A psychologist testified Wednesday that Johnathan Morris’ mental illnesses and the symptoms thereof — delusions, distorted perceptions, PTSD-related hyperarousal, among others — meant he did not know what he was doing or that it was wrong when he allegedly killed one McKeesport police officer, wounded a second, and shot at a third.

Terri Dilmore, a Howard University-based clinical and forensic psychologist, said Morris met Pennsylvania’s legal definition of insanity at the time of the Feb. 6, 2023, shooting that killed Sean Sluganski and wounded Chuck Thomas Jr.

Dilmore’s report that she submitted in the case, however, cited the requirements listed in the Pennsylvania crimes code that deals with the disposition of “guilty but mentally ill.”

The difference in definitions appears slight, but insanity and guilty but mentally ill are two different legal standards.

Advertise with us

State law defines mentally ill as one who, because of mental illness, “lacks substantial capacity either to appreciate the wrongfulness of his conduct or to conform his conduct to the requirements of the law.”

And that is the standard, Deputy District Attorney Ryan Kiray pointed out on cross-examination, that Dilmore used in her expert report. Her direct testimony on the stand, however, was different in that she used the correct standard for insanity.

“So the first time you opined [on insanity] was on the stand, correct?” Kiray asked Dilmore.

She said yes.

Kiray used that discrepancy as his final point in his hour-plus cross-examination in which he worked to dismantle the insanity-defense groundwork laid out by defense attorney Carmen Robinson through her expert witness and several of Morris’ friends and family members.

Advertise with us

The testimony Wednesday marked the seventh day of the trial and the first full day of defense testimony. Robinson told jurors in her opening statements last week that she intended to present them two defenses: insanity and self-defense.

Dilmore’s testimony — more than three hours altogether — touched on both of those.

She said records from throughout Morris’ time in the military and beyond paint a portrait of consistent and pervasive mental illness, including persecutory delusions, distorted perceptions of reality and psychotic symptoms. He had been previously diagnosed with stress-related disorders, adjustment disorder and PTSD.

Dilmore said she watched the partial video of the incident recorded by two bystanders and, it appeared to her, that Morris was in a psychotic, manic state, and his delusions were being fueled by his belief that there was an imminent threat: the police.

His actions, she said, would have also been in response to what he perceived as a life-or-death situation.

Advertise with us

Kiray pointed to inconsistencies in Morris’ retelling of his symptoms and memories depending upon who he was talking to.

For example, he said, Morris told a detective Feb. 9, 2023, that he didn’t know his mother called 911 the day of the shooting. An hour and six minutes earlier, he said, Morris had told a social worker that his mother had called 911 that day.

Dilmore said she reviewed Morris’ military, medical and jail records, performed her own assessments over six interviews, and conducted interviews with multiple people close to Morris throughout his life.

Several of those interviewed were called to the stand earlier Wednesday, including Morris’ ex-wife. She told jurors that Morris “wasn’t the same Johnathan” after he returned from six months deployed to Afghanistan.

Anais Badnell, a fellow Marine, said she met Morris when they were stationed at bases not far from each other in North Carolina.

Advertise with us

When they married in 2013, she said, Morris was happy, active and healthy. Once he was deployed, she said, she could tell something was wrong when she talked to him on the phone.

“I could hear in his voice he was going through something he didn’t want to tell me,” she said.

Things worsened when he returned home early to help care for Badnell while she was “going through her own” mental health issues. She said she would wake up and find Morris hiding under their bed.

His ex-fiancé, Arylin Ballesteros, testified to similar behaviors. She met Morris in 2019 at a San Diego Starbucks, and they moved to Florida in 2022.

She said he had trouble falling asleep, suffered nightmares, talked in his sleep, and would often wake with a start and not know where he was or who she was.

Advertise with us

She said Morris put cameras all throughout their small two-bedroom apartment, and he covered the windows with sheets and blankets. Sometimes, he believed she was trying to poison him; she always knew when because he refused to drink water from the apartment or eat the breakfast she had made him.

Ballesteros testified that Morris once called 911 because he believed there was an intruder in their home. She recalled him trying to chase an intruder but no one was there.

Testimony could conclude Thursday afternoon.