CINCINNATI -- Up until about 8:30 p.m. in Houston on Monday, Lonnie Chisenhall was supposed to be the starting right fielder for the Pirates. Chisenhall was brought in during the offseason after spending his entire eight-year career with the Cleveland Indians. The 30-year-old was excited for the opportunity created due to Gregory Polanco not being able to start the season.
Chisenhall's hopes were dashed after getting hit by a pitch in the fourth inning of an exhibition game in Houston. Initially, the team was optimistic about the possibility of Chisenhall playing in Thursdays 5-3 loss against the Reds.
"We had a follow-up exam with additional diagnostics that revealed the fracture," Pirates director of sports medicine Todd Tomczyk said. "He sustained a fracture to the right index finger, the second digit. It, unfortunately, didn't respond to the aggressive treatment the medical staff was providing. At this point in time, Lonnie will be down throwing and hitting with that right finger. We will reassess at that time."
Chisenhall will stay with the team in Cincinnati and continue to work with the medical staff for treatment and work out the lower half of his body with team trainers.
There were reports that Chisenhall would be out four to six weeks with the injury but Tomczyk cautioned against them.
“I think to put a general outline on Lonnie right now is not fair to him, not fair to the injury. Different bones heal different ways," Tomcyzk said. "There’s different degrees and different severities of the breaks. To put four to six weeks, I think, would be inaccurate right now to put that on Lonnie or this particular injury."
Read More
Melky Cabrera played in his place in right field. Cabrera went 0-for-4 with a strikeout before being replaced by Pablo Reyes in the eighth inning. Before the game, Pirates manager Clint Hurdle alluded to the possibility of Reyes or JB Shuck getting time at right field until Chisenhall is back.
"We have three men that can go out there and take it," Hurdle said. "We have a lot of confidence in Melky getting the first opportunity. JB Shuck can go there or Reyes can go there. We have some options on how we want to use Melky late in the games. If we want to run for him or play defense for him, we can use Shuck or Reyes in either situation. Melky is a switch-hitter, but we have to mindful of his usage."
Hurdle said he likes to give players their first opportunity to play early on. He ended up playing Shuck earlier than expected. Starling Marte was a late scratch with a migraine headache. Monday already changed things for Shuck. If Chisenhall hadn’t gotten hit by the pitch, Shuck wouldn’t have made the trip to Great American Ball Park. He would've flown back to Pirate City. Instead, he wound up starting in center field and had two walks in the game.
"It was a bit of a whirlwind. I found out after [batting practice] today," Shuck said. "It was pretty cool to get a start on opening day. You never want anyone to get injured. But it was really neat to play. Now I can say I got to play on opening day."
Shuck is from Westerville, Ohio, which is a little under two hours from Cincinnati. His family was planning on coming up for the games on Saturday and Sunday. The announcement was made about 40 minutes before first pitch and there wasn't enough time for them to make the drive.
Shuck got to know Chisenhall during his 2014 season with the Cleveland Indians. It was Shuck's first opening day start and fourth opening day. Because of the friendship that they share it was somewhat bittersweet for Shuck.
"You never want to see anyone get injured. Lonnie is a good friend of mine, so that makes it a little bit harder," Shuck said. "I'm looking forward to helping the team, however I can. If it's for a short time, a month or whatever it is I'm going to help out however I can."
Chisenhall's injury took Hurdle back to his playing days. Hurdle, a member of the Reds in 1982, rolled his ankle during pregame workouts on opening day. He still played on it and ended up playing only 19 games for the Reds that season.
"For Lonnie, there's a disappointment," Hurdle said. "There needs to be emotion. It's real. I think you need to work through it. To say it's not there or deny it or push it to the side isn't healthy. There are psychologists that will tell you that you need to feel what you need to feel. Then you close the book and focus on the recovery and rehab."
Chisenhall will keep working to come back and the Pirates will move on to Saturday's game against the Reds. The off-day could provide Marte enough time to heal from the migraine. If not, Shuck would likely start again. This time his family will be there.
Nubyjas Wilborn: nwilborn@post-gazette.com Twitter: @nwilborn19





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.