Gerry Dulac: Ok kids, we're going to start our chat in about 15 or so minutes, so get those questions ready .... if you haven't already (as I can see).
Gerry Dulac: OK, let's get started...GO!!
AZ Brian: Hi Gerry. Thank you for your valuable insight! With a potential trade of AB that should yield some 1st round picks (or at least one 1st round pick), should allow the Steelers to use the extra picks to move up in the 1st round and grab impact players for the D. (Moving up may be unnecessary if the trade partner is already in the top 10.) With the largest needs being CB and ILB, I would like the Steelers to target Greedy Williams (LSU CB) or Devin White (LSU ILB). Both are elite and would help immediately before our SB window closes. What do you think sir? Will the Steelers show some initiative or settle for whomever “falls” to them?
Gerry Dulac: You raise a good point, but that is all predicated on if they trade AB and what they get for him if they do. But there is no question the Steelers need to address those positions immediately and repeatedly in the draft. But, if they trade AB, a wide receiver will become a immediate need in the draft, either with a No. 1 or 2 pick.
KC: Why haven't they fired Butler yet? I am holding out hope that they are waiting to see if Greg Williams or Vance Joseph don't end up with head coaching positions. What have you heard?
Gerry Dulac: I don't think that is their mindset.
Read More
ADSteel: AB to 'Skins for Kerrigan and a first. Who says know?
Gerry Dulac: Kerrigan too old now
ADSteel: What would it take to sign and trade Leveon? If that can get hammered out, Lev for Patrick Peterson (who also allegedly requested a trade)?
Gerry Dulac: At this point, who wouldn't make that trade? Well, I
Gerry Dulac: Ooops....Well, I'll you who -- Arizona!! They already have David Johnson, a Bell-type back with just as much production and fewer headaches (not to mention failed drug tests)
PorterHouse55: W/ Alabama ILB Mack Wilson deciding to stay in school, is it same as always, BPA at pick 20, whether that be LB, CB, S or OG?
Gerry Dulac: You can forget guard. That's not a priority. And they could use a free safety too. I think Sean Davis is better in the box.
Fineline: You were too generous giving Ben an A. If we excuse his league leading INTs because he threw more than anyone we should expect him to lead the league in TDs. His TD percentage was lower than at least 8 other starting QBs. Should’ve had at least 3-1 TD-INT ratio.
Gerry Dulac: Thanx for pointing that up. Next
PorterHouse55: I read that a former GB GM said he doesn't think the Steelers will trade A.Brown because of the cap hit, do you think AB will be a Steeler in 2019?
Gerry Dulac: No, but I don't rule out anything
Scott: Is there any scenario that you can see Butler getting fired? After all the defense gave up numerous last minute drives that cost the Steelers several wins? Not to mention there didn't seem to be many in game adjustments at all? Linebacker stick in coverage against Keenan Allen not lobe or twice it was more like a dozen times?!
Gerry Dulac: Their issues on defense go beyond coaching. A lot of it is personnel, especially at LB. You don't have LBs, you're in trouble.
Jacob: Hey, Gerry. Thanks for the chat! Everybody wants Butler and Smith gone. At a certain point, when do you stop blaming player and see other coaches doing more with less? We may not have superstars on defense, but the inexplicable schemes, miscommunications, and mental lapses have plagued this team's games for quite a few years now. The constant is not the players; it is the coaches. How is this excusable to the management?
Gerry Dulac: To a degree, you are right. But ask any coach in any league, they are only as good as their talent. I'm not disagreeing with your point, but those circumstances are the rarity, not the norm. And, one more thing -- it's not always but having the best talent. It's having smart players who know how to execute and don't make mistakes, even if they aren't the most talented athlete.
jRR: If Munchak leaves for Denver, do you think our OL play will see a decline next year? Or is the group veteran enough to maintain without? Could be a big factor if the OL suffers and we part ways with AB, because we will have to rely on more of a ground control game.
Gerry Dulac: You don't have to worry about relying more on the running game because that isn't happening, not with No. 7. And the O-line has enough veterans, and good ones, that I think they will still be good. But there is no way you can lose a coach like MM and think your unit will still be the same.
Bob R: Gerry, will we ever really know what set AB off (this latest time)?
Gerry Dulac: There are many issues, many layers, to what's going on with him. But taking everything you hear should begin to give you an idea what the problem is with 84.
jRR: In your opinion, if we part ways with AB, assuming we will get a high draft pick in return, do we have enough on offense to invest it all on D? Or would we have to use one of those high picks on another Offensive weapon?
Gerry Dulac: If they trade AB, they will use a No. 1 or 2 on a WR, no question about it. I use as evidence what happened last year when they traded Martavis Bryant on draft day. They immediately drafted James Washington on round 2 because they needed a WR to replace Bryant. I haven't looked at the draft talent yet, but if AB is gone by then you can almost bet the top pick will be a WR. I say that with the understanding the Steelers will likely address CB in free agency.
Joe G: Historically the Steelers have prioritized their cap space for signing and extending their own players. As such, what is realistic in terms of impact free agents? One maybe two players at market comp?
Gerry Dulac: I think you might see a bigger splash in free agency. But, again, a lot of that will depend on if they trade AB and what they might get for him
Guest: Do you think Butler will be the Defensive Coordinator in 2019?
Gerry Dulac: Yes
Guest: Why was James Saxon jettisoned?
Gerry Dulac: Not sure. Neither are a lot of people there
Guest: Hey Gerry! Caught your post about a forthcoming assistant coach being added. Fair to assume this will be booth review/clock management specialist?
Gerry Dulac: I wouldn't assume anything. But there is no such thing as a clock management specialist in the NFL. Only with Rolex.
Joe G: At what point does Tomlin's "the standard is the standard", or "I take full responsibility" fall on deaf ears. The results/behavior on and off the field has under-performed. Also, can you politely asked Mr. Tomlin to stop including the word "obviously" in every sentence. Thanks
Gerry Dulac: I'll pass that along. Did you see the letter to the editor the other day in which the writer referred to the words and sentences Tomlin uses as "nonsensical word salad?"
Guest: Do you believe Antonio Brown will be a Steeler in 2019?
Gerry Dulac: No
Alan: If the Steelers can get a 1st round pick for Brown, do you think they'd pull the trigger?
Gerry Dulac: Yes I do.
Chet: Gerry, I think cutting Landry Jones cost them this season - hear me out, if Jones would have been available during that Raiders game and come in, no way they'd been as bad as they were under Dobbs, and won...thoughts?
Gerry Dulac: It didn't cost them, but I get your point about the Oakland game. They still came back to take the lead, but I will remind you the defense didn't stop the Raiders on the last two possessions of the game. That being said, I still would have held on to Landry Jones for one more season. I did not agree when they released him
Leo: After what this team did to Troy, they deserve this
Gerry Dulac: What did they do to him? Keep him around for a year, maybe two, too long?
Guest: Was your Marvin Lewis tweet a joke or is there credence to him being added to the LB coaching staff?
Gerry Dulac: It was an observation. But, you know me.....
Guest: Any other coaching changes we should anticipate?
Gerry Dulac: There could be another in the works, beyond hiring replacements
engle4: Any shot at signing and tradeing Bell? and realistic shot at getting a number one for Brown?
Gerry Dulac: The only way they are putting the transition (not the franchise) tag on Bell is if they KNOW they can trade him somewhere before they do. Otherwise, they will let him go. The last thing they want is another year of the Lev Bell nonsense. And thank goodness for that.
BB: Gerry - Is anyone in the Steeler organization concerned about the decline in public perception , or doesn't that rise to the level of anything to care about ? Thanks.
Gerry Dulac: They should, absolutely
ASIANGOLFERMAN: Im a season ticket holder and find the Art Rooneys silence to be annoying. Steelers are being laughed at and mocked! Do you think MT will be held accountable for this collapse of a season?
Gerry Dulac: I don't know what you want him to do -- come out and pound his fist on the table and make an angry public spectacle??? Their actions, not their words, will dictate what happens
Jacob: Hey, Gerry, why does it seem like Roethlisberger is impervious to any criticism or correction? The man throws a league-leading number of picks, and all anyone can say is 'you take the good with the bad' or 'well, he's a gun slinger'. How does that fly continuously? No one is above correction or improvement!
Gerry Dulac: Really?????
Jacob: Gerry, how does Heinz Field compare to Three Rivers?
Gerry Dulac: 50 times better. This love affair with watching a game at Three Rivers is wistful lost romance
Jacob: Gerry, can AB come back from this and still thrive in this organization? How could he?
Gerry Dulac: I don't see any way imaginable in which that can be the case. I don't see how they can keep him and bring him back to the locker room after what he did. This wasn't a Facebook Live video or stupid social media stuff or threatening a reporter or even a 100 mph speeding ticket. This was bailing on your teammates -- refusing to practice, skipping meetings, not returning your coach's phone calls. Why oh why would ANYONE tolerate that or want that type of player in tour locker room?? I can tell you this -- the biggest stars on that team don't want that type of player.
Sterling: With 100 catches in 3 out of the last four years (rookie qb last year). Wouldn't Larry Fitz be a huge addition to this team with or without AB next year?
Gerry Dulac: Larry Fitz is a great addition to ANY team. He might be the classiest, greatest athlete I've ever been around.
Joe G: Like Noll and Cowher before him, Tomlin appears to have lost his edge and influence with his players and fan base. It's just time to move on and I fear like our defensive personnel a few years back we are going to suffer mightily for waiting a year to two too long to make the tough decision to change. Do you agree?
Gerry Dulac: I don't agree, but I understand your point
ALB: Gerry, If Bell and Brown are gone, along with the possibility of a bunch of FAs, how different will this team look next year and is there the possibility of a of a major downward trajectory?
Gerry Dulac: Downward trajectory is not a phrase the Steelers understand or ever employ. A horrible season for them is 8-8. Despondency has set in with the fan base over a 9-6-1 season. I understand the angst. But history has shown this franchise does not spiral into a downward trajectory. And it won't as long as No. 7 is the quarterback. Always remember this: They are never out of any game, they are never out of any season, as long as he is the QB. If people don't know that by now, they know NOTHING about football.
JMAC: Will the Steelers look for another big receiver to compliment JuJu and Washington?
Gerry Dulac: They will if AB is gone. Absolutely
ASIANGOLFERMAN: AB to NY Jets for Jamaal Adams.. Throw in LB too!!
Gerry Dulac: Zzzzzz
Joe: Hey Gerry - great stuff as always on the chats. Doesn't look like much coaching change is coming (I would expect to it have already happened). Since we will be going into next year with pretty much the same staff, why should we expect much of anything different next year? Same team, same coaches, same results.
Gerry Dulac: Well, I wouldn't say the same staff because they have already let go of two coaches and could possibly add an additional one. I would not call that the same staff.
Jacob: Gerry, I don't mean to be disrespectful, but it seems like you guys are a little too merciful to Butler and Smith for their coaching performances. Injuries aside, their players are not performing well. They're not the league's worst players so what do you or Ed see to give them a continual pass after years of the same failures and mishaps?
Gerry Dulac: AFC title game in 2016. 13-3 in 2017. 9-6-1 in 2018. I do not call that repeated failures and mishaps.
Gerry Dulac: And with that kids, our time is up. Thanx for the questions. Bye now





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.