The NCAA handed down unprecedented sanctions against Penn State in July 2012 but in the days before officials of the governing body of collegiate athletics weren’t so sure of what they were going to do.
Several internal emails from the NCAA were released late Tuesday as part of state Sen. Jake Corman’s lawsuit against the NCAA. Corman, R-Centre, asked for 477 documents the NCAA was withholding to be reviewed in the discovery process. Corman’s lawsuit seeks to prohibit the NCAA from spending $60 million in Penn State fines outside of the commonwealth.
The Pennsylvania Supreme Court Wednesday denied the NCAA’s request that Corman’s lawsuit be dismissed, clearing the way for a trial.
The emails show NCAA officials questioned whether the organization had jurisdiction to act in reaction to the Jerry Sandusky sexual abuse case at Penn State and also wondered if Penn State was “so embarrassed they will do anything,” as one email read.
Another email exchange went as far as to call the sanctions — which included a four-year bowl ban, scholarship limitations, vacated wins and a $60 million fine — a “bluff.”
Part of an email from former NCAA vice president of enforcement Julie Roe to NCAA vice president of academic and membership affairs Kevin Lennon regarding how to punish Penn State read:
Read More
“We could try to assert jurisdiction on this issue and may be successful but it’d be a stretch,” Roe wrote in an email July 14, 2012, with a subject line titled ‘Confidential-checking in on PSU.’ The sanctions were handed down July 23. “I characterized our approach to PSU as a bluff when talking to [NCAA president] Mark [Emmert] yesterday afternoon after the call. He basically agreed b/c if we make this an enforcement issue, we may win the immediate battle but lose the war when the COI [Committee on Infractions] has to rule.”
Lennon responded that same day because he wrote that he was corresponding with Roe “only to get a sense of how off I am on what I see transpiring with our internal group. I feel like it is a bit of a runaway train right now and am a bit concerned on a couple of fronts.”
Lennon raised the question of how willing would Penn State be to accept a harsh penalty that was essentially thought of at the time by NCAA members as a bluff?
“The more penalties and sanctions placed on a school, conference, other members, the less likely they will agree,” Lennon wrote. “I know we are banking on the fact that the school is so embarrassed they will do anything, but I am not sure about that. … This will force the jurisdictional issue that we really don’t have a great answer to that one.”
The scope and reach of ethical dilemmas is something the two corresponded about, with Lennon questioning whether or not Penn State gained a competitive advantage on the football field by this issue not coming to light sooner. How would they handle future cases with regards to their jurisdiction?
“Debate and thorough consideration is central in any organization, and that clearly is reflected in the selectively released emails,” the NCAA said in a statement obtained by the Post-Gazette. “The NCAA carefully examined its authority and responsibility to act in response to the athletics department’s role detailed in the Freeh report.”
Ed Ray, who chaired the NCAA’s executive committee at the time and is the president of Oregon State University, exchanged emails with Roe July 12 when he wrote, “The sounds of silence are not good. If Penn State could have Louis Freeh conduct an investigation over the last year, why haven’t we done anything?”
The email exchange carries through July 21 when Roe was working on the wording of the news release the NCAA would issue to announce the sanctions. Ray would be at the news conference, standing at a podium to represent the president and chancellors.
Deciding on word choice and explanations for such penalties, including the vacated wins, was described in emails from Roe to the NCAA’s vice president of communications, Bob Williams.
“In this case, vacation of the wins is the right move because … Penn State had great success on the field from 1998-2012 and those wins were based on a pristine image which was a lie,” Roe wrote. “As a result, those wins need to be taken away.”
In a response issued Wednesday afternoon, the NCAA stated there is nothing unusual about the emails:
“Debate and thorough consideration is central in any organization, and that clearly is reflected in the selectively released emails. The national office staff routinely provides information and counsel to the membership on tough issues,” the NCAA stated.
In September, Penn State’s bowl ban was lifted two years early, making the Lions eligible for postseason play. The team also will return to a full allotment of 85 scholarships next season, something that wasn’t expected to happen until 2016. The ban was lifted early, stemming from Penn State’s progress to meet the recommendations set forward to make the university a stronger institution.
“We find it deeply disturbing that NCAA officials in leadership positions would consider bluffing one of their member institutions, Penn State, to accept sanctions outside of their normal investigative and enforcement process,” Penn State president Eric Barron and Keith Masser, Chairman of the Board of Trustees, said Wednesday night in a statement.
“We are considering our options. It is important to understand, however, that Penn State is in the midst of a number of legal and civil cases associated with these matters. ... Penn State’s commitment to the fight against child abuse and to the implementation of best practice governance, ethics and compliance programs and policies remains steadfast.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.