Like Sunday, the Pirates used a non-traditional lineup and unfurled a bullpen game in hopes of beating an American League opponent.

While the plan was the same, Monday’s game didn’t follow the same script.

The Pirates fell, 8-5, to the Detroit Tigers on Monday night at PNC Park. Carmen Mlodzinski struggled in his third outing since moving from his relief role, and while the Pirates had chances late, they weren’t able to dig out of the seven-run hole dug by Mlodzinski and right-hander Yohan Ramirez.

The Pirates trailed, 8-1, midway through the sixth inning before a rally fell short.

Advertise with us

“It was a tough one,” Mlodzinski said. “Last three have been a little rough for me. Part of the game, for sure, and I wish I would’ve been able to step up. Just looking forward to trying to get right back on track and looking forward to the next outing.”

The right-hander was hit hard early. After Lake Bachar had thrown three scoreless frames on Sunday, Mlodzinski was tagged for four runs on eight hits and a walk in his three innings. He has a 15.95 ERA (13 earned runs in 7 1/3 innings) in three appearances since moving to his pseudo-starter role.

All four runs came with two outs. Three two-out singles in the first inning (including a Hao-Yu Lee RBI single that was part of a 3 for 3 day with two walks) brought in the first two runs, then Kevin McGonigle ripped a two-out, two-run homer in the second.

After another rough outing, it’s worth wondering whether Mlodzinski will get a fourth start.

“We just need to continue to have conversations,” manager Don Kelly said. “He’s been in different roles and has been a huge pitcher for us. Did a really nice job coming out of the ’pen, so we need to keep beating it up on the best position to put him in.”

Advertise with us

Isaac Mattson threw two scoreless frames to get the Pirates to the fifth. But Yohan Ramirez, making his first appearance since coming off the paternity list, allowed three runs on two hits and three walks in a 44-pitch sixth inning.

“It seemed like the release point was off,” Kelly said. “Some spiked balls that we haven’t seen from him that weren’t really even close to the zone. But he was able to find a way to get through that. To push him to 44 was a little too aggressive [but] kinda needed it there.”

Prior to Monday’s outing, Ramirez had allowed just one run in his last 22 appearances (a 0.28 ERA in 32 1/3 innings).

The Pirates finally found some offense in the sixth. Lefty Framber Valdez had been dominant through five, only allowing an unearned run, but lost his command with two outs in the sixth. After consecutive walks to load the bases, Nick Yorke cleared the bases with a double into the left field corner, ending Valdez’s day.

Henry Davis lined a single up the middle against right-hander Kyle Finnegan, but pinch-hitter Jacob Gonzalez popped out to end the frame.

Advertise with us

It was over when…

The Pirates had a few more chances late, but their best came in the seventh. A Javy Baez error and a Nick Gonzales walk put two on and one out, but left-hander Drew Sommers came in and induced a soft Brandon Lowe groundout and a Rafael Flores Jr. strikeout.

On the mound

While the Pirates aren’t calling Mlodzinski a starter — he’s on the once-every-five-days schedule, but isn’t expected to pitch too deep into games — he did start Monday’s game.

His splits as a starter and reliever are drastic. In 50 1/3 innings out of the bullpen, Mlodzinski has a 2.15 ERA. In 52 1/3 innings as a starter, his ERA is 5.85.

Kelly hoped Mlodzinski wasn’t putting too much pressure on himself. Mlodzinski said he wasn’t, but he’s working through his mechanics and how he’s feeling physically. As of now, he’s trying to put up as many zeroes as possible.

“I think the way they're going to manage the game is going to be to win,” Mlodzinski said. “So if I'm being super efficient and super effective, I think yeah, I'm going to be able to earn innings. But the last three I just haven't been able to.

Advertise with us

“I know that time will come. I'll be able to put up zeroes and be efficient and go probably a little bit deeper into ballgames. But I don't think the expectation is a full load as a starter yet."

The Pirates have lost all three of Mlodzinski’s appearances since he was moved out of the relief role. With dwindling playoff odds, they may not be able to give him that shot to go deeper.

At the plate

The Pirates scored five runs on six hits, leaving seven runners on base. The Tigers walked five batters.

Yorke went 2 for 4, driving in three. Lowe singled twice against Valdez.

Jake Mangum walked twice, the first time he’d walked multiple times in a game in his major league career.

Advertise with us

Bucs bites

• The Pirates had one of their best ABS games of the season. Davis went 3 for 3 on challenges, including flipping a walk that would have loaded the bases in the eighth into an inning-ending strikeout. Mlodzinski also flipped a ball into strike three.

Camilo Doval burned the Pirates’ final challenge in the ninth.

• To activate Ramirez from the paternity list, the Pirates optioned left-hander Hunter Barco to Triple-A Indianapolis.

• The Pirates designated Triple-A outfielder Johnathan Rodriguez for assignment to activate Oneil Cruz from the 60-day injured list. He had previously been DFA’d by the Baltimore Orioles, then flipped to the Pirates for cash ahead of the trade deadline. He never appeared for the Pirates. Cruz did not appear Monday.

• With the Pirates trailing 8-1 in the sixth inning, a large group of shirtless fans in section 333 (participating in the “Tarps Off” trend) spelled out the letter “P”. The Pirates followed with a four-run frame, their best of the game.

Advertise with us

Up next

The Pirates and Tigers will play the second of a three-game series on Tuesday at 6:40 p.m. Right-hander Braxton Ashcraft (12-5, 3.88 ERA) will start against Tigers right-hander Keider Montero (9-7, 3.22). The game will be televised on SportsNet Pittsburgh and broadcast on the radio on 93.7 The Fan.