Colin Beazley: Good morning and welcome to another live Pirates chat! I'm a year older since the last time I answered your questions — hopefully I'm wiser, too. Thanks for rolling with chatting a little earlier than usual. Let's get this started...
Jeff M.: Hi Colin, do you think MLB owners already know what baseball will look like next season? Even if takes a lockout and missed year to get what they want.
Colin Beazley: Hi Jeff. I think they have ideas of what they want (a salary cap, etc), but no one -- not the owners, players, Manfred, ballboys, anyone -- actually knows what baseball will look like next year. Major league baseball won't be played until there's an agreement on the CBA, which will require compromise on both sides. Maybe that's compromise that includes the players agreeing to a salary cap (unlikely). Maybe that's compromise that includes a salary floor and no cap (also unlikely). But both sides are going to have to give up something for baseball to be played again.
Jeff M.: Do you think GMBC will survive another non-playoff & losing season?
Aces High: What a disappointing second half so far. Do you feel the Bucs need wholesale changes in the GM, Pitching Coach, and Manager after this debacle of a second half?
Colin Beazley: Honestly, I'm really not sure what the Pirates will do or should do.
Read More
On one hand, they said playoffs were the goal "period. Full stop." If that doesn't happen -- which looks extremely unlikely at this point -- then some level of accountability demands firings.
On the other hand, you can make the argument that this team is on a better trajectory, some good decisions were made this year and some better health would have led to the playoffs. (I'm not saying that, only saying that they could.) And with all the uncertainty of this offseason, it's not exactly a great time for a new GM to come in. And there is a lot of talent coming back!
Colin Beazley: I don't know. I think I'd say that, if this is in fact another losing season (which looks more and more likely by the day), then some change needs to be made.
Maybe that means Bill Murphy is scapegoated, though after Matt Hague was kept last year, I doubt Murphy would only get one year. I don't think Don Kelly is the issue either. That leaves Ben Cherington, who had a decent offseason and deadline.
At some point, something needs to change. Not sure who that should be. Hopefully I'll have some better answers as I'm sure we'll hear this question plenty over the next few weeks.
Matt from Davidson NC: What do you think of Don ‘We’ve got to find a way’ Kelly?
Colin Beazley: To me, a manager's biggest job is maintaining clubhouse culture and keeping a group of highly paid, highly competitive men focused on baseball instead of everything else. The players play, the front office assembles the team, and at this point, the vast majority of decisions are informed by data (as they should be -- use research to your advantage). The manager leads and deals with a ton of little things -- the media, managing coaches, managing personalities, the front office, etc etc etc.
To me, there's a major difference how this team is functioning under Kelly to the end days of Derek Shelton. Yes, decisions are similar, the numbers are the same. But the other things are far better. That's why, to me, Don Kelly isn't the issue.
Minogue: If the Pirates are trying to win games why wouldn't you have Cruz in the line up last night? Crazy!
Colin Beazley: Up until this year, Cruz struggled badly against left-handers. I don't blame the Pirates for having him sit against Valdez. I'm sure he'll start today.
Dan: Cruz goes 3 for 22 with 7 strikeouts in a rehab assignment in (mainly) Altoona and Indy. Come on man. The guy clearly doesn’t have it anymore. So you demote Simon and you’ll obviously take playing time away from our best hitter Mangum, who is also a significantly better defensive player than Cruz. Does this make sense to anyone??
Colin Beazley: Disagree with a couple things in here. For one, rehab stats aren't that important. Sure, you'd like to see him go 22 for 22, but the Pirates aren't making decisions on that. And Jake Mangum is a fantastic fourth outfielder, but I certainly wouldn't call him the Pirates best hitter.
That said, I do hope we see some more DH days for Cruz. Now that that spot's open, the Pirates have more flexibility to keep the bat in the lineup without the glove.
Matt from Davidson NC: Do you agree that Nick Gonzales, although a good singles hitter, is the worst fielding infielder in baseball?Jacob Gonzales & Mlodzinski are scrubs. It’s unbelievable Mlodzinski had the audacity to gripe about going to the bullpen. And it’s ridiculous Cruz has taken so long to come back from his hand injury. Predicting he performs terribly when inserted back into lineup.
Colin Beazley: Gonzales hasn't been good enough defensively. Hand injuries are bizarre. I've heard it's healed, but he'll likely still have to deal with swelling over the next few weeks, yet it's healed?
Colin Beazley: Strange injury that Cruz has had to deal with.
The Dude: Well now that it is clearly over, what should the Pirates do for the remainder of the season? Shut down Skenes? Forget about Carmen as a starter? Showcase Cruz to get ready to move him?
demosthenes98: Is there any reason why the experiment with Carmen Mlodzinski as a starter SHOULDN'T end, or, if necessary, be ended?
Connor: Should the pirates shut Skenes down for the season if his start on Wednesday does not go well?
Carmen Mlodzinski: Do you have any feel for whether they are going to use Mlodzinski as a starter for the remainder of the season? Could they be waiting until Sept call ups?
Colin Beazley: Some of these Qs are linked, so I'll answer together:
I disagree with my colleague Noah's article that Skenes should be shut down -- if, and only if, he is in fact healthy like he says he is. Yes, he's not getting better, but there's value in making 32 starts and knowing what you need to do in the offseason to be ready to make 32+ starts next year. Clearly, this offseason's work didn't have their intended results. Work on things in September and go into the offseason with a better plan.
I'm over the Mlodzinski starter experiment. I don't see a reason for him to get a fourth start. I'm fine with him being part of a bullpen game, but having him actually start it just isn't working. I'd rather see Antwone Kelly/Wilber Dotel/Hunter Barco/Khristian Curtis get experience.
Colin Beazley: That said, no idea why Mlodzinski is so good in three inning relief appearances and so bad in three inning starts. I really don't have an answer for it, but something needs to be fixed.
Tony Soprano: Whatever happened to Kristian Curtis? Guy came up, shut down CLE and hasn’t had another opportunity. Given Mlod’s last two starts, I’d certainly be up to him pitching next time out in SD as opposed to Carmen.
Colin Beazley: Curtis hit the 7-day injured list in Indianapolis after his first minor league appearance after Cleveland. Was told it was side discomfort. His first outing off the IL was short, but I'd expect him to get another look. Maybe they'll let him stretch out for one more turn through, then we see Curtis in St Louis?
demosthenes98: At what point in the season do the Pirates' players start to tune out and move on? Is it when Steelers training camp opens, the way it is for fans? Or is it later or earlier?
Colin Beazley: Hi demosthenes. Missed you these last two weeks.
I don't get the sense this team is checked out. It's a very different feeling than this point last year, even if the playoff odds are only marginally better.
demosthenes98: When they head to the places where they spend the offseason, do the Pirates' players admit to the locals that they work for Bob Nutting? Or do they just say that they play Major League Baseball (to the extent that the Pirates count as a major league team) and exit conversations very quickly afterward?
Colin Beazley: Doesn't everyone say they work where they're employed instead of they work for a certain person? If I worked at Subway, I'd say I work at Subway, not I'm employed by Roark Global Capital managing partner Neil K. Aronson.
Colin Beazley: No idea why that was the example I picked.
demosthenes98: Last week, Paul Skenes said, "I don't know exactly why we're not playing up to that standard right now." Aren't they, though? Given that, as your colleague Noah Hiles pointed out, late-season collapses are what the Pirates do best, is there not a case to be made that they are, in fact, playing up [or down] to the Bob Nutting standard?
Colin Beazley: The standard was supposed to be a playoff team. They're not hitting that standard.
JamesWV: Well Colin, once again there won’t be any October baseball and once again the September games will be relatively meaningless. If this was Survivor, who amongst the players, coaches or front office would be voted off the island?
Colin Beazley: Well it depends on who has idols and who has immunity. Maybe that's why some have lasted so long...
I do think you could argue that a productive offseason, better performance from the starting pitchers, better health and better usage of the $20m Ozuna/Soto money (Soto has been fine, but I don't think he'll be re-signed) can get this team to the playoffs.
But again, at some point, some changes have to be made. I just don't know where that should be.
Greg: Have to wonder about Temarr Johnson's future with the Pirates. His performance since being drafted 4th overall in 2022 has been pedestrian, at best, Now that he's sidelined until next spring, at the earliest, with a severe knee injury, how much additional leeway will he be given? He's not a kid anymore and has yet to put up numbers befitting a 4A player. What say you?
Jeff M: Is a team more likely to take Johnson in the rule 5 draft if they can stash him on the IL for most of the season?
Colin Beazley: For what it's worth, I'd written that Termarr would be sidelined until next spring at the earliest. Given what we heard from Dr Tomczyk yesterday, I'm confident it'll be much more than six months.
Right now, he hasn't even been a good AAA player. I'm not entirely out on him, but I wouldn't use a 40-man spot on him. I doubt someone else will. Just have no idea what he'll come back as, especially given he's struggled while healthy this year.
He's still 22, so he'll have opportunities once healthy. But I don't think he's someone that other teams will be clamoring to pick up.
Jim G: I may have missed it, but have there been any updates on the expected returns for O'Hearn, Griffin and Rodriguez? I assume Cruz will be in the lineup tonight, correct?
Colin Beazley: Yes, wrote about that yesterday. Here's the link. Short of it was good news for O'Hearn and Griffin, second opinion coming for Endy. And yes, I expect Cruz to start tonight.
Pittfan: Hi Colin. Is it possible Skenes is holding back in an effort to preserve his arm, a business decision if you will. Needing Tommy John surgery could certainly delay his half a billion dollar payday. This is not an indictment on Skenes, and with the current state of baseball I certainly wouldn't blame him. If that may be the case, is it time for the Pirates to consider trading him?
Colin Beazley: Hi Pittfan. I think Paul Skenes made changes to his mechanics and arsenal, including a decrease in velocity, to protect his health. I do not think he is intentionally pitching worse or babying pitches.
I do not think this is the time to trade Skenes. His value will be higher once he starts pitching better. The new CBA could give the Pirates a better chance to keep him, too.
Scorekeeper: Where is Horowitz? He seems to not be in the lineup as much as expected. Is he still dealing with his injury?
Colin Beazley: Just a lot of lefties recently. I expect him to start again tonight.
That said, he has slumped badly since returning. 5 for 39 (.128) isn't good enough.
Buzz: This may be a little early but with what do you project the pirates biggest offseason needs to be? Will the starting pitching need to be addressed?
Colin Beazley:
- Figure out how to get the starting pitching back on track. You have the players to make this a strength. Maybe sign a No. 5.
- Re-sign Brandon Lowe/find your Lowe replacement.
- Figure out your long-term plan at catcher/third base.
- Make sure you have enough pitching depth to deal with inevitable injuries.
There's my top four. Obviously, there will be bigger storylines this offseason regardless of if the Pirates make coaching/front office changes.
Jojobubajr: Do you see the Pirates doing anything with the number of innings Ashcraft and Chandler are projected to pitch this year? I'm concerned they will not manage their innings which could cause problems down the road similar to Jared Jones and Oviedo, who is still injured and hasn't pitched yet this year
Colin Beazley: A question advocating for innings limits? I didn't know I was allowed to get those!
I doubt either will be pushed once the Pirates' playoff chances are officially zero. I think there's benefit in staying on the schedule and making a full season worth of starts, but four innings and 60 pitches is fine if the result doesn't matter. Use the time to get more experience for the minor league guys I mentioned above. But I don't see them being fully shut down unless they're dealing with injuries, instead of soreness.
Buzz: What vibe are you getting from the clubhouse? Is the team checked out or is there a sense of belief that they can make a run still?
Colin Beazley: I wouldn't say checked out. Feels like there's some excitement around getting Griffin/O'Hearn/Cruz back either now or in the near ish future. But it's certainly tighter than earlier this summer.
PhilinCT: As always, thank you for your insight and availability. What are you thoughts/odds on the likelihood of re-signing Lowe with a salary cap CBA vs non-salary cap CBA? They can slide Nicky G. back to second but would need to get a thumper for 3B. I think Lowe is a keeper if the price isn't totally outrageous.
Colin Beazley: I agree Lowe is a keeper. Been very impressed by him this year.
As for odds, tough to answer without knowing the system. I think the Pirates could make the money work under the current CBA -- he's on the books for 11.5 this year, Ozuna makes $10.5, and I don't necessarily expect him to be a $20+m a year player on a multi-year deal. But it's tough to answer without a CBA in place.
Tommac from Y-Town: Do you think that Henry Davis would hit for a higher average if he stopped trying to pull everything to left field? Why can't he go with an outside pitch and hit the ball to right field?
Colin Beazley: Whenever Davis is at his best, it feels like he goes to the opposite field more. So many pulled foul balls.
Ryan: Colin with Oneil returning tonight how do they get Mangum playing time i think he looked good when Cruz was injured
Colin Beazley: I expect Mangum to still get looks as the fourth outfielder. He's hit well enough to stay in the mix and can play all three spots capably. I expect Cruz/Valdez/Reynolds to all have regular DH days, too.
Carmen Mlodzinski: What do you think about Travis Williams being the scapegoat? After all, he is the guy who made the ridiculous statement in the first place.
Colin Beazley: Entirely possible. Lot of different ways the Pirates can approach this.
The Eman: Starting pitching was supposed to be the Bucs greatest team strength. However, they woefully underperformed this year. Were they simply overrated, or are they as good as promised ? If potentially a major strength, what went wrong this year?
Colin Beazley: This is a major reason why the season has gone south. Apart from Braxton Ashcraft, none of the starters took a meaningful step up this year -- and even Ashcraft has been struggling from the break until Miami.
Skenes hasn't been excellent, regardless of what GMBC says. Mitch Keller was worse than anyone anticipated. I've been encouraged by what we've seen from Bubba Chandler lately, though I think expectations were higher this season overall. Jared Jones has slumped. Just haven't been as good as all thought they could be.
Pauly Walnuts: Not making excuses, but can you expect much given the plethora of injuries this team has had? Seriously, what bad luck. Griffin, Cruz, Horwitz, Rodriguez, O’Hearn, Keller (although he stunk) all out extended times. One comes back, another goes on IL. What exactly are they supposed to do to an extent???
Colin Beazley: It's a real argument. We'll see if this is the path Bob Nutting takes.
Syd: Any idea on who they might call up when the roster expands to 28? Im very intrigued by Mitch Jebb but I know he’s not on the 40 man. I was hoping we could see Johnathan Rodriguez but he was DFA’d. Maybe it will just be Griffin or O’Hearn if they’re healthy. Just curious your thoughts
Colin Beazley: Griffin could return Sept. 4. Jebb, Connor Wietgrefe and Brandon Neeck seem the likeliest off the 40-man, but in Wietgrefe's case, the Pirates don't need to add him until 2027.
I think it'll probably just be more depth. Pitching spot may just go to one of the starters for some bulk help.
Jim G: I realize it's hindsight, but I think the miscalculation that Soto and Santana would be effective in the "closer" role, and then staying with them long after they failed miserably, torpedoed the season from the outset. Your thoughts?
Colin Beazley: I'll finish on this question from Jim... there's been a number of things that have gone wrong, but this was the story of the early season. 20 blown saves don't correlate to 20 wins, but just five would have the Pirates in the wild card race right now. I get that trades rarely happen before the deadline, but I do think deals could have been struck for Doval and Yates before then. That certainly couldn't have hurt.
Colin Beazley: That'll do for this week's Pirates live chat. If I didn't get to your question, feel free to email me (cbeazley at post-gazette dot com). Thank you as always, and I'll talk to you guys next week from sunny San Diego.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.