With MLB hoping to return soon, the Post-Gazette’s Jason Mackey and Mike Persak will analyze 20 issues related to the Pirates — think 20 Thoughts or questions about the team. They’ll run each weekday online through May 22 and will appear in print (or via other PG digital platforms) on Sunday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday and Friday.

Outside of the million-dollar one that almost always involves owner Bob Nutting’s wallet, there may not be a more pertinent Pirates question right now than this: How can their starting pitchers improve upon what turned out to be a disastrous 2019?

Josh Bell is a legitimate MLB star. Bryan Reynolds and Kevin Newman are solid young players who enjoyed terrific rookie seasons. There’s even some infield talent coming down the pike, while the bullpen could be primed for a bounce-back year.

But for the Pirates to win more than 69 games and take a significant step forward in Derek Shelton’s first season as manager, their starting pitchers simply have to be better. The interesting question is how they could potentially go about doing that.

Advertise with us

Plenty of groundwork was laid during spring training, as new pitching coach Oscar Marin implemented an approach that relied more on analytics and technology than the Pirates had in the past. He and bullpen coach Justin Meccage also seemingly won over the trust of their pitchers.

“Oscar wants us to be the best version of ourselves,” Trevor Williams said. “For one person, it might be diving into the numbers more. For another, it might be focusing on your delivery. For a third, it might be repertoire.

“I think everybody can be a lot better than they were last year.”

For Williams, that means being more consistent with his delivery. Williams overlooked too many “red flags” in his return from a right-side strain, which in layman’s terms meant his delivery became entirely too inconsistent, the lapses producing costly mistake pitches.

It’s why Williams’ 2018 and 2019 seasons look almost nothing alike, where his ERA went from 3.11 to 5.38; his rate of home runs per nine innings more than doubled, jumping from 0.8 to 1.7; and he was worth just 0.5 WAR, a huge drop from 4.0 the year before.

Advertise with us

Williams also had a rough season against left-handers. They hit .332 against him and had an OPS .944 compared to career marks of .279 and .775, respectively.

The Pirates will also need Mitch Keller to pitch how he’s capable — as a future ace of the staff. Keller has the velocity and stuff. Now he just has to put it all together, and that seemed to arrive during spring training.

“I feel way better this year,” Keller said. “I’m more comfortable with my surroundings, the guys and being able to be who I am, not trying to be anybody else. I feel like I belong now.”

Keller is certainly due to enjoy a few more breaks this season. Renowned numbers-based website FiveThirtyEight.com did a story back in March on Keller's remarkably unlucky season and made the case that it might have been the most unfortunate in baseball history.

Among starting pitchers between 1900-2019 who logged at least 40 innings, Keller had the highest batting average against on balls in play (BABIP). Keller’s BABIP was an astounding .475. Second-worst was Trevor Rosenthal with the Cardinals in 2016 (.425). The MLB average last season was .298.

Advertise with us

Failing to turn batted balls into outs was also a team trend, as the Pirates had the National League’s highest BABIP (.315) and the second-worst such mark in all of baseball behind the Tigers (.317).

Keller flipping his fortunes will be important, and he could do that by diversifying his pitch mix. Among starters who logged at least 40 innings in 2019, only six threw four-seam fastballs more frequently than Keller (59.4%), who actually has two above-average spin pitches.

While Keller would be wise to lay off his four-seamer some, Chris Archer was better served by relying on it along with his slider, which was good enough for a career-best whiff rate of 42.2% in 2019.

Archer has talked about thinking less and leaning more on his natural ability. That seems to be a wise move, along with Marin’s directive for Archer to be a little athletic in his movements off the mound.

Like Williams, Archer will also have to address some of his untimely misses, as he endured a career-high home run rate (1.9 per nine) in 2019.

Advertise with us

But with the new group in charge, it’s possible no pitcher stands to benefit more from the Pirates’ updated approach than Archer, who has been miscast and basically wasted in his Pittsburgh tenure thus far.

That leaves us with the Pirates’ final two starters, Joe Musgrove and Derek Holland. Musgrove has been working on hiding the ball better, a mechanical tweak he started to make last season and one that led to a 2.89 ERA and 32 strikeouts compared to five walks over his final five starts.

Holland scuffled while pitching for the Cubs and Giants last season, producing a 6.08 ERA. But from what we saw in spring, the left-hander had cleaned up his mechanics, improved the location of his sinker — which he throws between 55-60% of the time — and flashed the ability to get swing-and-miss with his slider.

The Pirates could also have a little bit of rotation depth, which they didn’t have last season, assuming Steven Brault and Chad Kuhl are healthy and able to contribute.

STATISTICALLY SPEAKING: Pirates pitchers threw fastballs 57.4% of the time in 2019. Only the Atlanta Braves (59.0) relied on the pitch more.

Advertise with us

KNOW THIS: The Pirates actually had the best ERA in the National League through April of last season (3.15).

HE SAID IT: "If you’re doing something well, you should do more of it. That’s something I truly believe in. There is room for improvements with some things, but those are things that we’re going to figure out together as we go along.” — Marin on his overall philosophy with the group.

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.