Welcome to the Pitt mailbag, where the Post-Gazette reporters Noah Hiles and Chris Carter answer all of your questions about the Panthers. If you have a question, tweet them at @_Noahhiles and @Cartercritiques or email them at nhiles@post-gazette.com and ccarter@post-gazette.com. Noah and Chris will answer your questions in full length each Tuesday on YouTube. You can read the condensed version of the discussion below.
Alex: For a lack of a better way to put it, Is Pitt screwed when it comes to conference realignment?
Hiles: No, Pitt isn’t screwed because the ACC isn’t going anywhere. Plenty of lawyers have looked at the league’s grand-of-rights long before it was reported by Sports Illustrated last week. If a loophole couldn’t be found before, it’s not going to just show up now. The “Magnificent 7” were simply trying to light a fire under someone’s — really anyone’s — rear end, in hopes that they can find a way to make more money from this current media deal they’re stuck in until 2036.
Carter: Just to give a different answer, I think if the ACC were to ever dissolve, Pitt would find a home. Just because teams are in the “Magnificent 7” doesn’t mean their athletic programs are more attractive or lucrative than Pitt, especially Pitt football. I think the Panthers have established themselves as, at the very least, a respectable brand in the college football space. That would make them a decent addition for a few conferences, although, like Noah said, the ACC isn’t going anywhere.
Donnie: If you could pick a new conference for Pitt, which one would it be?
Hiles: Well, if I had to pick a new home for Pitt it would be the Big Ten. It makes the most sense geographically — although maybe not as much now that USC and UCLA are joining the league — and it would reignite the rivalry with Penn State. Heather Lyke has a ton of Big Ten connections, and I’m sure she wouldn’t mind getting in on that $70 million annual payout from the league’s new media deal that kicks in next year. If I had to pick another league, I’d say we should just recreate the old Big East. Bring back Pitt, West Virginia, Syracuse, Louisville, Cincinnati, Virginia Tech and a few other schools and have a small football league paired with an already strong basketball league. It would be horrible for Pitt financially, but it would bring back a ton of childhood memories for me, and that’s what really counts.
Read More
Carter: The Big Ten is the obvious play here. Pitt’s academics would make it a great fit, in addition to all the reasons Noah listed. I also think Pitt football specifically would benefit in the Big Ten because of its playing style. It seems like Pitt’s identity is being able to play great defense and run the football, which is similar to what we see from teams like Michigan State, Wisconsin, Iowa, etc. While I don’t think the Panthers would be able to compete against Ohio State, Michigan or, at least now, even Penn State, I do think they could be on that next tier of 8-to-9 win teams, which would be quite a statement in that league.
Sammy: Who needs to have the biggest breakout year for Pitt football to make the ACC championship game?
Hiles: I’ll just take the easy answer and go with the most important position. If Phil Jurkovec is Pitt’s best player next season, the Panthers will be a 10-win team. Pitt wasn’t far away from making it to another ACC title game last fall despite very poor quarterback play. I expect Jurkovec to be an upgrade, but if he can emerge as a true star, similar to how Kenny Pickett did in his final season with the Panthers, I think it’s fair to expect the team to experience similar success.
Carter: I’ll go on the opposite end of the football and pick Dayon Hayes. Pitt is losing a ton of production up front, which is the heart and soul of the team. If they can’t get a push against opposing offenses, they’re in trouble. The roster seems to have plenty of good breakout season candidates, but Hayes, I think, stands above the rest. He was expected to be a star when Pitt landed him out of high school. He had to wait his turn and the time has now come for him to be the top guy. If that can happen, I think Pitt will once again have a strong defense, which it will need against the offenses on its schedule.
CentVikes: While Coach Capel has added two players in the portal, it appears he is struggling to land another veteran guard and there hasn’t even been any mention of getting the more physical defender/rebounder many people felt he needed. He didn’t get Greg Elliott until mid-May last year, so perhaps he can pull a rabbit out of the hat again, even as most of the top portal guys are already committed. But if he doesn’t land someone soon, do you think he’ll just “bank” those two open scholarships to use for the Class of 2024?
Hiles: Well, you submitted this question about seven hours prior to Papa Kante announcing his commitment, which kind of answers your question for me. Kante not only fills a scholarship spot, but helps add depth and, more importantly, physicality down low. Pitt still has a very young team, so that final scholarship has to go to a veteran in the backcourt. I’m not sure who ends up getting that last scholarship, but overall, Kante’s commitment makes this offseason look much better for Capel and his staff.
Carter: This just goes to show that no one truly knows what Jeff Capel has up his sleeve. Just when you think nothing is happening, news like this surfaces. It happened last year with Dior Johnson. It happened a few summers ago with Will Jeffress. Kante is a huge addition. He’s young, but his talent makes Pitt better both now and years into the future. In addition to being interested in seeing where that last scholarship goes, I’m also curious to see how all these pieces fit together. There is a lot of talent. If they can build chemistry, this team should be just as competitive as last year, if not more.
Craig: What Pitt coach would you invite to your memorial day party and why?
Hiles: If I want someone to help run the show — controlling the grill, bringing food, etc. — I’m picking Pat Narduzzi. He seems like a guy who would be great at a cookout if you give him a task. If I’m going with someone who can just provide excellent vibes, I’m going with receivers coach Tiquan Underwood. He’s a guy who is always seemingly in high spirits, I’d trust him to control the music and I know he’d be able to hold a great conversation with anyone. However, my first overall pick, due to versatility, is Tim O’Toole. I feel like you get a little bit of everything with Tim — he can control the grill, he can entertain, he can adapt to whatever vibe you need.
Carter: My pick would be Jeff Capel, especially if they’re bringing a dish. Jeff has a classy taste, so I know he’d bring some excellent food. I also know he loves wine, so that makes me want to give him the invite even more. My second pick would be coach Underwood, because like Noah said, he provides the best vibes. He’d be a great time for everyone.
Thank you all for following along! Be sure to send questions on twitter to @_Noahhiles and @Cartercritiques or email them at nhiles@post-gazette.com and ccarter@post-gazette.com. And subscribe to our FREE daily all-sports newsletter, PG Sports Feed.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.