UNIVERSITY PARK, Pa. — Just after 9 a.m. on July 23, 2012, the state of Penn State football looked like this: No bowl games for four years. Twenty fewer scholarship players for four years. A $60 million fine. More than 100 victories rescinded. An option for any player to leave and attend another football program without having to sit out a season under normal rules.
After Monday, many of those penalties from the Jerry Sandusky child sexual abuse scandal will be nothing more than memories.
The NCAA on Monday eliminated Penn State’s bowl ban, effective immediately, and ruled the football team could have its full allotment of scholarships back for the 2015 season. The fine and the vacating of 111 victories from 1998 to 2011 remain.
The sanctions NCAA president Mark Emmert once called arguably “greater than any other seen in NCAA history” resulted in a few consequential departures of players who could freely leave and a 17-9 record over two seasons. Now, the sanctions are essentially over.
“Our student-athletes and our entire student body are to be commended for their resiliency and spirit during a challenging time,” said Eric Barron, Penn State’s president. “We also are grateful for the dedication and commitment to success on and off the field of our football student-athletes and the leadership of coach James Franklin and coach Bill O’Brien before him.”
The lifting of the bowl ban and restoration of scholarships were recommended as part of former Sen. George Mitchell’s second yearly report as an NCAA consultant hired to track Penn State’s reform process after the Sandusky scandal. Mr. Mitchell lauded Penn State’s progress in implementing reforms of the Freeh Report, specifically instituting an athletic compliance program that the senior university leadership and the board of trustees oversees rather than solely the athletic department. He also cited Penn State’s improved human relations information system, its fostering of an “ethical culture” and its enhanced security at athletic events.
Read More
“Where we have identified concerns, they have been of the type that occur within every large educational institution, they have not been chronic, and they have been quickly addressed,” Mr. Mitchell wrote.
Many legal experts and media members considered the NCAA’s decision to sanction Penn State in 2012 to be a public relations ploy. The organization never had punished a member school for illegal activities, including incidences of rape and murder. For Penn State, the lack of precedence didn’t matter. Rodney Erickson, Penn State’s president at the time, had signed a consent decree, agreeing to the NCAA’s unorthodox procedure and waiving its right to challenge the NCAA legally.
Because the university agreed to the penalties, Penn State’s only recourse was waiting for the possibility of modifying the sanctions. Several scholarships were restored last year, and in the past several months, it grew more and more apparent the NCAA was going to make another move.
In December, Mr. Mitchell hinted that further sanction reduction was likely if Penn State continued its progress of implementing reforms. Last month, the NCAA and state officials began talks aimed at settling a lawsuit seeking to distribute the $60 million fine, earmarked for child abuse programs, in Pennsylvania. University sources said talks about sanction reduction also were picking up at this time.
The lawsuit was withdrawn Friday after the NCAA agreed to distribute the money in Pennsylvania, and the elimination of remaining sanctions was announced Monday.
Mr. Emmert conducted a conference call with reporters last year after reinstituting scholarships, but the NCAA did not make him available this time. In a statement, Rita Hartung Cheng, chairwoman of the NCAA executive committee and the Northern Arizona president, said, “Penn State’s commitment to the integrity of its athletics department and its progress toward meeting the requirements of the consent decree are clear.”
All that’s left for the NCAA and its matters with Penn State are continued examination from Mitchell, set to continue until 2017 but possibly ending sooner, and a lawsuit. The Paterno family and others sued the NCAA in 2013 for damages they claim the consent decree inflicted upon them, and they’re going to push forward with the suit. Scott Paterno, releasing a statement on behalf of his family, said they would continue to seek a “full, fair and open review of the facts.”
Trustee Anthony Lubrano, one of the plaintiffs in the suit, said that although he’s happy for Penn State’s athletes he believes the NCAA should restore all the sanctions and void the consent decree.
“They’re going to hide behind the Mitchell report that we’ve made quote-unquote progress and are being rewarded,” he said. “That’s a cop-out. They don’t want to acknowledge they never should have been involved in this in the first place.”
The Nittany Lions now can think about bowl games and Big Ten titles, goals that didn’t exist in 2012 or 2013.
“During this bowl ban we weren’t playing for wins, championships, or bowls but simply for each other and Penn State,” linebacker Nyeem Wartman posted on Twitter. “I love my team and PSU.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.