The emerging theme of the Pirates’ season is resilience. The club has played close to .500 ball through the first month and change despite a rash of injuries, giving many hope that it can make some type of run if it can get everyone healthy at some point.

The stats tell a bit of a different story. They reflect a team that’s able to weather injuries not because backups are performing unexpectedly well in place of starters, but because the guys they’re replacing weren't particularly special in the first place. The roster is, more or less, an amalgam of interchangeable parts.

The easiest way to illustrate this phenomenon is the wins above replacement, or WAR stat, an estimate of a player’s total contributions to a team on offense and defense, measured in wins. It’s not a perfect stat by any means, but for the purposes of explaining the Pirates’ season to this point, it does a nice job of quantifying rough value.

Or in the Pirates’ case, a lack thereof.

Advertise with us

Through Sunday, Josh Bell leads position players this year with a total value of 0.8 WAR, according to Fangraphs. Outfielders Melky Cabrera and Bryan Reynolds are the only players who join him at a half-win of value or more.

Everyone else falls between 0.2 and -0.3. Functionally replacement level, defined as production that could be easily acquired from the minor leagues or other sources. That is a lot of mediocrity, especially in comparison to NL Central division peers.

The Milwaukee Brewers, for example, have gotten the production of roughly six Josh Bells in four players. Christian Yelich, Yasmani Grandal, Mike Moustakas and Lorenzo Cain have produced a combined 5.3 WAR. That is nine times the production of the Pirates’ entire roster of position players.

It’s a similar story in St. Louis. Paul DeJong more than triples Bell’s production with 2.5 WAR, and he has six other teammates at 0.6 or higher.

Division-leading Chicago doesn’t have anyone north of 2.0, but its roster is deep, with seven players at 0.6 WAR or higher.

Advertise with us

Overall, the Pirates have the smallest spread between their WAR leader and basement dweller at 1.1. That range is much smaller than that of the Brewers (3.1), Cardinals (2.7), Cubs (2.0) and Cincinnati Reds (1.8.)

It’s worth noting at this point that proven Pirates veterans could have better numbers with more opportunity. Outfielders Corey Dickerson, Starling Marte and Gregory Polanco have all missed significant time this season, and you’d expect them to be better than replacement level otherwise, as they all finished at 2.5 WAR or better last season.

How much better is debatable, though. It’s far from a sure thing that they’d be further ahead than, say, Cabrera and Reynolds, the guys who’ve filled in for them.

The recent attrition in the pitching staff could prove to be a different story. Starter Jameson Taillon was the team’s WAR leader at 3.8 in 2018, and he’ll be replaced by Steven Brault and/or Nick Kingham, who both finished last season at -0.3, an eerie sign for the 0.5 WAR spread between Taillon and Kingham this year.

Then again, purported No. 2 starter Chris Archer — also on the injured list for now — hasn’t been anything special. He was at 0.2 WAR, the same mark as Kingham despite pitching more than double the number of innings.

Advertise with us

It’s a wash. The same is true in the bullpen, where no one beyond Francisco Liriano — injured or healthy — has produced more than 0.3 WAR; and at shortstop, where Cole Tucker’s -0.2 WAR puts him in a league with the guys he replaced, Kevin Newman (0.0) and Erik Gonzalez (-0.1.)

In that context, there’s a good argument to be made that Taillon’s injury is the only one that’s truly mattered in the big picture, and its fallout lies ahead of the team, not behind it.

Everything else has been what you’d expect a team projected to finish in the .500 range would do — exchange unremarkable talents for each other all summer long.

Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24.