ORLANDO, Fla. — The cost of the Pirates’ major league payroll could and should exceed $100 million, provided they accomplish everything they want to this offseason. But the price of failing would almost assuredly be worse, at least in terms of lost jobs and fan sentiment with the franchise.

This isn’t your average Pirates offseason — they made a respectable offer to Kyle Schwarber, for crying out loud — and it naturally doesn’t come with average consequences.

The stakes have been raised. There’s professed urgency. There have been a boatload of internal conversations, as well as trade talks and Pittsburgh expressing interest in free agents. Multiple people I’ve spoken with around the industry genuinely believe the Pirates are trying.

It’s about time, yes. But it’s also about that time for general manager Ben Cherington, president Travis Williams and even owner Bob Nutting. There’s simply no turning back from what has been leaked into the national baseball world.

Advertise with us

“We’re looking to seize an opportunity,” Cherington said Monday at Signia by Hilton Orlando Bonnet Creek, site of MLB’s winter meetings. “We believe we have the foundation. We have to add to it. We believe we can win in 2026 if we do the necessary work.

“Part of that is going to be roster-building. Part of that is going to be building the team culture and executing well. We’re pursuing a whole host of free agent and trade options as part of that strategy.”

Speaking with reporters inside one of the team’s suites, Cherington outlined how the Pirates are approaching this offseason:

• They’re casting a wide net but also shooting high with free agency and trades.

• The No. 1 goal is improving the lineup, although Cherington isn’t specifically targeting power bats or on-base percentage.

Advertise with us

• They’d like to get a little more left-handed given PNC Park’s dimensions. But it also won’t preclude them from adding a righty.

• They’d like to add a reliever or two and might consider trading a second starting pitcher, although Cherington added “we’ll have a high bar” and return must be a bona fide MLB bat.

There are logical parameters Cherington presented, but at the same time, there’s only so much he can say at this point. As Williams told the Post-Gazette recently, talk is cheap. The Pirates don’t necessarily need to act before Wednesday, but they will need to kick it into gear here soon.

“There are a number of options out there for us,” Cherington said. “We just need to stay on all of them to the point that it becomes clear, ‘OK, here's the price we believe makes sense. Let's get ready to say ‘yes’ and go execute on it.'"

Can you believe we’re here?

After the season, there were legitimate questions regarding Cherington’s job status. Now, the Pirates have offered Schwarber and they’ve expressed interest in popular Japanese sluggers Kazuma Okamoto and Munetaka Murakami, as well as quality MLB hitters in Jorge Polanco, Ryan O’Hearn, Brandon Lowe (trade), Ketel Marte (trade) and others.

Advertise with us

Cherington explained what looks like a hard right turn as a natural part of the offseason unfolding. “I personally don’t feel any different than I did at the end of the season,” he insisted.

OK, but we’re still entering Year 7 of this regime’s tenure, the high-water mark has been 76 wins, there’s an MLB strike looming, and everything we’ve seen and heard indicates they’ll operate differently this offseason.

Good ... but there’s a lot to do.

And this group can ill afford a misstep this large when it comes to adding offense, especially with the Paul Skenes Clock ticking and the Pirates getting fans’ hopes up by flirting with some of the best available players.

It’s pretty simple. They better deliver, or it could get ugly.

Advertise with us

“Yes, there's urgency,” Cherington said. “We need to deliver for people that care about the Pirates. That's motivating.”

It’s also an opportunity and something that could frame what the Pirates do this week. At one point Cherington was asked what his sales pitch might sound like for prospective free agents. The GM focused on three things:

• The pitching staff in place means the Pirates aren’t that far away.

• Pittsburgh is a great place to live and play — and would be even better if the Pirates found a way to win.

• There’s a chance here to be part of something unique.

Advertise with us

Given all that has already been discussed, the Pirates must hope they find the proper partners to ensure their bet this winter ultimately pays off.

“I don’t have a sense if it’s going to happen in the next three days, next week or next month,” Cherington said. “But I’m confident we’re going to be able to land some stuff that makes us feel better about the team, specifically the position player group and the depth of the lineup going into spring training.

“We believe the best way to do that is to be engaged on as many fronts as possible.”