The tone was set in early October. Canyon and Carter Swartz, twin brothers from Carmichaels, rode the T into Downtown and made their way to City Hall. Together they stood on the front steps, boasting signs — one of them with spelling errors — that attempted to send a clear message.
Similar to many other Pirates fans, they were fed up with the state of the franchise. They were desperate for change. And when it was announced that both general manager Ben Cherington and manager Derek Shelton would be returning for the 2025 season, they felt as though something had to be done.
“We’re tired of this,” a frustrated Canyon, still proudly wearing his Pirates cap, told the Post-Gazette that afternoon. “We can’t go through another year of the same nonsense.”
Despite the demonstration catching the attention of some on social media, few people joined the Swartz twins that day. But as a new year arrived, the Pirates would soon learn many shared their same level of vitriol toward their organization.
The Pirates’ 2025 season was a disaster from the very beginning, filled with on-field disappointments and off-field public-relations gaffes that generated more wrath throughout the fan base than possibly ever before. In the end, the team finished in last place for the 11th time in PNC Park’s 25-year history as attendance for home games dropped 11.4% from the season prior.
While the Pirates hope to leave this year’s many embarrassing moments in the past, it’s worth noting how things sunk to this new low.
Read More
Below is a detailed timeline of the many chaotic moments that unfolded throughout 2025:
Jan. 18-19, PiratesFest: Typically known as a fun, free, family-friendly event that aims to create excitement for the season ahead, the two-day PiratesFest event at David L. Lawrence Convention Center brought the Pirates a slew of embarrassing moments. The most noteworthy moment came on Day 1, when fans pulled no punches during a public Q&A with Cherington, Shelton and team president Travis Williams. Supporters questioned the club’s low payroll, referred to past player acquisitions as “hot garbage” and expressed their desire for owner Bob Nutting to sell the team. While the trio on stage, along with team announcer Greg Brown, was able to ease some tensions, the embarrassment continued later on. The Pirates posted a picture of Andrew McCutchen, a long-time face of the franchise, signing autographs in front of a sign with his last name misspelled. A day later, fans posted on social media that they had been sold soda that was past its expiration date. The event as a whole generated national headlines and set the stage for more to come.
Feb. 11, Horwitz reports to camp injured: On the evening of Feb. 11, less than 24 hours before the official start day of spring training, the Post-Gazette learned first baseman Spencer Horwitz was expected to miss significant time due to a wrist injury that required surgery. The Pirates confirmed the Post-Gazette’s reporting the following morning, saying the 27-year-old underwent surgery the week prior to “address chronic symptoms” in his right wrist and his timetable to return to gameplay was six to eight weeks. Horwitz’s injury was significant news, as he represented perhaps the biggest move the club made that offseason, acquiring him in a trade from Cleveland for right-hander Luis Ortiz, along with two pitching prospects. Horwitz wouldn’t play his first game for the Pirates until May 17 but ultimately ended up being the most productive hitter in the lineup.
March 16, Jared Jones suffers season-ending injury: The Pirates lost right-hander Jared Jones, one of the top performers in last year’s rotation, for the 2025 season less than two weeks before opening day. Jones informed the Pirates he was experiencing soreness in his right elbow on March 16. The team made the news of his injury public three days later. On March 26, a day before opening day, Pirates senior director of sports medicine Todd Tomczyk announced Jones had been diagnosed with a UCL sprain. The plan was originally for him to avoid surgery, although that changed on May 21, when he underwent an operation that repaired his UCL and ended any hope of him pitching in 2025. Jones last spoke with reporters last week at PNC Park, informing them he has started a throwing program. The Pirates hope to have him back on the mound sometime early next season.
March 27-31, Struggles in South Beach: The Pirates started their regular season in disastrous fashion, losing on a walk-off hit in three of their first four games against the Miami Marlins. Opening day was especially bad, as relievers Colin Holderman and David Bednar, a duo that struggled mightily in the back half of 2024, allowed a three-run lead to slip away. But pitching wasn’t the only problem. The Pirates were sloppy in all areas. Endy Rodriguez looked overwhelmed at first base, perhaps due to only playing one game at the position throughout spring training. Oneil Cruz made multiple mental miscues in center field, a theme that remained present throughout the season. The club struggled to come up with timely hits and made costly outs on the bases. For many, it felt as though last year’s second-half collapse had never ended.
April 1, Bednar optioned: After refusing to name him the club’s closer throughout spring training, the Pirates took things a step further on April 1, optioning Bednar, a two-time All-Star, to Triple-A Indianapolis. The move was made just four games into the season, although Bednar was the losing pitcher in two of those contests. The good news was Bednar wasn’t in the minor leagues for long. He returned to the club on April 19 and pitched at his old, elite form until he was traded to the Yankees on July 31.
April 4, The home opener: The day began with a plane flying over PNC Park displaying a sign that read, “SELL THE TEAM BOB.” A day normally known to be one of the happiest on the baseball calendar, Pirates fans seemingly showed up frustrated that afternoon on the North Shore. Shelton and a few players were booed during the pregame introduction ceremony. Nutting doubled down on his commitment to winning, telling the Post-Gazette and MLB.com he had done everything he could “to provide the tools and resources to the team.” His words couldn’t have come at a worse time, as the Pirates, already 2-5 to start the year, were blown out 9-4 by the Yankees. A sold-out crowd at PNC Park collectively chanted, “Sell the team!” multiple times throughout the game, which became a frequent theme throughout the first half of the season, especially when the stadium was full. Nutting himself gained a firsthand glimpse of the fans’ fury, as one man filmed himself following the Pirates owner throughout the rotunda in left field, hurling a slew of questions and jeers his way.
April 5-6, Surfside vs. Clemente: A few other big observations came from the home opener. The first was fans noticing the placement of an advertisement for Surfside, an alcoholic beverage company from Philadelphia, on the right-field wall. The ad, which was a 10-plus-foot-tall can of the drink, was placed in a spot that previously displayed a logo that honored Pirates legend Roberto Clemente. Many took issue with the ad placement, including Clemente’s son, Roberto Clemente Jr., whose reaction on X was viewed by more than 3 million users in its first 48 hours after being published. The Pirates released their first statement on the matter on April 5. Clemente Jr. issued a statement the next morning, which led to a second statement from the Pirates and ultimately the return of the old logo.
April 8, Bucco Bricks: Just a few days after the Surfside incident was resolved, the Pirates found themselves in even hotter water due to another public-relations blunder. When fans arrived at PNC Park for the first homestand of the season, some noticed the missing bricks in front of the home-plate entrance. The bricks had been there since the opening of PNC Park, displaying custom messages from fans who paid to have their personal mark left in front of their team’s home venue. And when they were no longer there, questions began to arise. On April 8, a report from KDKA-TV showed the bricks had been shipped off to a recycling center in Reserve Township. The Pirates, after failing to give any notice ahead of time, rushed to explain the bricks were being replaced and the messages on the bricks would return to the ballpark in a new display built to better withstand the elements of Pittsburgh’s weather. While more specifics on said display were offered as the year progressed, the season ended without the new display being finished.
April 19, Skenes bobblehead day: Pirates fans arrived to the North Shore hours before the gates at PNC Park were scheduled to open with hopes of securing the game’s promotional giveaway, a Paul Skenes bobblehead. Lines stretched across the Clemente Bridge and into Downtown. The frenzy caught the attention of many, including Nutting, who had the Pirates announce all fans with a ticket to the game would receive a bobblehead rather than just the first 20,000 through the gate. That, however, was the last moment of positivity for the Pirates that afternoon. Tensions within the clubhouse were revealed a few hours before first pitch, when Andrew McCutchen responded to a post on X claiming he had the day off. McCutchen later provided additional context to his post, voicing disagreement with Shelton’s lineup construction. But McCutchen wasn’t the only Pirate to make waves on social media that day. Tommy Pham also generated attention, as fans spotted him standing outside the ballpark in team workout gear, seemingly waiting to pick up a delivery order just 90 minutes before first pitch. Pham was in the starting lineup that day. The game itself provided further embarrassment. Skenes’ quality start — two earned runs allowed over seven innings — was wasted, as the Pirates offense was blanked in a 3-0 loss. The result went on to be a recurring theme for the 2025 Pirates. In the late going of the game, the sold-out crowd again started “Sell the Team” chants.
April 23, “The streak” begins: On April 23, the Pirates defeated the Angels by a final score of 3-0. The shutout win secured their first road series victory of the season. But it also marked the start of yet another embarrassing highlight. For the next 25 games, the Pirates failed to score more than four runs. The 26-game streak tied the 1969 California Angels and the 1931 Boston Braves for the longest of its kind in the game’s modern era. The Pirates finally tallied a five-run effort on May 22 against the Brewers, plating their fifth and final run in the bottom of the ninth inning, in an 8-5 loss at PNC Park.
April 25, Pham suspended: In the same game the infamous 26-game streak began, Pham earned himself a one-game suspension due to an altercation with Angels fans. The incident occurred after Pham fielded a ball hit to the corner in left field. One fan seemingly reached over the wall and touched Pham in the midst of the play. After the play was over, Pham was seen conversing with fans along the third-base line, near the left-field foul pole. Pham then made what the league defined to be "inappropriate actions towards fans.” The suspension was announced two days later on April 25. Pham appealed the suspension, but it was upheld. He served the one-game suspension on May 12 against the Mets. He was also fined an undisclosed amount.
April 30, Fan falls from stands: Perhaps the scariest moment in the history of PNC Park unfolded on April 30, when in the midst of play a fan fell off the Clemente wall and onto the warning track in right field. It happened in the bottom of the seventh inning. McCutchen smacked a two-out ground ball up the middle, which bounced off Cubs shortstop Dansby Swanson into shallow right-center field. The hit scored a pair of runs, putting Pittsburgh ahead 4-3. But the entire ballpark fell completely silent just seconds later, when a fan could be seen laying motionless on the field. The man would later be identified as Kavan Markwood, a then-20-year-old from McKeesport.
Markwood, seated in the front row of the Clemente wall with his girlfriend and a pair of friends, lost his balance while celebrating McCutchen’s hit. He flipped over the front of the right-field wall, falling 21 feet onto the warning-track dirt. Training staff from both the Pirates and Cubs, along with emergency medical services on site, rushed to save Markwood’s life. He was rushed to the hospital, where he remained in critical condition for the next few days. Markwood suffered numerous injuries, which included a concussion and a broken back, neck and clavicle. The Pirates celebrated Markwood’s recovery from the incident last weekend, when they hosted him at PNC Park and had him throw out the first pitch before their Saturday evening contest against the Athletics.
May 4, Usher fights fan in stadium: As the Pirates wrapped up their third homestand of the season by getting swept in three games by the Padres, one more moment of humiliation occurred before the club hit the road to St. Louis. Following the end of their 4-0 loss on May 4, while kids were running the bases on the field, a physical altercation took place in the concourse along the first-base line between a fan and a stadium employee. A video on social media showed the fan antagonizing the stadium employee for minutes, egging him on to start a fight. Eventually, the stadium employee reacted, striking the fan multiple times. After the two were briefly separated, the fan then spit blood on the stadium employee. In response, the stadium employee removed his belt and began whipping the fan before they were separated again. The fight received national attention. The Pirates announced on May 6 the stadium employee had been suspended for his actions.
May 8, Shelton fired: On May 8, after losing seven straight and boasting a 12-26 record on the season, the Pirates announced Shelton had been fired from his position as the club’s manager. Hired prior to the start of the 2020 season, Shelton finished with a career record of 306-440. His final win as the Pirates manager came on April 30, the evening of Markwood’s fall. The Pirates never achieved a winning record under Shelton’s lead, nor did they ever finish above fourth place. The team named Don Kelly as Shelton’s replacement. That part of the announcement came with a bit of a surprise, as Kelly was not given the "interim" tag.
May 10, Kelly ejected with no replacement: Formerly Shelton’s bench coach, Kelly needed a bit of time to redesign his coaching staff after being tasked with taking over. For the first few games with Kelly at the helm, the Pirates played without an established bench coach, meaning there was no clear No. 2 on the staff should Kelly, now the manager, be ejected from a game. That logistical flaw was exposed on May 10, when Kelly, just two games into his new role, was ejected for arguing balls and strikes. As he left the field, Pirates players, staff and team employees were left wondering who would take over for the remainder of the game. Third-base coach Mike Rabelo ended up being the answer, managing the Pirates until the end of their 3-2 loss to the Braves.
June 19, Santana takes swipe at fan: Kelly’s fire gave new life to the Pirates. The club finished 15-15 in his first full month at the helm, which included a sweep over the Phillies, who were in first place in the NL East. The switch had provided a much-needed breath of fresh air to a clubhouse that had been visibly tense throughout the first month of the season. Weeks had gone by since the Pirates last made a mistake that received national attention. But that changed on June 19 in Detroit.
During the second game of a doubleheader at Comerica Park, relief pitcher Dennis Santana was seen taking a swing at fans in the outfield stands who looked to be heckling the right-hander while he was in the bullpen. Santana apologized for his actions after the game, which the Pirates won 8-4 in 10 innings. He received a four-game suspension for his actions, which was reduced to three games after an appeal was made. He was also fined an undisclosed amount. Santana wasn’t the only Pirates player who had an issue with Tigers fans that evening. Pham also had a moment of contention, taking it upon himself to stop play in the top of the 10th inning to have three fans behind home plate ejected.
June 20, Cruz disregards ground ball: One day after Santana’s incident, the Pirates suffered on-field embarrassment in the first inning of their series opener against the Rangers at PNC Park. Just two batters into the game, left fielder Sam Haggerty smacked a single to Cruz in center field. The ball snuck under Cruz’s glove and continued rolling toward the center-field wall. Cruz, however, made no effort to run the ball down. As Cruz watched Bryan Reynolds hustle from right field to field the ball, the Rangers tallied an easy run off his carelessness. A few days later, Cruz was benched after slowing up while running down the first-base line on a double-play ball. Kelly said the decision was centered around Cruz’s “energy and effort.” Cruz took responsibility for the mistake but noted his decision to slow up was because he believed there were already two outs in the inning. Cruz was in the lineup the following afternoon, a game the Pirates lost 4-2.
June 22, Pham highlights vision issues: For the first two months of the season, Pham, who signed a one-year, $4.025 million deal with the Pirates in February, was among the worst players in MLB. His .237 slugging percentage was the lowest among the 209 major league hitters with at least 150 plate appearances. His wRC+ (46) and fWAR (minus-0.8) also ranked within the bottom 10 of that group. But in mid-June, things started to turn around for the veteran outfielder.
On June 22, Pham told reporters he had been experiencing issues with his vision and those issues had just recently been resolved. Pham, who has dealt with a unique vision disorder known as keratoconus throughout his entire career, had been adjusting his contact prescription throughout the first two months of the season. The Pirates, aware of Pham’s issues, still chose to play Pham consistently, which resulted in the aforementioned poor production.
After noting his vision issues had been fixed, Pham quickly became the best hitter in the Pirates lineup. From June 22-Aug. 22, Pham’s .345 batting average was second best among qualified big-league hitters, trailing only Nick Kurtz of the Athletics. He also seventh in on-base percentage (.408), eighth in wRC+ (166) and 10th in slugging percentage (.568) over that stretch. It’s worth noting Pham dramatically regressed at the plate in September. He entered the final week of the regular season with a 91 wRC+ on the year, meaning his production overall has been 9% below a league-average hitter’s.
July 4-6, Scoreless in Seattle: The best stretch of the Pirates’ season came on June 27-July 2, when they won six straight games at PNC Park, thanks to a pair of three-game sweeps over the Mets and Cardinals, two clubs that were in the thick of the National League wild card race at the time. But similar to past instances, that good moment was quickly ruined. After holding the Cardinals scoreless for the entirety of their three-game sweep, the Pirates suffered a similar fate from July 4-6 in Seattle, suffering three straight shutout losses to the Mariners. Five more losses followed their scoreless weekend in Seattle.
July 18-20, Swept by White Sox: The All-Star break was a good stretch for the Pirates. Konnor Griffin received plenty of attention in the MLB All-Star Futures Game. Cruz delivered a show in the Home Run Derby. Skenes threw a perfect first frame for the National League in the midsummer classic. But when the club returned to Pittsburgh to start the second half of its season, more humiliation ensued. The Pirates were swept by the White Sox in dominant fashion, getting outscored by a total of 27-7 over three games at PNC Park. The low point of the weekend came on Saturday, when more “Sell the Team” chants erupted among a sold-out crowd, most of whom were in attendance for the Mac Miller bobblehead giveaway. It should be noted the Pirates played much better after the White Sox debacle. The club responded by winning eight of its next nine, which included sweeps over the Tigers at home and the Giants at Oracle Park, their first road sweep of the year.
July 31, Deadline day: On July 30, just before the start of the final contest of their three-game sweep over the Giants, the Pirates traded Ke’Bryan Hayes to the Cincinnati Reds for left-hander Taylor Rogers, infield prospect Sammy Stafura and cash considerations. The deal was notable due to the departure of Hayes, the first financial commitment the club made in the Cherington era. While the Hayes trade received mixed reviews, the activity on the following afternoon created an uproar within the fan base. First, the Pirates moved Bednar to the Yankees for prospects Rafael Flores, Edgleen Perez and Brian Sanchez. Flores was the highest-rated player among the group, deemed the No. 8 prospect within the Yankees organization.
Next was a deal that sent left-hander Bailey Falter to the Royals for left-handed reliever Evan Sisk and minor leaguer Callan Moss, a High-A first baseman who went undrafted in 2024. If those two moves weren’t puzzling enough, fans were even more confused by the team’s decision to not trade Pham, Isiah Kiner-Falefa and Andrew Heaney, a trio of veterans on expiring contracts. Cherington, who had stated numerous times throughout July the goal was to improve the team’s ability to score runs, netted nine new players by the time the deadline expired. None of those nine newcomers joined the major league club in Denver on Aug. 1.
Aug. 1, Rockies win 17-16: Twenty-four hours after the deadline chaos ended, the Pirates suffered their most embarrassing loss of the season. After jumping ahead to a 9-0 lead in the top of the first inning, the Pirates looked to be en route to a sixth straight victory. Matched up against the Rockies, who boasted the worst record in MLB, Pittsburgh seemingly responded every time the opposition made a comeback push. A two-run homer by Yanquiel Fernandez made the score 16-12 in the bottom of the eighth inning. Santana took the mound in the bottom of the ninth, looking to maintain his club’s four-run lead. Instead, the Rockies rallied to score five runs, the final two coming on a game-winning, walk-off homer from Brenton Doyle. The two clubs combined for 40 hits that evening. The Rockies tallied another comeback win the next evening, rallying to win 8-5 after trailing 4-0 at the end of the fifth inning.
Aug. 12, Blown out by Brewers: While the meltdown in Colorado was their worst loss of the season, a 14-0 blowout to the Brewers on Aug. 12 was a close second. Not even Skenes could save the Pirates that evening. Milwaukee tagged the National League’s Cy Young favorite for four runs, all earned, over four innings. The Pirates bullpen struggled even more than Skenes, allowing 10 runs over the next four frames. Jared Triolo was tasked with finishing the game out for Pittsburgh, pitching the bottom of the eighth. The Pirates, meanwhile, tallied just four hits.
Aug. 18, Pham vs. Blue Jays: Pham delivered one final memorable moment on Aug. 18 with his antics during and after the club’s 5-2 win over the Blue Jays at PNC Park. It started in the bottom of the seventh inning, when Pham took issue with Toronto catcher Tyler Heineman questioning balls and strikes, something he later described as “disrespectful.” After drawing a walk, Pham flipped his bat and stared Heineman down, causing both benches to clear. While nothing more came of the situation on the field, Pham opened another can of worms after the game, saying Blue Jays third baseman Addison Barger “takes steroids.” Barger later clarified he was suspended 50 games in 2019 due to a banned stimulant rather than steroids. Pham, however, stood by his original remarks, telling MLB.com, “Let them know I speak in facts.”
Aug. 26, Heaney designated for assignment: Heaney, a veteran left-hander, was signed to a one-year, $5.25 million contract during spring training. The deal included performance incentive bonuses that, if maxed out, would earn him $750,000 in additional money. After starting the season on a high note, Heaney’s production plummeted in June. His poor performance tarnished his trade value, resulting in him not being moved at the deadline. The Pirates moved Heaney to the bullpen on Aug. 16, when he was just one inning shy of reaching a $50,000 bonus for eclipsing 120 innings of work. Heaney pitched just twice more in a Pirates uniform, recording a pair of outs in both outings. He was designated for assignment on Aug. 26 after reaching his bonus mark, although some claimed the Pirates prevented him from reaching further milestones. Heaney, however, frequently blamed himself for the situation, citing numerous times that his own poor play led to his demotion.
Sept. 2-4, Post-Dodgers sweep collapse: The Pirates opened the final month of the regular season with a three-game sweep over the Los Angeles Dodgers, who were in first place in the NL West. The sweep put the club’s record at 52-51 since Kelly took over as manager. But that winning record didn’t last very long. The Pirates went on to lose 12 of their next 13 games. A series win over the Athletics last weekend concluded their final homestand in 2025. Overall, the Pirates played well at their home ballpark, going 44-37 on the North Shore. But a disastrous record on the road, along with overall poor play at the start of the year, doomed the season before it could truly begin.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.