The Pirates have three players whose production should have warranted a spot this year’s National League All-Star team. None of them were selected. Instead, the franchise’s lone nod went to its most recognizable player, a starting pitcher who has more commercials than wins in 2026.

The All-Star selection process has never been perfect in any sport. Baseball’s can be especially whacky, considering fans determine the starting nine for both squads. There are snubs every year, and this year, there were multiple on the Pirates’ roster.

“I feel like we've got a lot of guys that deserve to go,” Pirates manager Don Kelly said after the National League’s roster was announced Saturday. “It's not closed yet — there will be replacements and other things — and we'll certainly be pushing for and pulling for other guys that are deserving to be on the team as well.”

Kelly is correct. There’s still a chance we see a few Pirates get added into the fold, once it’s announced which of the original selections won’t be available for the Midsummer Classic. Even still, it shouldn’t have had to come to this point. The numbers don’t lie.

Advertise with us

Let’s start with the pitching staff. The Pirates’ most deserving All-Star on the mound is right-hander Braxton Ashcraft, who entering Sunday, ranked in the top 10 in the National League in wins (9), strikeouts (122), WHIP (1.10) and innings pitched (108 1/3).

Only four of the nine starting pitchers originally selected have a higher bWAR than Ashcraft’s mark of 2.8. One of those behind him in that category was Pittsburgh’s lone selection, Paul Skenes.

“He’s one of the best pitchers in the game and I don’t really think you can argue that,” Skenes said of Ashcraft. “All the numbers say that, too.”

There will be more discussion on Skenes’ selection later. But first, let’s review their two position player snubs: Brandon Lowe and Bryan Reynolds. Both have been All-Stars before, and it could easily be argued that both are in the midst of their best seasons of their respective careers.

Lowe entered Sunday leading all second basemen — not just the National League, but in MLB — in home runs (20), RBIs (60) and slugging percentage (.494). His fielding has also taken a notable step forward in 2026, with baseball savant ranking him in the 97th percentile in outs above average.

Advertise with us

Reynolds, meanwhile, has been even better. Just six of the National League’s 21 selected position players have a higher bWAR than his mark of 3.2. On an offense that ranks among the top five in MLB in essentially every relevant statistical category, Reynolds entered Sunday leading the Pirates in runs scored (62), on base percentage (.395), OPS (.865), walks (57) and doubles (21).

“Our offense is just a buzzsaw,” Skenes said. “Nobody wants to face us.”

Now for the Skenes discussion.

I’m not suggesting he was undeserving. While his traditional stats rank near the bottom of those who made the original cut, his 119 strikeouts, 1.01 WHIP and 2.04 walks-per-nine-innings all rank within the top five among qualified National League starting pitchers. He’s one of the primary faces of the sport. No active pitcher in MLB has better name recognition — excluding that guy from the Dodgers who also plays designated hitter.

All-Star games are better when the most popular players are involved, but it can’t come at the expense of their more deserving teammates getting the short end of the stick. Skenes, himself, seems to recognize this.

Advertise with us

“I was shocked that I was the only one,” Skenes said. “Yeah, not too happy about that.”

Should Skenes be unavailable to pitch in this year’s All-Star Game, I’d hope MLB does the right thing and selects Ashcraft as his replacement. I’m less optimistic that Lowe and Reynolds will find their way to Philadelphia, although both should also be near the top of the list as far as position player replacements are concerned.

The 2026 Pirates have been a fun story to follow, going from one of the worst hitting teams in the sport to one of the best. It’s a shame that MLB won’t be able to highlight this on one of the game’s biggest platforms.

Three thoughts

1. How much longer does Mitch Keller have to struggle before the Pirates consider moving him to the bullpen? While I think Carmen Mlodzinski has been solid in his long relief role, it’s hard to argue that he wouldn’t be a better alternative. Keller is the longest tenured pitcher on staff and the highest paid player on this year’s roster. He’s earned the right to have a longer leash than most. But he’s hurt the club far more than he’s helped in 2026 and we’re quickly approaching the point where the Pirates have to step in and change his role.

2. Seeing Eddy Yean make his MLB debut Sunday reminded me of just how bad the majority of the Pirates’ trades were during the first few years of Ben Cherington’s time with the organization. He’s had more wins than losses over the last two offseasons, but looking back at his moves in 2020 and 2021 is rather brutal.

Advertise with us

3. As the dog days of summer wait just around the corner, the Pirates have a rookie duo providing a major spark. Konnor Griffin and Esmerlyn Valdez have picked up the slack over the past few weeks while Oneil Cruz and Spencer Horwitz have been on the shelf. This year’s team might not have what it takes to reach the postseason, but I continue to feel more optimistic about this organization’s overall future.

Most Valuable Player

Noah Kahan

I attended his concert Friday evening at PNC Park. It was sold out. The energy around the ballpark was tremendous. Throughout the entire show, I found myself thinking how fun it would be to cover an October baseball game in a similar atmosphere. Maybe someday, I guess.

Least Valuable Player

Noah Hiles

For mentioning folk-pop singer-songwriter Noah Kahan in a column about Pittsburgh sports.

Advertise with us

Question of the week

Time for redemption?

The Pirates looked overmatched the first time they faced the Atlanta Braves this year. Getting swept in the peach state kicked off their worst month of the season. If the Pirates can take at least two games from the Braves this week, it should be considered a massive win.