Looking at his back-of-the-baseball-card stats for this season, you’d be forgiven for not understanding all the hubbub about the Pirates’ trade for Chris Archer.

Yeah, yeah. He’s a two-time All-Star. He’s a big-time strikeout guy. But he’s also 3-5 with a 4.31 ERA — numbers that don’t exactly scream “ace.” Assuming he bumps Nick Kingham from the Pirates’ rotation, he’ll rank fourth among the Pirates’ five starters in ERA, behind Jameson Taillon, Trevor Williams and Joe Musgrove.

Is that really worth Austin Meadows and Tyler Glasnow, two young players the Pirates have touted as their future for years?

We’ll find out in time, but there are two new-age stats that tell the story of why general manager Neal Huntington would be willing to take the risk that it is.

Advertise with us

The most striking is batting average on balls in play, or BABIP, and it measures just that. Remove home runs from the equation, and how often do batted balls against a pitcher end up landing for hits?

The league average in this category is generally around .300, and most established pitchers — regardless of their overall numbers — tend not to venture too far above or below that mark as sample sizes grow. When they do, it’s often a sign that something weird is happening.

Archer’s BABIP is a whopping .343 in 17 starts this season. That’s off the charts. Only two starters with at least 90 innings pitched are lugging a worse number. So what’s the problem?

Probably little more than rotten luck.

That’s one of the factors Fangraphs lists among the three that can contribute to an inflated BABIP. The others are defense and skill, and it’s unlikely that those are Archer’s problem.

Advertise with us

The Rays are known for their defense, and in fact, their staff BABIP is a more manageable .279. That suggests their defenders are better than average at preventing batted balls from becoming hits. If anything, defense may be more of an issue here.

Meanwhile, Archer’s career BABIP is exactly .300, and many of his other peripherals like walk rate and strikeout rate are solid. All good signs for his overall skill level. (And important factors in another key stat that we’ll look at in a moment.)

That leaves bad luck. An unusual number of bloopers that drop in awkward spots on the field. A rash of weak contact that sneaks through the infield. Line drives that find gaps more often than normal. The types of plays that average out over the course of a season but can swing numbers one way or the other in sample sizes as small as 17 starts.

The Pirates are wagering that the bad luck will, in fact, improve over the three-plus seasons that they have him under control, and it’s probably a good bet, if for no other reason than it’d be hard for it to get much worse.

That’s not all they’re banking on, though. There’s also the matter of Archer’s solid fielding independent pitching, a number that forecasts ERA based on the outcomes a pitcher can control like walks, strikeouts and home runs.

Advertise with us

Archer’s is 3.62 in large part because he excels in those areas. His strikeout rate is down from the past but is still a solid 9.56 per nine innings. His walks per nine is a responsible 2.91. And his homers per nine of 1.03 is right around his career average of 0.99.

Punch that into the FIP formula, and you have the profile of a pitcher who’s pretty competitive regardless of the defense behind him. Or in his case, regardless of where the batted balls he allows land.

None of that is to say the deal is without its risks. Archer’s ERA has significantly lagged behind his FIP since 2015, and his ground ball rate of 44.7 percent is a few ticks off from what it was in his best seasons. Those aren’t great signs for a guy who’s a couple months away from turning 30.

That said, the peripherals pretty strongly reinforce the notion that Archer has upside worthy of the hype that will follow him to Pittsburgh.

Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24.