The Pirates’ mission for 2026 has been clear since last fall: Reach the postseason. Anything less should and will be deemed a failure.
We’re still months away from October. Plenty can happen between now and then. And while nothing can truly compare to the high-stakes pressure that comes from playoff baseball, this week’s homestand should feel like an appetizer of what this organization is chasing.
On Tuesday, the Pirates will host their final homestand before the All-Star break. They’ll play six games, three against the Atlanta Braves, three against the Milwaukee Brewers. Both opponents sit comfortably atop their respective divisions. Both are legitimate World Series contenders.
This week will show us where the Pirates truly stand in their hunt for October. They enter the homestand a game above .500, still in the hunt for a National League wild card spot. They can’t afford a bad week of baseball. They need to keep winning. And they need their best player to lead the charge.
The way the schedule is currently shaped, only one Pirates starting pitcher will get to pitch twice this homestand.
That pitcher is Paul Skenes.
Read More
This is the scenario Pirates fans dreamed of at the start of the year — a high-pressure week in early July, two elite clubs in town here to face the best pitcher in the world. But things haven’t exactly gone according to plan.
The Pirates have been a better team without Skenes in 2026.
They’ve lost the last nine games he’s started. He’s coming off the worst start of his professional career. This is his first true taste of adversity in the major leagues. Seemingly the entire baseball world has been discussing his struggles. Few have answers — himself included.
“I’m not sure,” Skenes said after allowing seven earned runs over four innings last week in Philadelphia. “We’ll figure out what it is and just keep attacking it.”
The noise must be impossible to ignore, even for someone with his laser focus. But if Skenes can return to his old form, all of that noise will vanish.
Having covered Skenes from the moment he arrived, one of the things I’ve admired most about his game is the way he almost always rises to the occasion. Whenever he toes the rubber in an iconic venue or an elite batter steps in the box to face him, he delivers a show. We haven’t seen much of that this season. If it were to ever return, now is the time.
Tuesday’s start against the Braves is Skenes’ biggest outing of the season. Atlanta is starting right-hander Hurston Waldrep, a 24-year-old with 7 1/3 innings logged in the majors this season. The Pirates need a win. Skenes has to win.
Should Skenes’ losing streak end Tuesday evening, it would be one of the Pirates’ biggest wins of the season. It would serve as a key first step in the challenging week ahead. It would put them more than a game above .500 for the first time since June 10. And, perhaps most importantly, the daunting narrative that’s loomed over their organization like a dark cloud would finally be put to rest.
One win, however, isn’t enough. Not this week. Not for Skenes.
Sunday’s contest against the Brewers also lines up to be a Skenes start. Some teams view the final game before the All-Star break as an opportunity to get their players early rest. This shouldn’t be the case for Skenes. The Pirates can’t afford to take it easy, especially against the Brewers. They need him to pitch again. And he needs to lead them to another victory.
The Pirates offense has dramatically improved this season. Their bullpen has looked better — still not anywhere good enough, but there’s been some progress — over the last few weeks. All that said, this team isn’t going anywhere until Skenes gets right.
Without Skenes at his best, these Pirates will be nothing more than an average ballclub. He’s their superstar. They will go as far as he can take them. They need him to be the best pitcher in the world, something he hasn’t looked like since mid-May.
“It’s Paul,” Nick Gonzales said last week after Skenes’ loss in Philadelphia. “Cy Young last year, and we’re confident that whatever ups or downs he has, he’s gonna persevere through. He’s gonna be Paul Skenes.”
Some people aren’t as confident as Skenes’ teammates. Some are wondering if he’s still capable of checking that box.
This week is the perfect time for him to answer that question.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.