ORLANDO, Fla. — The Pirates made their first signing of the 2025-26 offseason on Tuesday night. While it wasn’t a bat, it was a move that improves the 2026 Pirates.

On Tuesday night, the Pirates signed left-handed reliever Gregory Soto to a one-year, $7.75 million contract, a source confirmed to the Post-Gazette. Soto, 30, is a two-time All-Star and a seven-year major league veteran.

Most importantly, he fills a need for the Pirates. The Pirates are incredibly heavy on right-handed pitchers, to the point where just two of the 21 pitchers on Pittsburgh’s 40-man roster are left-handed. A left-handed reliever was a 2026 necessity, which general manager Ben Cherington admitted when he spoke to reporters on Monday.

“[The bullpen] is something we'd like to add to,” Cherington said. “Leverage and maybe attacking left-hand hitters, too, whether that's actual left-hand pitchers or righties that get lefties out, I think probably those are the two things that we could add and strengthen the 'pen, those would be two things we'd like to check. … I'd be surprised if we don't add to the pitching group in some way.”

Advertise with us

Soto checks both boxes.

The lefty made 70 appearances in 2025, pitching for both the Orioles and the Mets. In 60⅓ innings, he finished with a 4.18 ERA and 70 strikeouts. He was better in Baltimore, which dealt him at the trade deadline, as his strikeout numbers dipped from 10.9 per nine innings to 9.8 and his hits allowed per nine rose from 7.2 to 12.4. At each stop, he kept walks and homers low.

However, he did one thing better than anyone the Pirates currently have: he gets lefties out. In 2025, left-handed batters hit .192 against Soto with a .549 OPS. In his seven-year career, Soto has allowed 34 homers, a number that’s impressive in itself. Just seven of those were allowed to lefties.

Soto projects as someone who will pitch at the back end of the Pirates bullpen. Soto, Isaac Mattson and Dennis Santana project as the Pirates top three leverage relievers, with Justin Lawrence likely to fill in if he can continue his 2025 effectiveness.

Soto and Santana have particularly strong numbers against left-handed hitters, while Mattson was dominant against right-handers. Manager Don Kelly will be able to play matchups with the back end of his bullpen if all goes to plan.

Advertise with us

The Pirates’ new addition probably isn’t their ninth inning option, even if he will almost surely be their most expensive pitcher out of the bullpen. He had 30 saves in 2022, but hasn’t been a team’s main closer since. He also went 2-11 that year, though it was for a 66-96 Tigers team.

However, the Pirates weren’t looking for a closer. Santana should still get the majority of save opportunities, though baseball is moving away from teams having a set closer. The Pirates were looking for someone to get lefties out and to get the game to Santana in the ninth inning, and Soto should fill that role.

If you project the Pirates bullpen in March 2026 as of Dec. 9, 2025, it will surely include Soto, Santana, Mattson, Lawrence and Carmen Mlodzinski. Evan Sisk, the Pirates’ only other lefty, presumably gets another spot. The other two spots would go to some combination of Kyle Nicolas, Yohan Ramirez, Chase Shugart, Brandan Bidois and Ryan Harbin, possibly with a slight edge to Ramirez of those options given the fact that he can pitch multiple innings, he strikes people out, and the Pirates cannot option him to the minor leagues without placing him on waivers first.

Santana, Mattson and Lawrence are the Pirates’ top-three right-handed leverage relievers, with Santana as the Pirates’ top option and Mattson and Lawrence playing matchups. Soto should face opponents’ best lefties, which could be in the seventh, eighth or ninth innings, depending on the game script.

Sisk, or any other lefty the Pirates could still sign, still has a role getting lefties out. However, Soto will be relied upon for the best lefties and more important moments.

Advertise with us

Mlodzinski was dominant in a multi-inning role, especially after he moved out of the rotation. He has his most value there. The other right-handers — Nicolas, Ramirez, Shugart, Bidois, Harbin, etc. — will be relied upon to get to Santana, Mattson and Lawrence.

While few will confuse the Pirates’ bullpen with the Dodgers, who signed Mets closer Edwin Diaz to a three-year, $69 million deal on Tuesday morning, the Pirates do have some intriguing pieces. The Pirates still have more moves to make to be competitive in 2026, but there’s plenty to like about their first signing this offseason.