The Pirates’ season appears dead. Their playoff odds, per FanGraphs, have dipped below 5%. Baseball Reference puts the number below two. Losing 15 of 20 games will do that to you.
Those in the clubhouse still believe, saying all the right things about how important each remaining matchup is.
But for those in Pittsburgh, Thursday night’s Steelers game at Acrisure Stadium meant two things.
First and foremost, it’s football season. Second, when it’s football season, that usually means the Pirates are out of playoff contention again — sometimes after a collapse.
Don Kelly knows how attention shifts around this time each year. He’s seen it as a local, as a player, and now, as the one in charge.
“For the Pittsburgh Pirates right now, our focus every day is on being prepared and going out there and competing at that level that we expect to play well and win baseball games,” Kelly said. “As we show up every single day to do that, that's the goal, to go out and play baseball at a level that Pittsburgh fans can appreciate.”
Read More
Three wins in four games, aided by three Rafael Flores Jr. home runs, helped to keep the slimmest of hope alive. But the season still feels like it’s going the way of 2011, 2016, 2018 and 2024.
The latter feels most applicable, both because it's the most recent and because of how it all unfolded. Few Pirates fans need reminding, but that year’s team bought at the trade deadline, then proceeded to lose 12 of 13 and fell from third in the division to fifth. The dagger was an 0-6, West Coast road trip to Los Angeles and San Diego.
This year’s club bought at the trade deadline, then lost seven of eight. Maybe they can pull out of it. Another August swing to Los Angeles and San Diego looms.
Asked why he believes the 2026 squad can be different from 2024, Kelly pointed toward the resilience the team has shown. In recent times, when Ryan O’Hearn suffered his injury in Cincinnati, the Pirates won the next day. When Mitch Keller went down, they again responded, that time with a win on deadline day. They avoided sweeps against the New York Mets (middle game) and Miami Marlins (series finale) with resounding wins.
Kelly stressed injuries aren’t something unique to the Pirates, but he’s still impressed with how his players have handled them.
“I think that that's what gives me the hope that we're going to continue to win games,” Kelly said, “because of the way that we've gone about it all season up to this point.”
But a few wins won’t get the Pirates into the playoffs. Sure, those four wins prevented what would have been indisputably a season-ending 16-game losing streak, but 4-12 isn’t much better.
So how else do this year’s Pirates compare to the 2024 team? And what, if anything can be done to avoid the same fate — if they still have a chance?
This year’s team has weathered worse injuries than the previous contender. The 2026 Pirates have a 31-25 record with Oneil Cruz in center and 27-27 with Konnor Griffin at shortstop. They’re 22-20 with Ryan O’Hearn in right field (and 10-5 when O’Hearn is the designated hitter). And they’re 38-36 with Spencer Horwitz at first base. All four of those key contributors have missed or are still missing significant time.
While Endy Rodriguez was sidelined for all of 2024 and Nick Gonzales, Jared Jones and Carmen Mlodzinski all missed the decisive stretch that year, that 2024 group had fewer stars but also had fewer injury woes.
But pitching was the bigger issue in 2024. In the 13-game skid, the Pirates had a team ERA of 5.51 (while scoring 3.8 runs per game). The 2026 Pirates, in their 20-game swoon, had a 4.74 ERA (while scoring 3.1).
The pitching stabilized some in 2024, but not enough to make a miracle run. When the skid ended, their playoff odds were less than 1%. This year’s odds aren’t there yet.
“There is pressure,” Kelly said, “and we've earned that pressure. And how do we slow things down to continue to go up there and go out on the field and compete the way we have all season.”
At some point, the Pirates need to go on a run if they want to end up in October. From injuries to Paul Skenes’ continued slump to team-wide struggles against lefties, there’s little reason to believe it can happen. Progress from a 71-91 record in 2025 — or even the 76-86 mark that the 2024 squad racked up — is very attainable, but a postseason push doesn’t seem likely.
Maybe the two wins Thursday and Friday were the start of a historic run. It’s highly unlikely, but Kelly likes the attitude.
“The only way that we can win today is to attack every single pitch, every at-bat, everything one step at a time,” Kelly said. “ ... Talking to the guys about showing up every day to go 1-0. Can't worry about tomorrow. How do we tackle today and get after it today to go 1-0.”
Still, according to Baseball Reference’s championship leverage index, the two-game winning streak came in the Pirates’ two least important games of the season.
It’s almost certainly too late to avoid continuing a decade-long playoff drought. Unless they can pull off a miracle that never came in 2024.
I’ll be watching …
Bryan Reynolds’ continued slump. Only two players in MLB have a bigger decrease in wRC+ from the first half to the second half: the Yankees’ Ben Rice and the Marlins’ Otto Lopez. Reynolds had a 142 wRC+ before the All-Star break, compared to a 52 wRC+ after (100 is league average). TJ Stats on X posted the 20 biggest wRC+ fallers, and it was almost a surprise that Reynolds was the only Pirate on the list. But it shows the impact a contributing Reynolds can have.
The Carmen Mlodzinski bullpen game. My understanding is the Pirates want Mlodzinski to pitch in bulk every fifth day, throwing three or four innings instead of ramping up for five or six. It’s understandable. The Pirates don’t have the luxury of time to ramp him up, and after the deadline revamp, the bullpen is better than the rotation. But Mlodzinski has struggled enough in his first two starts that I wonder whether the Pirates would be better off having him return to the more flexible role and using spot starters such as Khristian Curtis, Wilber Dotel, Antwone Kelly or Hunter Barco every fifth day.
How Rafael Flores looks as the second catcher. Flores is among the Pirates with the most to prove over the final month-plus, especially if Endy Rodriguez misses significant time. If he hits and fields, perhaps he can carve out a role for himself in 2027 (looming lockout aside) as either a platoon first baseman or part of the catcher’s mix. As Rodriguez continues to deal with injuries and Henry Davis struggles offensively, there’s a role to claim. If not, the Pirates may need to look externally for 2027 as they wait for prospects to develop.
They said it …
“Game is tough, for sure. But one thing's for sure, I'm just going out there every day just try to add to the team and finding ways to get better myself to help the team. I know we're going to go through some tough stretches personally, but I'm just working hard every day just to help my team” — Esmerlyn Valdez, via major league coach Stephen Morales
Prospect pictures
Low-A Bradenton right-hander Levi Sterling is quietly having a strong second professional season, earning himself a promotion to High-A Greensboro on Sunday. Drafted with the 37th overall pick out of Notre Dame High in Los Angeles in 2024, Sterling has made 21 starts for the Marauders this year and just tied a Bradenton franchise record by striking out 11 batters in six innings on Thursday. Still only 19, Sterling has pitched 96 innings and struck out 112 in Bradenton. He’s allowed three or fewer hits in seven of his last eight starts (though that does include two planned short starts). It’s encouraging to see the 6-foot-5 right-hander succeed after having some struggles in the Florida Complex League in 2024. Elsewhere, I watched Oneil Cruz rehab on Tuesday in Altoona. The top three in the order that night: Robert Hassell III, Cruz and Lonnie White Jr.
On deck
Tale of the Tigers
Judging by deadline strategy, this should be an easy series for the Pirates. Judging by actual results, it’ll be anything but. The Detroit Tigers were sellers two weeks ago, yet entered the weekend with a wild-card spot and a playoff-worthy resume.
Left coast Los Angeles
The Pirates end the week against the reigning champs in Los Angeles. The projected pitching matchups, per FanGraphs: Jared Jones vs. RHP Yoshinobu Yamamoto on Friday; Paul Skenes vs. All-Star LHP Justin Wrobleski on Saturday; and Carmen Mlodzinski vs. all-world LHP Tarik Skubal on Sunday.
Bottom of the ninth
In modern baseball, it’s rare for a manager to publicly call out a player via the media. Even calling out the group or admitting frustration can have more drawbacks than benefits — playing tight is a risk, as is creating unnecessary pressure. It’s for that reason that I understand why Don Kelly is almost unfailingly positive, and also why comments such as Wednesday’s (when Kelly said it “felt like we felt sorry for ourselves”) hit home. He was 100% right that the performance was “not good enough,” and it can be argued that the comment had its intended result when the Pirates beat the Marlins, 13-0, the next day. Is it too late? Given where the Pirates are in the standings, probably. It’s also not like Braxton Ashcraft decided to pitch the best game of his career or Rafael Flores decided to hit two homers because Kelly was strict in a postgame press conference. But amid a skid which has too often felt like the same thing over and over again, a different strategy felt like a good start.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.