Greetings and welcome to the home opener edition of the Pirates mailbag. You can submit questions to Nubyjas and me on Twitter, @BrinkPG and @nwilborn19, or via e-mail, bbrink@post-gazette.com and nwilborn@post-gazette.com.
Q: Bill. Is it a coincidence that the Bucs are failing miserably once again at converting someone to first base? Is it something in their development staff? It can’t be this hard.
— @JordanO_21
A: There are shades of Pedro Alvarez with Josh Bell, aren’t there? The difference is that the Pirates moved Bell there out of foresight, knowing he would not have a spot in the outfield with McCutchen, Marte and Polanco, knowing they didn’t have great first-base options, and hoping to carve a path to the lineup. Alvarez’s throwing issues forced the Pirates to move him there.
But the defensive issues are similar. Bell struggles to throw accurately, as did Alvarez. Bell also struggles to field the position. Both challenges were on display during the opening series in Cincinnati. Bell bobbled a ball, allowing a runner to reach base. Later in the inning he fielded a hard grounder, then threw slightly wide of second base to begin a rundown, then was not in position to complete the rundown. Neither cost the Pirates a run, but they forced Jameson Taillon to throw some extra pitches.
I don’t think the Pirates are unable to convert players to third base, but I do think learning the position is challenging. As Ron Washington said in “Moneyball,” when he and Billy Beane were trying to convince Scott Hatteberg to play there, “It’s incredibly hard.” And it is certainly not for lack of work. Bell, to his credit, has worked hard to learn the position, but it has not translated as he and the Pirates would have hoped.
Read More
Q: Will Ke’Bryan Hayes and Cole Tucker be the starting left side of the Pirates infield in the second half of 2019?
— @ThomasZielke
A: To me, this depends on where they are in the standings. If they’re in it, and Jung Ho Kang is producing, he will probably stay at third base. I find it more likely that Tucker continues to improve and gets a chance to play ahead of Erik Gonzalez, but it’s too soon to make a judgment on Gonzalez one way or another.
If the Pirates are out of it, they could try to move Kang, who is a free agent after this season and whom they hypothetically don’t need with Hayes in place. Moving Kang, though, could be hard, because if he’s good enough to bring value, he will probably be more valuable to the Pirates than another team, and other teams might not want to acquire him because of his off-field issues, which include DUIs and a sexual assault allegation (which has not resulted in charges).
I see this as more likely in September, or 2020. The moving parts of injuries, contention and performance make it hard to predict at this point.
Q: Any chance we can sign Evan Gattis to fill in at Catcher/OF/1B?
— @BrunoGarrett1
A: No doubt Gattis can mash: He hit 21 or more home runs in five of his six major league seasons, including 32 in 2016. But he’s 32 and appeared at catcher in only two games last season, starting neither of them. He’s started only five games at first base in his major league career. He’s not a strong defender when he is on the field, and is more suited to DH at this point. He was brutal as an outfielder — minus-10 Defensive Runs Saved in 2013, minus-4 in ’15 — and he hasn’t played there since. He doesn’t really solve any of the Pirates’ problems.
Bill Brink: bbrink@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrinkPG.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.