Give Neal Huntington much credit, sure. He stepped miles and miles out of character Tuesday by trading prized young players for a couple of veteran pitchers who can help the Pirates win now and — as he pointed out repeatedly — for at least the next two seasons. It couldn’t have been easy for him to give up Class AA left-hander Taylor Hearn in the Keone Kela trade, and Austin Meadows and Tyler Glasnow in the Chris Archer trade. He should be applauded for doing it. He did his part to turn the Pirates into a legitimate playoff threat, maybe not to catch the Chicago Cubs in the division race but certainly with a strong chance to win a wild-card slot.
But let’s not lose sight of the real stars in this rarest-of-rare uplifting Pirates story. Their names are Marte, Dickerson, Bell and Polanco, Taillon, Williams, Musgrove and Nova, Santana, Crick and Vazquez. They left Huntington no choice but to make the trades by playing phenomenal baseball in a 15-4 run, including an 11-game winning streak. They went 14-31 after a 26-17 start but never stopped believing in themselves when just about everyone else did, including Huntington, who virtually apologized July 8 for his 40-48 club and had every intention of being a big seller at the deadline. But instead of trading away Jordy Mercer, Josh Harrison, David Freese and Francisco Cervelli — players who might not be here next season — Huntington was the day’s most notable buyer, to the shock of just about everyone in the game because of his reputation for hoarding prospects. He reeled in the best available relief pitcher in Kela and the best available starter in Archer. What a difference this day was from the awful January weekend when he traded Gerrit Cole and Andrew McCutchen in what looked to be salary dumps. Those deals were widely criticized — inside the clubhouse and out — leading many fans to boycott the team. These deals were cheered in the clubhouse and should go a long way toward winning fans back. I know they won me back. I was a guy who wrote many times it’s always about next year with the Pirates. Now, finally, it’s about now.
“That’s not really our focus. That’s not the reason why we made the moves,” Huntington said. “We made the moves to get better. If that’s a side effect, that’s fantastic.”
The players certainly are on board. Harrison talked about “everybody” in the organization wanting to win after he questioned that commitment in January. All of the players seemed thrilled even if they were sad to see pals Meadows and Glasnow go.
“It’s pretty cool,” Kyle Crick said. “We’re making moves, trying to win. It’s a special time.”
I love the Kela deal. Baseball has become a bullpen game. I like the Pirates’ chances if they get six innings from their starter and take a lead into the seventh. Kela, who brings closing experience to a young bullpen, can slide in nicely between Crick and closer Felipe Vazquez. If Clint Hurdle needs a reliever in the sixth, he has Edgar Santana.
Read More
The more I think of the Kela trade, the more it amazes me. In essence, Huntington turned Mark Melancon, who was on an expiring contract, into Vazquez and Kela. Vazquez and Hearn came from Washington in the Melancon trade at the 2016 deadline.
Wow.
I also like the Archer deal. Huntington acknowledged Archer’s “surface numbers aren’t the typical Chris Archer surface numbers” — his ERA and WHIP have increased each of the past three seasons — but he believes Archer will benefit getting out of the powerful American League East, facing one less hitter in a National League lineup, and working in more pitcher-friendly PNC Park. “We believe the indicators are there that Chris Archer still is an upper-echelon, top-of-the-rotation starting pitcher.”
Of equal importance to Huntington is that Archer is signed through 2021 with team-friendly salaries of $7.5 million next season and $8.25 million in 2020 and 2021. Kela is making just $1.2 million this season and has two years of arbitration left before he can become a free agent after the 2020 season. Those are big reasons Huntington abandoned his long-standing policy of not giving up talented prospects in any deal, although he did it in 2016 to dump Francisco Liriano’s salary. It made sense in these trades because the Pirates added proven big-league players at the cost of players who might or might not develop into major contributors on a playoff-caliber team. Give me a sure thing over a maybe any day.
“We were able to give up a significant amount of talent, but yet still feel that, OK, we have 12 of our top 15 prospects still in the system and a lot of depth beyond there,” Huntington said.
“We felt like this was the right opportunity to add to this club. The ability to add two players such as this, we felt, pushed us into a higher level. It comes back to our belief in this core. The team went on a great run. It showed what we are capable of.”
Good for the players for doing it against overwhelming odds.
Good for Huntington for recognizing it and reacting perfectly.
Good for the Pirates who really needed a wonderful day like this.
Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com and Twitter @RonCookPG. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Poni” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.