooved you to be an offensive genius.
The Denver Broncos are the only team so far to hire a defensive coach to run their show, Vic Fangio. The latest trend sweeping NFL owners’ boxes is to hire young, offensive coaches, thanks to the success of Sean McVay with the Los Angeles Rams, who named him as their head coach when he was days short of turning 31 in 2017.
So, Noll, Cowher and Tomlin would have been going against the current as possible candidates under conditions that exist today. Oh, they were young alright. Noll was 37 when the Steelers hired him 50 years ago. Cowher was 34 when they tabbed him in 1992, as was Tomlin when they hired him in 2007.
Read More
As those three showed, there’s nothing wrong with hiring young coaches and it’s not a new fad sweeping the NFL. What those three had that might turn off current owners is their defensive backgrounds.
All three were defensive coordinators when the Steelers hired them — Noll from the Baltimore Colts, Cowher from the Kansas City Chiefs and Tomlin from the Minnesota Vikings.
What also seems strange is the desire by NFL teams to hire head coaches who have the reputation as quarterback whisperers. It’s why Arizona hired Kliff Kingsbury, 39, the Jets hired Adam Gase, 40, Cleveland promoted Freddie Kitchens, 44, and Tampa Bay hired Bruce Arians, 66. Green Bay hired Matt LaFleur, 39, who was the Tennessee Titans’ offensive coordinator. The Bengals don’t need anyone to school a young quarterback but they’re reportedly set to hire Zac Taylor, 35, the Rams’ quarterbacks coach.
That’s not a new idea, either, because many teams have hired coaches based on their background to aid quarterbacks, build a defense or fix an offense. The Steelers never did that. They hired who they felt was the best man for the job and then let them put together a staff to do all of those other things.
Why, for example, do the Bucs need Arians to “fix” quarterback Jameis Winston? Couldn’t an offensive coordinator and quarterbacks coach do that? Doesn’t Arians have enough to deal with on the rest of a team that finished 5-11? Or a defense that finished 3 points from allowing the most in the NFL last season? Arians hired Todd Bowles, freshly fired as head coach of the Jets, to run his defense.
Same with Kingsbury in Arizona, where he ostensibly was hired to develop quarterback Josh Rosen, drafted with the 10th overall pick last year from UCLA. The Cardinals finished 3-13 and allowed 425 points, third-most in the NFC and by far the most point differential (minus-200) in the NFL.
The Jets hired Gase to tutor quarterback Sam Darnold, the third player taken in the 2018 draft. The Jets were 4-12 last season and allowed 441 points, third-most in the AFC even though their head coach, Bowles, was a defensive coach. Maybe Bowles can fix the Buccaneers’ defense as coordinator, which he couldn’t do for the Jets as a head coach. And maybe Gase can turn around the Jets after failing to do so in Miami.
The Steelers defied today’s logic when they hired Tomlin in 2007. He was a defensive coach, yet they kept Dick LeBeau as their defensive coordinator and he basically had autonomy over that area. Tomlin promoted Arians to offensive coordinator and hired Ken Anderson to coach Ben Roethlisberger and the quarterbacks. It allowed Tomlin to have veterans in charge everywhere and for him to oversee it all.
Shouldn’t that be the way things work?
All these coaching changes should remind everyone that while change is not a four-letter word, doing so often can be.
Among the teams that fired their coaches this year, Cincinnati and Arizona have never won a Super Bowl, Cleveland has never been to one, Miami last made it 34 years ago and last won 46 years ago, the Jets last made it (and won) in Super Bowl III, and Tampa Bay made it just once (and won) 16 years ago. Only Denver and Green Bay have had championship success through the years.
Arizona and Cleveland are working on their third head coaches in the past three years.
Ed Bouchette: ebouchette@post-gazette.com and Twitter @EdBouchette






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.