The Pirates have spent the past two weeks having to defend last summer’s trade for Chris Archer. The thinking is that the Pirates got “fleeced” because the three principal components to the trade have gone in different directions. Archer has, for the most part, under-performed given the expectations for him while Tyler Glasnow and Austin Meadows have both thrived in Tampa.
Neal Huntington was at it again Sunday during a media session in which he was asked about the trade and how lopsided it seems. Huntington said that he is happy for Glasnow and tips his cap to the Tampa staff for finding the right adjustments to bring the best out of him.
“People miss in baseball trades,” Huntington told the gathered media. “Neither GM goes into the trade hoping to fleece the other team. When fleecing trades happen, it’s more often because a player takes a step forward or a player regresses.”
I get it, the trade looks extremely one-sided at this point. But Huntington, who doesn’t need me to defend him, is correct. The idea that one side or the other got “fleeced” is usually based on hindsight.
The overwhelming majority of people out there thought the Pirates did the right thing by going out and getting an established starter like Archer. There were a few who moaned about giving up Meadows, but Glasnow was considered damaged goods and largely a bust and most fans offered to drive the bus to take him out of town.
One can make the argument that Archer, based on his last three seasons, was not the right pitcher for the Pirates to spend that much prospect-capital on. Archer had become a slightly above-average pitcher, his numbers had flat-lined and he was just not living up to his reputation.
Read More
The flip side of that is he was in the American League East, which is tough on pitchers, he still had great stuff and may just have needed a little bit of a change of scenery to get back on track. And if the Pirates were going to bet on a pitcher to make a strong comeback, why not go after one with Archer’s arm and stuff?
Regardless, the Pirates may have given up a little too much to get Archer, but the trade was necessary. Glasnow was going nowhere and the Pirates needed a veteran pitcher that was under control for a few years to help solidify their rotation, which is still loaded with younger pitchers.
The bottom line is the Archer deal — at the time it was made — was not a bad one for the Pirates. Nobody could see Glasnow turning into the second coming of Roger Clemens. The Pirates had, and still have, outfield depth in the minors and two starting outfielders signed for a few more years each, so Meadows was somewhat expendable.
I’ve read different scouts and general managers suggest the Pirates gave up way too early on a young power arm like Glasnow. That may be true, but there was nothing we saw from him in his 2½ seasons here that suggested he was ever going to figure it out. The Pirates were trying to get something for him before it was four years into his career and his value was greatly diminished.
Huntington said that instead of ripping the Pirates for not being able to figure out how to unlock Glasnow, people should instead give the Rays credit. That’s especially true considering there are plenty of examples of players who struggled elsewhere but thrived under the direction of Ray Searage and company.
“Tip of the cap to them for the adjustments they’ve made,” Huntington said. “Tip of the cap to Tampa to figure out how to get them to make those adjustments. If you are afraid to trade players that are going to be good elsewhere, then you’re never going to trade as a general manager. That’s not a good way to go about it, either.”
The best part of that entire quote is at the end because the Pirates did break protocol and trade high-level prospects for an established player. That isn’t the way they have usually operated, but hopefully this Archer trade won’t stop them from making this kind of deal again in the future.
The Pirates need to be a little more bold in the moves they make and they need to stop being so afraid of these kinds of trades. Archer can still turn it around and become the pitcher they hoped he’d be, and that could change the way the trade is perceived. The Pirates didn’t do anything wrong in trading for him no matter what the public perception — with the benefit of hindsight — has to say about it.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.