BRADENTON, Fla. — Last Tuesday evening, the Post-Gazette first reported that Spencer Horwitz, a first baseman the Pirates acquired via trade in December, was set to miss extended time this spring due to a right wrist injury that required surgery. The team confirmed Horwitz’s injury Wednesday morning, saying the 27-year-old underwent surgery last week to “address chronic symptoms,” and that his timetable to return to game play was six to eight weeks.
The news of Horwitz’s injury caused a stir among the Pirates’ fanbase. In what has been deemed by many as an uneventful offseason, Horwitz served as the club’s key pickup. And the idea of him being on the shelf due to a chronic injury before the 2025 season began only added additional fuel to their fire.
Despite general manager Ben Cherington holding a news conference Wednesday morning to provide further details on Horwitz’s injury, many remain confused on the specifics pertaining to the situation. How long has Horwitz had wrist issues? What information did the Pirates have on Horwitz’s injury history when he was acquired? Is this a new injury? And what is the latest on Horwitz’s status?
The Post-Gazette spoke with Horwitz on Sunday afternoon to gather these details. Below is what we have learned during the past week:
What did the Pirates know?
Howritz informed the Post-Gazette the issues with his right wrist began in September 2022 while playing for the Blue Jays’ Triple-A club in Buffalo. His injury was sustained while sliding head-first into second base in a game on Sept. 13 of that season.
“That’s what started it,” Horwitz said. “Since then, it’s been a battle.”
Read More
Horwitz was placed on the seven-day injured list five days later and did not play again that year. This incident remains the lone IL stint of his professional career.
Cherington explained the Pirates were aware of Horwitz’s chronic wrist issues but still felt comfortable trading for the first baseman based on the medical information they received from the Blue Jays at the time of the trade.
So what information did the Pirates have? On Friday, Cherington said the Pirates reviewed an MRI of Horwitz’s wrist that was taken at the end of the 2024 regular season, when they were looking to acquire him in December at the winter meetings.
Horwitz told the Post-Gazette this MRI took place in October and was done as an end-of-year check-in by the Blue Jays, not because there was fear of a new injury or additional wear and tear. This MRI was reviewed once again in 2025 after Horwitz underwent a new MRI when he informed the Pirates he was experiencing discomfort in his right wrist.
“The MRI that was taken when he went to see Dr. [Thomas] Graham, most recently, showed an injury to the tendon that had not been there in the last MRI that had been taken while he was still a Blue Jay,” Cherington told reporters Friday. “So sometime in between the acquisition and when he went to see Dr. Graham, this thing happened, so we don’t know for sure exactly how that happened. It would be speculation. It was clear to us, based on the information we got and from Dr. Graham, that somehow it occurred during the time in the offseason.”
A new injury?
Cherington said Wednesday that Horwitz informed the team he was experiencing discomfort not long after PiratesFest, which took place on Jan. 18-19.
“At some point, he reached out to us and said, ‘Hey, it’s not feeling right,’ ” Cherington said. “ ... Then there was a period of back and forth with him, and let’s give it a few days, and it still wasn’t feeling great. At that point, we decided to get him back to see Dr. Graham, who had treated him before for something else while he was with the Blue Jays, and a new MRI showed something that Graham felt, clearly, needed surgery.”
Horwitz said he originally believed his injury was a continuation of the issues he had gone through in the past. However, he told the Post-Gazette that his doctor explained otherwise.
“The way Dr. Graham explained it to me was, ‘It’s the same guy, same wrist, but it’s two inches away [from the area of chronic pain], and that’s almost 100 miles away in the wrist,’ ” Horwitz said. “The way it happened, I was just going through my offseason hitting, my offseason progression, the typical one I do, and something didn’t feel right. I thought it was the normal chronic wrist issues, but upon seeing Dr. Graham and the MRI, we learned that it was something different.”
Progress update
So what now? The Pirates announced Wednesday that Horwitz was expected to return in six to eight weeks. Cherington then clarified on Friday the timetable was for his return to game play, not baseball activity.
“Clearly, we want to stay away from specific dates this early on in the recovery, but that would be a back-in-games timeline, and that’s coming from Dr. Graham and obviously in consultation with our group,” Cherington said. “So we would anticipate, barring something unforeseen, that he’s doing baseball activity well before that. Six to eight weeks is more of a game estimation.”
While unable to participate in drills during the past week, Horwitz has remained present at Pirate City, often seen chatting with teammates on the field during batting practice. Horwitz was in positive spirits when he spoke with the Post-Gazette on Sunday afternoon, saying he is encouraged with the early steps of his recovery.
“Feel great,” Horwitz said. “Obviously not how I wanted to start my Pirate career, but yeah, so far so good. We’re 12 days post-op. Stitches are coming out Monday. It’s exciting. ...
“I trust the medical staff here, and we’re off to a great start. I really don’t know what’s going to be the biggest challenge, but I’m gnawing at the bit to get back.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.