In the dead of night, Neal Huntington made his first move. The Pirates general manager sealed a deal for Texas Rangers closer Keone Kela just after 1 a.m. Tuesday, and then he slept. Poorly.

So, as the clock ticked toward the 4 p.m. non-waiver trade deadline, Huntington resumed the pursuit of his primary target: Chris Archer, the Tampa Bay Rays’ two-time All-Star right-handed pitcher.

“At about 3:57 [p.m.],” Huntington said, “we realized it had a chance to be a reality.”

He went for it.

Advertise with us

The Pirates added Archer to their starting rotation, where he’ll likely remain for the next three seasons, and they pulled from their rich minor league system to pay a steep price. Outfielder Austin Meadows and right-hander Tyler Glasnow, two of their top homegrown players, were sent to the Rays, plus a player to be named later — Huntington said it is a “player of significance.”

This is the cost of doing business at the trade deadline.

“It’s absolutely tough to sit across from a young player and tell him that he’s going to become a really good player somewhere else,” Huntington said Tuesday. “But to bring in a player like Keone Kela, to bring in a player like Chris Archer that should impact us immediately — vs. thinking somebody is going to impact you in the future — those are fun conversations to have.”

Neal Huntington on Pirates' trade deadline deals

In recent years, the Pirates have arrived at the trade deadline on the edge of the playoff race, and Huntington’s answer has been to add here, subtract there and protect prospects. Don’t mortgage the future, the thinking goes, but still give this team a chance to win. The result was three consecutive wild-card appearances, then two losing seasons, and no splashy moves.

After a quiet 2013 trade deadline, Huntington quipped: “We were willing to do something stupid. We just weren’t willing to do something insane.” The next year, the Pirates were reportedly in the mix for left-handers David Price and Jon Lester at the deadline. The asking prices then might have been stupid, might have been insane — and might have been worth it.

Advertise with us

That’s the equation Huntington was trying to solve Tuesday, weighing logic against instinct, present against future. The conversation began with Meadows, a former first-rounder. He was a “must-have” for the Rays, Huntington said. With Corey Dickerson under contract through 2019 and decent outfield depth, Huntington was willing to rewrite a part of his plans.

“To give up Austin wasn’t a decision we made,” he said. “It was something Tampa had to have.”

Huntington and team president Frank Coonelly both said Pirates owner Bob Nutting was engaged throughout the trade talks with the Rays, a deal in which the Pirates ultimately took on about $2.9 million in salary this year. “[Nutting] was very clear with myself and Neal that if you believe this team is in position to push forward, there’s some urgency, you should seize this opportunity and bring in a player to help us win a championship,” Connelly said.

In a statement, Nutting said it was “the right time to seize an opportunity and continue in the clear direction that was set this offseason.” This winter, the Pirates traded outfielder Andrew McCutchen and pitcher Gerrit Cole. “We needed to get better then and needed to get better now,” Nutting said. “These moves should make us a stronger team this season and beyond.”

What finally made parting with prized prospects and young players palatable for Huntington was the fact Archer and Kela aren’t just rental reinforcements. The Pirates players gave the front office and fan base reason to believe this month, but even if they crumble in August, the roster — especially the starting rotation — is already crowded for the next few years.

Advertise with us

“We were able to give up a significant amount of talent but still feel we have 12 of our top 15 prospects still in the system and a lot of depth beyond there,” Huntington said.

Archer, 29, eats innings. He turned in at least 32 starts and 194 innings in each of the past four seasons, averaging more than 10 strikeouts per nine innings.

Archer is affordable too. He will make $7.5 million next season and has club options for $9 million in 2020 and $11 million in 2021. Huntington said the Pirates scouting department’s “indicators” suggest he “is still an upper-echelon, top-of-the-rotation starting pitcher.”

Does that make the cost worth it? Or a little insane?

“Ask me in about five years,” Huntington said, then laughed. “We feel great. We do.”

Advertise with us

News of the Archer trade circulated in the Pirates clubhouse before Tuesday’s game against the Chicago Cubs. Pitchers Trevor Williams and Joe Musgrove tweeted photos of the empty lockers beside theirs and asked Archer which one he’d prefer. Reliever Kyle Crick, who arrived in the McCutchen trade, said, “It’s pretty cool. We’re making moves, trying to win. It’s a special time.”

In the manager’s office, Clint Hurdle said deadline deals can give teams adrenaline, but wins must follow.

“It’s not about sending messages,” he said. “That, I think, is the most overrated term you can use in baseball. It’s about delivering. [This] gives us a better opportunity to deliver, I believe, and that’s what everybody’s looking for. The fans, us, everybody.”

Can't get enough of our in-depth Pirates coverage?

Support quality journalism. Subscribe today.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: snesbitt@post-gazette.com and Twitter @stephenjnesbitt.