UNIVERSITY PARK, Pa. — Less than a week after Penn State was granted relief from the NCAA sanctions, a Centre County judge ruled the Paterno family has the standing to challenge the consent decree but also removed several of the plaintiffs from the case, including active members of Penn State’s board of trustees.

In a decision that was released Thursday afternoon, Common Pleas Judge John Leete sided with the plaintiffs in seven of the 10 objections filed by the NCAA.

Foremost among them was the ability to legally challenge the consent decree, the basis for all of the NCAA’s sanctions.

Judge Leete ruled the Paterno family could challenge it based on the family’s argument that was “imposed through an illegal and unauthorized exercise” and from the language used in the consent decree.

Advertise with us

“The alleged harm does not come from an action, duty or relationship resulting from the Consent Decree, but instead from the language of the document itself,” Judge Leete wrote. “The Court finds this distinguishing characteristic alone also warrants Plaintiffs’ standing to challenge the Consent Decree.”

But the Paterno estate will now be fighting this lawsuit largely on its own. Because a charge of civil conspiracy was removed by Judge Leete, the only remaining plaintiffs are the Paterno estate, Jay Paterno, former trustee Al Clemens and former assistant coach Bill Kenney.

All other plaintiffs, including trustees Anthony Lubrano, Adam Taliaferro and Ryan McCombie, were only alleging civil conspiracy and were therefore removed from the suit.