Jurors will begin deliberations Friday afternoon in the homicide case against Johnathan Morris, at which point the 12 men and women must decide whether Morris physically knew what he was doing when he opened fire on McKeesport police officers Feb. 6, 2023, and whether he knew that it was wrong.

Prosecutors say Morris intended to level his 9mm pistol at Officer Chuck Thomas Jr. and then turn and fire three fatal shots at Officer Sean Sluganski before turning the gun back on Thomas.

“He premeditated, and he shot to kill,” said Deputy District Attorney Emma Schoedel in her closing argument early Friday afternoon. “You simply do not shoot someone multiple times unless you intend to kill. No one knows this better than a Marine.”

Defense attorney Carman Robinson urged jurors to find her client not guilty by reason of insanity, telling them Morris was in the throes of a psychotic episode and responding to his delusions and own perceived reality that afternoon.

Advertise with us

“I need you to consider who Johnathan Morris was at that time,” she said. “No one is trying to hurt him. They’re trying to help. Johnathan doesn’t know that.”

Sluganski and Thomas had initially responded that afternoon to a domestic violence call from Morris’ mother, former McKeesport officer Candace Tyler. She said he was being violent and suffering from PTSD. She asked for medics to assist with obtaining an involuntary commitment, but the call taker told her police had to respond to such calls. Tyler planned to go to UPMC McKeesport to get the 302 paperwork.

Morris had walked away from the Wilson Street home by the time officers arrived. Thomas testified that he was a short distance away, shouting. Thomas said that when he pulled up next to Morris, he tried to coax him into the car: He told him they were going to the VA.

“[Expletive] the VA,” Thomas said Morris replied.

The officers followed Morris throughout the neighborhood for just over eight minutes in what Thomas described as a game of “Frogger” — they would pull up to him, he would run across the street, they would try to pull next to him, and so on. Thomas said in radio transmissions that he was concerned Morris had a gun in his right pocket. He said it looked heavy.

Advertise with us

Robinson offered two defenses: insanity and self-defense. In terms of the latter, she told jurors, Morris truly believed his life was in imminent danger, in part, she alleged, because Thomas had been attempting to strike him with his patrol vehicle.

Schoedel said Thomas was using his car tactically and, beyond that, the self-defense argument flies in the face of the insanity defense.

“Both things cannot be true,” Schoedel said. “He did not know what he was doing but knew he needed to shoot to survive?”

‘Officer Sluganski is down’

Marconna Taylor and her sister, D-Ama Taylor, saw the shooting unfold.

They had seen Morris looking distressed and trying to wave off the officers following him minutes earlier. They said he looked disheveled, frightened, and as though he might be suffering a mental health crisis.

Advertise with us

He told the women he felt as though the officers were trying to kill him, and he asked them to record him as he tried to leave the area. When he fled officers again, the pair followed.

Morris and the officers ultimately ended up on the northernmost end of Grandview Avenue, lined with houses on its west side and St. Mary’s Cemetery to the east.

Testimony as to what, exactly, happened next varies, but all agree that Thomas drove his police vehicle, a Ford Taurus with “McKeesport Police” ghost letterings, sharply toward the fence that runs along the cemetery. He testified that he intended to block Morris’ path so they could take him into custody.

Marconna Taylor testified that she believed Thomas was trying to hit Morris, saying the officers were driving aggressively and appeared to be trying to “go after him.”

From there, Morris ended up on the hood of Thomas’ patrol vehicle. Thomas said he jumped there. Marconna Taylor said it appeared that Morris was forced on top of it to avoid being pinned against the fence.

Advertise with us

Morris ran across the street and up onto the hillside in front of 1300 Grandview Ave. Ring footage from the home next door shows Sluganski, now on foot, following behind. “Stop running, dawg,” he shouts to Morris.

At the same time, Thomas turns left into the adjacent De Long Alley. He testified that his intention, again, was to block Morris’ path so the pair could take him into custody.

As Morris moved in front of the house — with Thomas in his vehicle in front of him and Sluganski coming through the yard — he pulled his gun. Prosecutors say he fired twice through the windshield of Thomas’ car, turned, fired three times at Sluganski, and then shot again at Thomas as he ran toward the intersection of Grandview and Versailles. Thomas, who was shot in the face, returned fire through his open passenger window and Morris fled.

Together, the Ring footage and Marconna Taylor’s chaotic, shaky video show the moments Sluganski collapsed to the ground. The Ring shows him being propelled down the hill. The cellphone video captures him standing up, staggering partway up the small hillside, and then collapsing for a second and final time.

Dr. W. Ashton Ennis, of the Allegheny County Medical Examiner’s Office, testified early in the trial that one of the shots went through Sluganski’s shoulder, into his chest, and out the other side, severing his aorta in the process. The wound would be fatal, he said, but studies have shown people suffering such an injury able to get up and move for several seconds before the lack of blood and oxygen catches up to the brain.

Advertise with us

D-Ama Taylor said she ran to try to help Sluganski. She cradled his head and felt for a pulse, She found one, she said, and used her T-shirt to put pressure on the gunshot wound she could see. He gasped, she testified, and she felt for a pulse again. She found none.

Radio transmissions from Thomas as the shooting started were played for the jury last week. He is frantic, and he screams for help, saying he’s been hit. He didn’t realize at first that Sluganski had been shot, then screamed into his radio, “Officer Sluganski is down.”

‘I’m a Marine, please help me’

D-Ama Taylor said that, when she failed to find Sluganski’s pulse, she turned her attention to Thomas: She grabbed him by the back of the vest and told him he’d been shot — that he needed to lie down. Later footage recorded by her sister showed Thomas’ head in her lap.

“He was speaking on his walkie saying, ‘Slug’s down,’ ” she testified. “He said he needed to call his daughter.”

The first paramedics on scene testified at the start of the trial. McKeesport Ambulance Rescue Service Chief Bill Miller and another EMT were on their way before they were even dispatched, having heard Thomas’ frantic radio calls.

Advertise with us

When he arrived, he said, Sluganski was on his back on the ground. Thomas was over top of him in a protective position, weapon drawn. He triaged the scene, he said: Thomas was conscious, talking and ambulatory. He turned his attention to Sluganski who, he testified, his voice cracking, showed no signs of life. He said the officer took two or three agonal breaths – the body’s last attempts for oxygen before death.

While D-Ama Taylor was still tending to Sluganski and Thomas, Morris, prosecutors say, had fled toward the intersection of Patterson and Versailles streets. He collapsed in a parking lot, and two men from a nearby auto body shop cautiously approached to try to help him.

“He put his hands up and said, ‘I’m a Marine, please help me,’ ” Brian Savani said.

Security footage from the scene showed that, within seconds, Eastman’s police SUV came into view, and the men flagged him down. As he approached and tried to assess the situation, Morris can be seen grabbing his gun from his lap.

Eastman testified last week that he wasn’t certain who fired first but that he ultimately emptied his .45-caliber Glock at Morris. Investigators say Morris fired once — his final round — and then rolled into the intersection, tossing his gun toward a sewer grate along the way.

Advertise with us

He was taken into custody at 12:30 p.m., less than 20 minutes after his mother first called 911.

Sluganski was pronounced dead at UPMC McKeesport shortly before 1 p.m.

In an interview with detectives from his hospital bed three days after the shooting, Morris recounted what he believed happened, noting several times throughout that he “blacked out.” Footage of the interview recorded on body-worn camera shows Morris was surprised to learn he’d killed one of the officers.

“Johnathan, I mean, whether you know or not, you know you shot one of the police officers, right?” County homicide Det. Patrick Kinavey asked.

“I’m sorry about that,” Morris said.

Advertise with us

Kinavey continued: “And you know you shot the second officer as well — you shot two officers. One of the officers died.”

Morris said there’s no way he could have killed Sluganski, who he referred to as “the white officer.” He maintained that he fired twice at the police vehicle, though he later called his shots “warning shots.”