CINCINNATI- Pirates general manager Neal Huntington elaborated on his comments made on Thursday in defense of first baseman Josh Bell. Sports Illustrated posted comments from an anonymous scout on March 19 in the magazine's baseball preview session. The author skewered Bell along with other players and Huntington didn't like the racist undertones in the scout's critique.

"In reading the anonymous scouts evaluation, I had a few concerns. One, the clickbait, controversy stirring attempt of the questions," Huntington said. Two, the crushing inaccuracies in some of the reports. For example talking about (Texas Rangers reliever) José Leclerc as a soft-tossing lefty when he’s a right-hander with power, missing players on wrong clubs. So, the credibility was crushed."

Huntington is normally very careful with his words and is normally succint. On Sunday the general manager was intentionally verbose in his response to the offensive article.

"The anonymous reports were more personal attacks than they were useful, helpful analysis of tools and abilities and how those abilities play. The amateur psycho-babble about players’ drive, makeup, and competitiveness. Unfortunately, so much of the information from the anonymous scouts appears to be based on archaic, racist stereotypes. The white players tended to be labeled as ‘gritty,’ ‘smart’ and ‘tough.’ Minority players seemed to be labeled as physically talented but maybe not the most talented or they had their work ethic or motivation repeatedly questioned."

Advertise with us

"So much of it, unfortunately, seemed to be based on archaic, racist stereotypes, which don’t have a place in our game. My rant was primarily against archaic, racist stereotypes. They don’t have a place in our game. That preview just reinforced that they still exist and there still is a lot of work to do to rid those, not only from our game but ideally from our society."

Assuming that the scout was real and verified this type of analysis would likely show up in reports he or she has sent to teams. Huntington is working to make sure Pirates scouts aren't using what he believes to be lazy language.

"Don’t tolerate that language within your organization. Don’t tolerate those stereotypes within your organization," Huntington said." I jokingly thought we should replay Key and Peele's Super Bowl preview of their skit, it’s one of the funnier things I’ve seen and it’s horribly accurate. Maybe we should play that at our next organizational meeting and say, ‘If you find yourself using this language, just stop.’ "

The 2015 skit featured an announcer refer to New England Patriots quarterback Tom Brady as 'cerebral' and Seattle Seahawks Richard Sherman cornerback as '"physically gifted". Of course, when it was noted by the other broadcasters that Sherman was a Stanford alum, the announcer used another dog whistle and called him articulate.

Oftentimes minorities are referred to as articulate when they're intelligent. It is a backhanded compliment based on the assumption that minorities aren't expected to be well-spoken. While it was a comedic skit, this language makes it into actual scouting reports. Huntington wants to make sure people are aware of the words they use and their impact.

Advertise with us

"I like to think that we’re progressive enough that we don’t allow our people to use that lazy language. I can’t tell you that we’ve never done it. I can’t tell you we’ve never had those conversations," Huntington said. "But it’s not something that we tolerate or we want as part of our group. We want to be better than that. It’s not accurate. IT’s not relevant. In scouting reports, you want accurate information, not generic stereotypes. You don’t want lazy narrative on any player."

As for Bell, he drove in the first run in the Pirates 5-0 win on Sunday. Huntington hasn't yet spoken to Bell about the article.

"I wasn’t sure how big of a story it was going to become. I didn’t want to make it a story because I brought it to their attention," Huntington said. "I hope they know we have their backs and that none of this is accurate and it’s not something we’ll tolerate."

Nubyjas Wilborn: nwilborn@post-gazette.com Twitter: @nwilborn19