With MLB hoping to return soon, the Post-Gazette’s Jason Mackey and Mike Persak will analyze 20 issues related to the Pirates — think 20 Thoughts or questions about the team. They’ll run each weekday online through May 22 and will appear in print (or via other PG digital platforms) on Sunday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday and Friday.
To predict the impact Ke’Bryan Hayes could have on the Pirates, some roster projection needs to be done.
For 2020 specifically, even without possible MLB roster expansion amid the COVID-19 pandemic, the 23-year-old third baseman had a pretty good shot of making the big league roster at some point during the season. Now, that may be even more true.
The problem, though, is that Hayes is barred from substantial playing time by the Pirates’ current everyday third baseman, Colin Moran. And while Moran has his limitations, namely on the defensive side, he was a valuable hitter in 2019, slashing .277/.322/.429, finishing second on the team with 80 RBIs and hitting 13 homers over 149 games.
Those aforementioned fielding limitations loom large, though. Moran was worth minus-21 defensive runs saved last season, tied for the worst on the team.
Hayes, as of right now, seems to be somewhat of Moran’s inverse. His strength has always been his ability in the field. Fangraphs currently has him as the 30th-ranked prospect in MLB, and his fielding is the highest projected skill he has. Over 899 innings in Class AAA Indianapolis last season, he committed just three errors.
Read More
On offense, Hayes is fairly comparable to Moran in terms of power. Moran’s isolated power numbers the last two seasons were .130 and .152, respectively; Hayes’ were .150 and .151. And even though Hayes doesn’t hit a ton of homers, he does hit plenty of doubles, finishing second on his team with 30 last year, but his on-base percentage and batting average leave something to be desired. That’s especially true, since when he gets on base, he’s a threat to steal another. He totaled as many as 27 swipes in a season back in 2017 with Class A Bradenton.
Still, Moran’s experience, having proven his ability with the bat at the major league level, likely puts him in the everyday third-baseman spot to begin 2020. The Post-Gazette’s Jason Mackey outlined how Moran might fit into the Pirates’ plans if a designated hitter is implemented this season, but for the purposes of this article, let’s not get too deep into the weeds on players who aren’t Hayes.
After all, we’re talking bigger picture here, what Hayes could eventually turn into down the road. And while Moran is a piece of what the Pirates have for right now, Hayes likely will get every chance to succeed in the coming years.
For the reasons outlined above, Hayes is nearly a lock to be a plus-fielder at third base down the line. BaseballSavant.com, MLB’s advanced scouting website, has a 2020 scouting report on Hayes that reads: “He's consistently brought up in conversations about the best defensive prospects in the game at any position, and he's clearly the best third baseman in the minors, one who will be a Gold Glove contender the minute he joins a big league roster. He has tremendous range, great footwork, plus-hands and a plus-arm to make him the complete package.”
On the raw numbers, one would hope for a little better from Hayes in the batter’s box, but there were encouraging signs at the end of 2019. Hayes missed some time in late June due to a fractured index finger. When he came back, he hit .255 in July before exploding in August, slashing .327/.379/.452 over the last month of the season.
The power aspect is only a problem in that teams traditionally expect more of a home run threat from their corner infielders. If Hayes were surrounded in a lineup by other guys who did possess the power he lacks, then it wouldn’t matter as much. That hasn’t been the case for the Pirates, though, who finished 27th and 25th in home runs in 2019 and 2018, respectively. Basically, they need all hands on deck in that department.
But part of Hayes’ deal is that you’ll have to accept what he can give you at the plate — which still projects to be solid production, if not a lot of balls hit into the outfield stands — because the whole package is so good.
For his part, Hayes did speak last season about the step up from Class AA to Class AAA, specifically about how the pitching is harder to pick up at times. That was right after his injury. Things seemed a bit easier for him by the end of the year.
The hope would be that Hayes can repeat that quick learning curve in the majors, but that leap is a completely different animal.
The key for Hayes may be how he deals with acclimating amid high expectations. With where the Pirates currently stand, fans are understandably hungry for the young talent in the Pirates’ farm system to grow up fast and make an impact soon. Those expectations have a way of outreaching what is realistic.
The good news is that, despite Hayes’ early-season struggles in 2019, he hasn’t had a substantial, statistical drop off in his season statistics yet. His .261 average in 2019 was the lowest of his professional career, but it’s only two points lower than his next-worst year.
There will surely be growing pains, and that is understandable, but Hayes and the Pirates alike will need to stay patient to make sure any pressure on the highest-ranked prospect in the organization doesn’t have a negative, lasting affect.
After all, he’s that highly ranked for a reason. If all goes well, he will be manning the hot corner in Pittsburgh for years to come.
STATISTICALLY SPEAKING: In three of his five minor league seasons, Hayes made the All-Star team for the respective league in which he was playing.
KNOW THIS: In the 2015 draft, the Pirates selected Kevin Newman, Hayes and Adam Frazier with their first three picks.
THEY SAID IT: ”I feel close [to making the major leagues], but at the same time, you have to think as if you’re far away. You’re always trying to get better every day.” — Hayes

Mike Persak: mpersak@post-gazette.com and Twitter @MikeDPersak






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.