I’ve never been more than a casual fan of professional wrestling, but I’ve always been a sucker for a good quote.
WWE Superstars routinely provide us with memorable one-liners. One of them popped into my head as I watched Carmen Mlodzinski struggle through his start Monday evening.
I thought about Mlodzinski’s 2026 campaign as a whole, the mixed results and drama it has produced. I pondered how the Pirates should approach him heading into the offseason. That’s when I heard the iconic voice of Dwayne “The Rock” Johnson pop into my head.
“Know your role and shut your mouth,” the People’s Champion would say.
Yep, that is indeed the message.
I’ll say this about Mlodzinski: He has ambition, which is an admirable quality.
Read More
There’s nothing wrong with having goals, especially in a professional setting. I will never begrudge another individual for wanting a better opportunity — as long as it’s handled with the correct approach.
Such desires can create an occasional sticky situation in the world of sports. Athletes are tasked with finding an ideal balance between what’s best for themselves and what’s best for the team. Like anyone else, they’re entitled to chase something bigger.
These are some of the most confident individuals on the planet. They believe a bigger role will not only benefit them personally but will also contribute more toward the collective role: winning.
Again, this is a very good mentality at its core — as long as that individual delivers. That just hasn’t been the case when it comes to Mlodzinski. Year after year, he’s lobbied for the same opportunity: to be a starting pitcher. And just about every time, he’s failed to deliver.
Sometimes the bosses are correct. It’s a harsh truth few of us like to admit, but it’s a reality Mlodzinski must learn to accept.
Mlodzinski has pitched 108 2/3 career innings as a starting pitcher. He has a 5.13 ERA over that span. Opposing hitters are batting 30% above league average against him as a starter, per Baseball Reference.
Now compare that to his duties in relief. Despite a heftier workload (179 2/3 innings), his career ERA as a reliever is 2.55. Per Baseball Reference, opposing batters are hitting 20% below league average against Mlodzinski whenever he enters a game out of the bullpen.
The Pirates knew what Mlodzinski was all along. They recognized his potential and selected him 31st overall in the 2020 draft. They attempted to develop him, but Mlodzinski pushed back. He wanted to pitch his way in the minor leagues, which forced the Pirates to pivot.
They turned him into a relief pitcher — a pretty darn good one, too. He reached the major leagues before anyone else in the Pirates’ 2020 draft class. He established himself as a reliable bullpen arm, someone who could be used in multiple ways to help the team win.
We all know what happened next.
After two strong years in the major leagues, Mlodzinski wanted more. He demanded an opportunity to start games. The Pirates granted his wish in spring training of 2025. He made the rotation by default. There were better options, but they were either injured or preemptively assigned to Triple-A due to a strict development plan.
Mlodzinski did nothing with his first opportunity. He struggled mightily when facing the order for a second time. Once the alternative options became available, he found himself in Triple-A and then back in the major league bullpen not long after.
A similar opportunity surfaced this year.
To Mlodzinski’s credit, he pitched better as a starter throughout April and May. But when Jared Jones was ready to return, it was rather clear who would be the odd man out. Jones was the better option, a far more valuable asset with much higher upside. Mlodzinski, meanwhile, was the perfect fit to address the team’s greatest need: right-handed relief pitching.
While disappointing, it could’ve been a win for all if Mlodzinski handled it correctly. But he didn’t.
“Obviously just excited to have Jared [Jones] back with us,” Mlodzinski said on May 29. “I can honestly say I’m just still communicating with the organization and the people in my corner, whether that’s my family or my agency, about what is next. I really don’t have any comments after that.”
The Pirates danced around Mlodzinski’s ego for the next few months. Rather than using him the way they should have — the way the team needed him to be deployed — they kept him on a strict routine. As the bullpen continued to cost the Pirates games, Mlodzinski watched from afar on most nights, waiting for another shot at the rotation.
That shot arrived in August. Mitch Keller suffered a season-ending injury. The Pirates moved Mlodzinski back to the role he always desired. The team had addressed the bullpen at the trade deadline. They now needed him to contribute as a starter, to provide some stability, some value the way he always claimed he could.
This was another opportunity, his third in the last two years. And the results have been laughably bad.
“I hope he’s not putting too much pressure on himself, trying to do more than he’s capable of,” manager Don Kelly said after Monday’s loss. “I don’t know the answer to that.”
There’s plenty of blame to go around for this disappointing Pirates season. Mlodzinski’s name isn’t at the top of the list, but it certainly should be included. It's worth wondering how things would’ve gone if he had simply embraced the bullpen, if he had taken on a high-leverage role in June, when this team was still in the hunt.
Would they have won a few more games? Would they have built a bigger cushion, thus perhaps lessening the blow of their post-break skid? We will never truly know.
What we do know is Mlodzinski simply isn’t a capable major league starting pitcher, at least not when the Pirates really need him to be. He is, however, a solid reliever — one who can help a team win a lot of games, one who could still demand plenty of money in free agency if he truly embraces pitching in high-leverage spots.
That should be his focus heading into the offseason. No more lobbying for a spot in the rotation. No more drama. After the way things unfolded in 2026, Mlodzinski would do best to adhere to the Rock’s advice.
He’s had his chances. He failed.
It’s time for him to know his role and keep his mouth shut.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.