George Edward Tyler Jr. took several short breaths to stop from crying.
“We called him Lovie,” he said of his brother, Johnathan Morris, who is on trial for the Feb. 6, 2023, shooting that killed McKeesport Police Officer Sean Sluganski and wounded Officer Chuck Thomas Jr. Morris.
“He was just a loving person since he was a baby,” Tyler testified Thursday during day nine of the trial. Closing arguments in the case are scheduled for Friday.
That person changed when Morris returned to Pittsburgh, he said.
When he stepped off the bus, Tyler said, his brother was different — unshaven and some 30 pounds lighter, a far cry from the body-building physique that once scored well in national competitions.
At one point, Morris suspected that someone was poisoning his food, Tyler said.
Read More
He described his brother’s new aggressiveness and his fear. A thunderstorm would send him ducking for cover, Tyler said.
Tyler, his mother and two other brothers had gathered at her house on Feb. 6 to attempt an “intervention.”
“We were going to get him some help.”
The attempt was brief, he said.
In a 911 call that his mother, former McKeesport police officer Candace Tyler placed shortly after noon that day, she said Morris was being violent and suffering from post-traumatic stress disorder. She asked for medics to assist with obtaining an involuntary commitment, but the call taker told her police had to respond to such calls.
As Candance Tyler prepared to get the paperwork to have Morris committed, she told her son, George Tyler, to watch Morris.
“When I left the house, I felt like all of us was going to work together,” Tyler said of the family and the police.
When Thomas, who was following Morris in his patrol car, began to rev his engine and drive up on the sidewalk of Grandview Avenue to get closer to Morris, Tyler grew worried.
Morris said that “he was running out of time,” his brother recalled.
At one point, Morris dropped his phone while running and Thomas picked it up and waved it around, to try to lure Morris back, Tyler said.
“Thomas kept messing with him,” he said. “That’s when I realized they weren’t there to help.”
Tyler said he was trying to keep his eyes on his brother, as his mother instructed.
He saw Morris fire shots into the patrol car and then take off.
He saw shots fired back at his brother, he said. Then Morris disappeared from view.
When Tyler caught up with him, he found his brother lying on the ground surrounded by blood.
He said he didn’t know if his brother was alive. And that he didn’t know that Sluganski was dead.
“I didn’t know. I just kept my eye on my brother the whole time,” he said.
The defense sought to establish that Morris’s known paranoia about police, his PTSD from his deployment to Afghanistan, and his training as a Marine to respond to danger, warranted a different approach than the one Thomas chose that day.
But a witness that the prosecution called as an expert in the use of force found that the officers behaved appropriately given the information they received from the 911 call and what they observed once at the scene.
Much of the testimony on Thursday attempted to parse the legal definitions of Morris’s mental state at the time of the shooting.
Dr. Bruce Wright, a psychiatrist and expert for the prosecution, explained that “insanity” is a binary state, not a spectrum.
Wright, who examined Morris’s medical records, Navy documents, and interviewed Morris four times by video jail, agreed that he had mental illnesses: schizoaffective disorder, post-traumatic stress disorder, and cannabis use disorder.
Wright noted Morris’s paranoia, which seemed to focus on police and members of his family, whom he thought were stealing from him and trying to kill him.
He said this constituted a “partial impairment,” but not a total break from reality.
“Insanity is an absolute,” he said. “You either don’t know what you’re doing or you don’t know it’s wrong.”
Morris “knew what he was doing,” Wright said.
Wright also questioned Morris’s memory lapses, which did not follow a consistent pattern and increased with time, something Wright said was not typical of trauma-induced memory loss.
“Being psychotic does not equate with insanity,” he said.
Wright said that instead of being unaware of what he had done, Morris made a number of conflicting statements that suggested the opposite — “he indicated several times that he was sorry” and told a detective that “I didn’t mean to hurt nobody” and “I didn’t meant to shoot those officers.”
Morris told some interviewers that he remembered shooting another office, Lt. Robert Eastman. To others he said he didn’t, according to court testimony.
“He’s given a different account of the offense every time he talked about (it),” he said.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.