Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Lee Lacy and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions …
Mark, @Markvg31V: On a scale of one to incrinculent, how would you rate Shelton's, Sullivan's, and Tomlin's job of most recent?
Starkey: Much as I appreciate you incorporating “incrinculent” into the conversation, Dr. Mark, I’ll stick to a traditional grading scale (based on most recent season).
Envelopes please ...
Mike Tomlin — C
Mike Sullivan — D
Read More
Derek Shelton — B+
And if I might interject with two more …
Pat Narduzzi: — C
Jeff Capel: — A
I suppose you want me to elaborate, so let’s take ’em one at a time.
The Steelers were expected to be a mediocre, eight- or nine-win team, and that is precisely what Tomlin delivered. That’s a ‘C’ on any report card. Nice finish against horrible teams, but that simply did not make up for the horrendous start. And Kenny Pickett should have been installed as the starter the second he arrived on campus, just as Joe Burrow was in Cincinnati.
The Penguins were expected to make the playoffs, as usual, and failed. So maybe a ‘D’ is one grade too high. It isn’t all on Sullivan, of course, but his stubbornness in sticking with his system no matter the personnel on hand is hurting him. And I can’t help but notice how many ex-Penguins are flourishing elsewhere. Were some of them misused by the coach here?
Shelton has his team tied for first place, despite some recent massive struggles. And his team is the Pittsburgh Pirates. His grade, however, is incomplete. He has about three more semesters plus final exams ahead.
Narduzzi gets a ‘C’ because his team underachieved last season. Remember, there was talk of championships at Pitt before the season. It wasn’t all bad, but it certainly wasn’t that.
Capel had the best season of any Pittsburgh coach — Shelton pending — by turning a seemingly lost basketball team into one that actually won an NCAA tournament game (or two, depending on your definition). That’s why he gets an ‘A.’
Jim Masterson, @Bat_Mastersonn: Has Narduzzi turned the corner on the recruiting front - is he attracting higher caliber players?
Starkey: I’m no recruiting expert, Bat Man, but based on stories like this one from colleague Noah Hiles, it would be appear that Pat Narduzzi has a chance for a spectacular 2023 class.
By the way, the last Vegas line I saw on Pitt was 6.5 wins. Even though they sustained heavy losses, they appear to have some young talent on the way and a fairly favorable schedule. I’d go over.
Martin, @martindrgz1986: Hello Joe … hope you are doing fine… How long do you foresee Tomlin coaching the Steelers if they don’t have a deep playoff run in the next seasons?
Starkey: As long as he wants.
Bobby, @BuStA607: Thoughts on the new MLB schedule? Seems odd the Pirates haven't played the Brewers or Cubs yet.
Starkey: I don’t mind it, Dr. Bob. In case people aren’t aware, there were major changes to MLB’s schedule this season.
To wit:
— The number of divisional games for each team decreases from 76 to 52, so each team faces each divisional opponent 13 times across four series.
—Interleague games take a dramatic rise, from 20 to 46.
Like I said, I’d rather face a variety of teams than stay mostly in the NL Central, although MLB designating the Pirates’ “natural rival” outside the division as the Detroit Tigers is laughable. It should be Cleveland.
Yinzersaurus, @jbfrompgh: What are the NHL playoffs telling you about the NHL regular season?
Starkey: Same as ever — that it only matters to get to the playoffs. It’s not like the Penguins were Presidents Trophy winners when they went on to win Cups.
Justin Belback, @AKAFloyd: Are the Steelers being overhyped by Pittsburgh media, or do they have a real shot at making the playoffs? It doesn’t matter how many former defensive captains they sign (3), or how good the draft was. They aren’t going anywhere unless Pickett takes a massive leap in year 2.
Starkey: I agree with the last part of your statement, Dr. Belback: They aren’t going anywhere unless Pickett takes a massive leap. Of course they have a real shot at the playoffs. They won nine games last year, had a good draft (apparently) and have an extremely favorable schedule. If you gave every team in the NFL a chance to write down the five opponents they’d most like to play, they would all put down Houston, Arizona and Indianapolis. The Rams might make that list, too. The Steelers have all four.
JSE, @SoTexSteelr4Evr: With all the additions to this Steelers team, will they have enough time to gel and make the playoffs this year? The offense line got it together a little too late last year.
Starkey: See answer above, Dr. JSE, and also consider this: The Cincinnati Bengals brought in a bunch of new players on defense two years ago and made the Super Bowl that year. There is plenty of time to “gel” over a 17-game season. But as our previous caller mentioned, the quarterback is going to be kind of important.
Mark, @Markvg31V: Which do you think will have better Pittsburgh ratings this year, the NBA or NHL playoffs? The NBA has been more exciting in this house.
Starkey: I do not have those numbers in front of me, Dr. Mark, but I would imagine it’s the NBA. This is not really a hockey town as much as it is a Penguins town — and not really a Penguins town if the Penguins aren’t winning.
CryptoZach, @zpenguins68: Going into next Steelers season, which unit will be the one winning them the most games, and which will we complain the most about: the offense or the defense?
Starkey: I’ll say this much, Dr. CryptoZach — the defense better be the superior unit. It remains one of the highest-paid units in the NFL. It has the star power. It better be a top-five defense. Anything less really would be unacceptable.
Brian Blaze, @B_ri_Blaze: Joe, have you seen how historically bad the Oakland A's have been this year? They only have 10 wins, -168 run differential, and record low attendance (one game only drew 3,400 fans). They may be having one of the worst seasons ever! It's the opposite of incrinculent.
Starkey: Which would simply be “crinclulent,” Dr. Blaze, and who would disagree? The A’s are historically horrendous, by design, as they prepare to flee Oakland.
Philip Clarke, @pfclarke1970: Kyle Dubas is no longer the GM of the Leafs. Does he deserve a shot as the Pens new GM?
Starkey: He deserves an interview, for sure, Dr. Clarke, assuming he has interest in the job. That said, I’m not quite as enamored as some with Dubas’s resume.
Angerman, @_Angerman_: Can we end the “if the Penguins made the playoffs they could have gone on a run” baloney? A 2022 Presidents Trophy winning club that has speed, tenacity, forechecking and a former Vezina winner that’s found himself vs. … I mean come on.
Starkey: I’m not really in that camp this year, Angerman. I was in that camp the past two seasons. And I believe that if it had not been for extreme goaltending situations (like being forced to use Mr. Pork and Broccoli), the Penguins could have made a run. Not this year, though. They simply weren’t good enough.
Pittsburgh Sound, @412commenter: Where does coining the term “increnculent" rank in your all-time list of achievements?
Starkey: It’s spelled “incrinculent,” and probably No. 1, Dr. Sound. What a wonderful question — and if you listened to the Pirates pregame show on 93.7 The Fan on Monday, you heard host Dan Zangrilli use the term.
I’m very proud of that.
Thank you, kiddies. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com). And subscribe to our FREE daily all-sports newsletter, PG Sports Feed.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.