ORLANDO, Fla. — This year’s winter meetings were absolutely different for the Pirates, at least in tone. Time will tell whether their offseason accomplishments match the level of urgency they seemed to convey during this year’s event.
Over three days at the Signia by Hilton Orlando Bonnet Creek, many around the sport did notice a change with the Pirates, one that had them casting a wide net regarding potential free agent signings or potential trades to improve the offense.
Along the way, the Pirates made a four-year, $125 million offer to Kyle Schwarber that publicly affirmed what many privately perceived: Pittsburgh knows it has needs and apparently will be more aggressive than many are accustomed to when addressing them.
“We’re looking to seize an opportunity,” Pirates general manager Ben Cherington said. “We believe we have the foundation. We have to add to it. We believe we can win in 2026 if we do the necessary work.”
The Post-Gazette was there the entire time, talking to club officials, agents, scouts and others within the baseball world. Here’s what we learned:
If not Schwarber …
The Pirates never had a realistic chance of landing Schwarber, though their offer was competitive. What it told us, however, was that the Pirates were willing to pay one player $31.25 million per season to play baseball for them.
Read More
Hard to say that’s a bad thing.
Throughout the offseason, the Pirates have expressed interest in a number of hitters, including Jorge Polanco, Willie Castro, Ryan O’Hearn, Kazuma Okamoto and Munetaka Murakami. They've been linked to trade pieces in Ketel Marte, Brandon Lowe, Jarren Duran, Yandy Diaz, Alec Bohm and Steven Kwan.
Again, those are only a select few that've become public.
The point: If the Pirates are comfortable spending $31.25 million on one guy, they won't be excluded from many conversations. The question becomes fit, balancing a trade and the willingness of free agents to come to Pittsburgh.
But the Pirates' actions have led a bunch of people within the game to believe they're genuinely serious about getting something done. It's either a massive sell job or legitimate, and even those outside the organization believe it’s the latter.
"I'm confident we’re gonna be able to land some stuff that makes us feel better about the team, specifically the position player group and the depth of the lineup going into spring training," Cherington said.
‘Find a way to unlock’ Cruz
Despite the sizable focus on outside additions, manager Don Kelly and Cherington also addressed one of the biggest storylines from within the current team: getting more from Oneil Cruz.
Their center fielder saw his wins above replacement (per Baseball Reference) drop from 2.5 in 2024 to 0.3. It should have gone the other direction. His OPS dropped from .773 to .676, and Cruz ran into myriad issues: too much swing and miss, prolonged slumps, a lack of focus and some ugly defensive moments.
It simply can’t continue. Kelly and Cherington know that.
“I don’t think there’s any kind of magic to it,” Cherington said. “It’s continuing to try and find the right relationships around him that can help him organize his day in the best possible way. When he does that, he can be the best player on the field.
“I’ll continue to be stubborn on the belief that there is another level for him and believe that Oneil is a good person who does care and wants to be good. It’s just going to look a little bit different than it does for other guys. Our job is to find a way to unlock that.”
Cherington talking about finding the right relationships around Cruz was telling. One of the best things the Pirates did for Cruz’s development was signing Carlos Santana prior to the 2023 season, though they screwed up by trading Santana too early and not bringing him back the following winter.
It doesn’t have to be Santana. It absolutely should not be a babysitter. But the Pirates need additional leaders, and it’s a make-or-break year when it comes to the maturation of a tantalizingly talented player in Cruz.
Skenes’ presence growing
Paul Skenes’ most important pitch for the Pirates might not come on the mound.
The Post-Gazette reported Tuesday that Skenes had volunteered his services to Cherington, offering to call potential free agents and explain why he thinks they should consider signing with the Pirates.
It could be helpful. It’s hard to imagine someone clicking ignore on that call. But there’s a bigger-picture takeaway, as well: Skenes’ shadow, in Pittsburgh and beyond, continues to grow at a rapid rate.
The presence of Skenes should — and hopefully will — impact what the Pirates do this season. He’s become the face of their franchise. Along with being one of the most popular players in MLB, he’s a member of the MLB Players’ Association subcommittee, a key figure with a potential labor war looming.
Leave most of that for another day. But Skenes involving himself on the free agent front could be the type of game changer the Pirates need.
Dealing starting pitching
The Pirates have already subtracted from their starting pitching depth by dealing Johan Oviedo to the Red Sox. They say they’re willing to make more deals from that depth, though they’ve also made clear they’d want the return to improve their offense in 2026 if they deal pitching.
It’s also been more quiet on Mitch Keller than some were expecting, at least publicly. While a bidding war could be playing out behind the scenes, Keller hasn’t been at the forefront of Pirates-related conversations.
The biggest takeaway is the Pirates don’t want to limit their options, though they have made very clear that Skenes isn’t going anywhere. Reports from The Athletic have indicated that the Pirates are most willing to listen to offers for Keller or right-hander Mike Burrows, who isn’t arbitration-eligible until 2029. The same report says they’ll listen on Bubba Chandler or Jared Jones, though they’d need a major return.
Cherington said the Pirates would need to “backfill” if they do trade a pitcher. That would likely come in free agency. But he also reiterated multiple times what the Pirates are looking for in return if they do trade starting pitching: a player that improves the lineup in 2026.
They’re not pursuing shortstops
The Pirates have been linked to just about everyone on the free agent and trade markets, as the team has some spending room for signings and the prospect capital for deals. But there have been two exceptions:
1. The Pirates haven’t been linked to starting pitching, which makes sense given their depth.
2. No shortstops have been mentioned, even as short-term solutions.
The obvious reason is No. 1 prospect Konnor Griffin. Both Kelly and Cherington attempted to slow talk that Griffin will be the opening day shortstop. He’s 19, after all, and hasn’t played above Double-A. But with all he’s done and, maybe more tellingly, what the Pirates aren’t doing, it seems like there’s a real chance Griffin is the immediate answer.
Cherington was also asked about extension talks with Griffin. Those haven’t happened yet, but December also isn’t the typical time for that conversation. It’s more likely sometime during spring training.
Both sides would be interested in those conversations. Brewers outfielder Jackson Chourio signed an eight-year, $82 million extension before his major league debut, and the Pirates would surely love to sign Griffin to something similar. However, given how the early extension market has developed since Chourio signed, that price may not be enough to get a deal done.
Deciphering ‘The Password’
At first glance, it seemed like the Pirates’ trade of Oviedo (and two minor leaguers) was for their opening day left fielder. While new Pirate Jhostynxon Garcia could be that, the Pirates seem to see him more as a player for the future instead of the de facto 2026 outfield answer.
“We do think he has a chance to impact 2026,” Cherington said Monday. “Just as much, this was a baseball trade that we just believed in. We think it fits in the strategy, but it’s not the end of the strategy. We’re going to keep going. So it’s kind of a baseball trade inside the broader offseason strategy.”
A “baseball trade,” as Cherington put it, is generally when two teams trade from positions of strength for positions of need. The Pirates need young outfielders with power and upside. That’s what Garcia is. So while Garcia will be a part of the 2026 Pirates, he’s not slotted as the starter quite yet.
Soto a smart first step
The Pirates made their first free agent signing on Tuesday night, signing left-handed reliever Gregory Soto to a one-year, $7.75 million deal, per a source. It’s a good first step, even if the Pirates still have needs.
The bullpen needed both a back-end reliever and a left-hander, and Soto checks both boxes. He’s a two-time All-Star who has made 60-plus appearances in each of the past five seasons.
There’s still plenty to do, but Soto was a smart first signing.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.