If you woke up this morning with the urge to compare the current states of the Steelers and Penguins, resist. This is important. It will stop you from looking dumb.

There isn’t much to gain there — yes, the Penguins have seemingly righted the ship, and sure, the Steelers, at this precise moment, are a tipped-over chemical toilet.

The inverse was true, oh, 15 minutes or so ago, though, and the exercise is generally on par with comparing apples to Applebee’s. That’s before you consider how quickly it can go down dumber, more racist wormholes.

So, let’s leave most of that alone. The Penguins aren’t the Steelers, the Steelers aren’t the Penguins, and there’s not much to glean from ... any of it, really.

Advertise with us

Except for one thing — a thing that popped up during the Penguins’ Tuesday night win over the Florida Panthers: Mike Tomlin, if there’s any bit of Mike Sullivan’s act to steal, has to hire some sort of review specialist.

That’s nothing new; we all know that Tomlin (0-9 on challenges in his past two seasons, 2-14 in his past three) is about as bad on challenging calls as he possibly could be. For all the criticism thrown at him — and this includes the way he handled or didn’t handle Antonio Brown — that is the single, most obviously right-minded bit. He’s horrible there, and because of pride or stubbornness or whatever, he doesn’t seem to realize it.

At minimum, it’s not something he publicly acknowledges. Not that any of us expect his press conferences to turn into apology tours, or whatever, but ... it’s sort of weird, right? A lot of people go to college for seven years. A lot of coaches don’t win a challenge for more than two seasons.

And really, it isn’t even something you should expect him to be good at; he’s making decisions based on in-stadium video boards, in between doing all the other things a head coach does. Should an executive chef randomly decide to run to the front of a restaurant and seat people? Would it be worth her time to do salad prep? No and no. Bosses delegate.

The best example of the 2018 season? Probably this.

Advertise with us

Watch that as many times as you want. The Patriots are going to keep the ball out of the end zone every time.

The second best came in the Steelers’ first game against the Bengals this season; Tomlin challenged a third-down spot on a Ryan Switzer reception that was clearly short of the first-down marker.  If he was banking on winning a better spot, and not even a first down, someone out there has a bridge to sell him — because that never works. Plus, even if Tomlin used that challenge as a de facto timeout to get the punt team ready, later in the half he opted not to challenge what looked like a scoring play by James Conner. The Steelers had to settle for a field goal.

“I didn’t see it,” Tomlin said after the game, a 28-21 Steelers win. “You don’t get opportunities at replay in visiting stadiums.”

Know where you do get replay in a visiting stadium? On TV, in the coaches’ booth.

In any case, maybe Tomlin got the opportunity to watch the Penguins’ most recent successful challenge on Wednesday. This one overturned a Panthers goal to maintain a 4-0 lead and put the staff at 5-of-8 for the season. Another challenge on another Panthers goal didn’t work, so they’re at 5-of-9. That’s better than 50 percent. It’s also better, in fact, than zero percent.

Advertise with us

It’s not a coincidence that Sullivan isn’t the point man for those decisions, either. That falls on video coordinator Andy Saucier; you’re familiar with his work during the 2016 Eastern Conference final, if nothing else. (Jason Mackey, by the way, took a nice tour through Saucier’s background in December 2016).

The upshot is that the Penguins’ staff, through teamwork, delegation and specialization, are good at this part of their collective job. The Steelers are not. And in an offseason where the phrase “culture change” is getting tossed around frequently enough to lose meaning, this is an obvious tweak. The hockey game Wednesday was just the latest reminder.

What’s the downside for Tomlin? In a micro sense, it’s probably a loss of control. He wants to make important decisions, and he wants the buck to stop with him. It makes sense, until you realize that he’s consistently — demonstrably — putting himself and his team in a hole, and at the mercy of whoever is running the video board at whichever stadium he’s standing in. It’s better to share credit than take blame, and the next time anyone accuses Sullivan of not exerting enough control over coaching decisions will be the first.

Bigger picture, Tomlin finding his own Andy Saucier — and Gerry Dulac said that may well be in the cards as part of a staff expansion — would prove something else: that he’s willing to change. It’d be an acknowledgement of failure, and a resolution to improve. It’s not a huge thing; if it’s the biggest alteration, a loud, considerable portion of the fanbase won’t be satisfied, and it’d be hard to blame them.

But as a move that’s equal parts functional and symbolic? As one that, in itself, fixes a legitimate problem and hints at a larger philosophical shift? It’s tough to see the downside, but we’ll have to check the replay to confirm.

Advertise with us

Sean Gentille: sgentille@post-gazette.com, Twitter @seangentille