There seems to be some optimism around the Pirates this year, and that is understandable -— misguided, perhaps, but totally understandable. The Pirates seem to have a great pitching staff, a great bullpen and some good young, hungry players.

I want to jump on that “playoffs, baby” bandwagon so many people seem to be on. I just can’t because I deal in reality; I don’t deal in pie-in-the-sky best-case scenarios. I don’t deal in the “what if everything goes right” and, for the record, I don’t deal in the world of “what if everything goes wrong,” either.

The Pirates have a competitive baseball team. They are better than the bad teams. They are not as good as the top teams and they are somewhere near the top of that pack of teams in middle. Their pitching will give them a chance to compete and their bullpen will give them a chance to win more than they lose.

That’s still not enough to add up to the 89 or 90 wins it will likely take to return to the playoffs, and nowhere close to enough to get to the 95 or 96 wins it will take to win the National League Central. The Pirates seem to be one or two pieces short of truly being a contender.

Advertise with us

That is why this season is doomed to end in frustration. The Pirates are close, but they still will miss the postseason. And if they miss it by only a few games, the spin from the front office will be, “We were one or two lucky bounces away from the playoffs and you just wait until next year!”

That spin, however, is incorrect. The story of the Pirates’ season should they miss the playoffs by just a few games will be: Had you just spent a few more dollars and shored up one or two more holes, you’d have gotten those extra games and been in the playoffs.

That — the fact that the Pirates’ front office refused to do anything this offseason to upgrade the roster just a little — is why this season is destined to end in frustration for fans. They will look at the $75 million payroll and they will look at the shortstop situation and perhaps the starting rotation and say, “What if?”

That’s not to say this won’t be an exciting team to watch. I do believe they have a lot of good young players, and I do believe they will play an exciting brand of baseball.

People who are high on the Pirates are high on the pitching staff, and they should be. I do believe the Pirates rotation is solid, but it is also a little overrated. The people who are picking the Pirates to win 90-some games are all doing so on the strength of the rotation. They talk about this group as if they are the pitching staffs of the early 1990s Braves, and that’s a bit much to stomach.

Advertise with us

Jameson Taillon and Trevor Williams are both likely to have excellent seasons. Williams will regress a little from what he was in the second half of last season, but he will still be one of the better pitchers in the National League.

After those two, there are plenty of questions on this staff. Chris Archer may be the pitcher we saw in September, but he might also be the one we saw for about the last four seasons, and that’s not a good thing. Joe Musgrove needs to stay healthy and prove he can consistently pitch at a high level. And the fifth spot is a bit of a disaster considering the player brought here to win that spot, Jordan Lyles, will start the season on the IL.

And there is one place where the Pirates could have improved themselves by spending a few extra dollars. They had Ivan Nova under contract but traded him because he made too much money. Nova isn’t a world beater, but he is compared to Lyles, and he would have given the Pirates one of the best fifth starters in the National League.

The shortstop situation is not good enough either, and they could have upgraded that spot had they wanted. The bench is not very deep and the bullpen is probably one injury away from being a lot less impressive.

The Pirates should benefit from an improved infield defense, and I do believe Jung Ho Kang and Josh Bell will both provide legitimate power. But there isn’t quite enough power on this team and they will struggle at times to score runs.

This is going to be another successful season if success is measured in a winning record, though. I predict the Pirates will go 84-78 and that will mark their fifth winning season since 2012. That’s something to feel good about, but it won’t be enough to get the Pirates into the playoffs, and it won’t be enough to validate the front office’s offseason.